No. 4. — "Die Welt" — Page 11.
(continued from page 10)
…now emancipate themselves, because they have the power to do so. A political autonomy is, at bottom, as much as a detachment, a shelling-out, a differentiation from the unitary state into a federal state. All the functions of the centralist state are transferred to the autonomous community. This political autonomy is the first condition for a real cultural-national autonomy. The two kinds of autonomy stand in a reciprocal relation to each other. But as matters now stand in the countries that come into consideration for this question, political self-government is the prius, national self-government the consequence. It is from this point of view that we must also regard the Jewish autonomy movement. National autonomy or political autonomy — which of these two forms is the more attainable, the more desirable for the Jews? One might of course say "both," but that would be no answer with any political meaning. If one makes unclear demands, one receives unintelligible answers, or none at all.
Can the Jews in Austria demand a political autonomy, that is, can they attain it? And if they were to attain it, how would it affect the destinies of the Jews? History can give us the answer. It is by no means a novelty that is now being demanded by the Jews. On the contrary, it is the re-establishment of an old historical tradition which has already fallen into oblivion, like many an interesting piece of ancient Jewish life.
Yes, one must openly confess it, the earth is round and everything returns. What was once a fact wishes to become one again. Most Jews, who have a rather weak historical memory, although Hess had called them the historical people, will probably never have thought of the existence of a regular autonomy of the Jews in the late lamented "Republic" of Poland. And yet it is one of the most interesting chapters of Jewish history. One of the most reviled of Jewish institutions was the so-called "Kahal." This word was a bugbear to all progressive Jews, an object of superstitious fear and of the hatred of the non-Jews. But this "Kahal" was another form — an antiquated one, of course — of the complete autonomy of the Jews.
Although the institution of the "Kahal," that is, the communal system, actually reaches far back into the Middle Ages, it had never and nowhere attained so great and decisive an importance as in Poland. The economic and internal political conditions of the "Rzecz-Pospolita" — as the official name of Poland ran — brought it about that the Jews formed a wholly peculiar class, existing by itself. They were the tiers état, without, however, forming a constituent part of the nation. Being thus a heterogeneous phenomenon, they could not fit into the framework of the political life of the Poles. By force of circumstances they had to attain a special position. And this they found ready to hand, by raising their own communal cell to the rank of a state-recognised organisation. The "Kahal," or the union of the "Kahals," became an institution which formed a factor of the state. The mass of the Jews lived wholly apart, followed their own laws, and came into no contact whatever with the outside world. The Kahal was the representative of the Jews towards the State; the representative of the Kahal was the "parliament," the "Waad Arbo Arozos" — the representative assembly for the Jews of Great Poland (Posen), Little Poland (Cracow), Red Russia (Galicia and Podolia with Volhynia) and Lithuania. This "Waad," which the Polish government officially designated as the "Congressus iudaicus" or as the "Diet" (Sejm), had the most far-reaching powers. It was the real authority for all affairs of the Jewish community. For two centuries this institution flourished, until in the year 1764 it was abolished by law by the Polish Diet and, in consequence of the upheaval in the political conditions of the Polish realm which soon followed — the partition of Poland — was also shattered for ever. The new, centralising Russian government undermined the communal system, the Kahal system, and made any further development of it impossible. A reminiscence of Jewish autonomy, moreover, is the existence of the so-called "political communes" in Moravia, which survived even the reorganisation of 1848, but have gradually fallen into decay.
Had the Kahal not perished, the development of Jewish life would have taken another direction; we should now perhaps stand before an accomplished fact of Jewish autonomy. But it could not be so. The old institution held the Jews together. The political unity was destroyed. The institution broke in two. And new interests approached the Jewish people, drove into its midst like a wedge, dividing, rending.....
But the wind of time is gathering the scattered bones together again. Bone to bone, splinter to splinter. But will a new skeleton be able to form from them? Will this skeleton be covered with skin and flesh and come to life?
The present strivings of the Jews in Austria and Russia, so far as they aim at the attainment of a Jewish autonomy, are a re-linking, perhaps an unconscious one, with the historical tradition. But one does not step twice into the same stream! Even if the outward forms resemble one another, the contents in no case coincide. The conditions under which the Jews now live are fundamentally different from those which made the existence of an autonomy possible, nay, demanded it: the Jews are no longer a homogeneous mass. They no longer form an estate, a closed class. They no longer live from one another and among one another. Their interests are as many-sided as their surroundings, their conditions of life as divided according to economic rank as those of the other peoples. Formerly they were a hermetically sealed mass. Now the osmosis and the diastole are too great.
Can the Jews, then, under the present circumstances, that is, living among host peoples, as town-dwellers, with the rural population of the great non-Jewish majority as a wedge between them, lead an autonomous political life? We have questioned the past; let us now hear the present. —
A. Cor.
"WITH FIRE AND SWORD"
A few months ago I heard for the first time in my life that an antagonism existed between the Poles of Galicia and their Jewish fellow-citizens of Zionist colouring. For when, on the occasion of a short stay in Lemberg, I asked a distinguished and deserving Zionist whether he would not stand for a seat at the next elections to the Reichsrat, he said hesitatingly that it would make him proud and happy to be sent to the Reichsrat by the Jews of Galicia, but ...
I: Is a candidature on your part so hopeless?
He: Perhaps not that. I have often spoken at meetings and sometimes made a great impression; the Zionist creed lies deeper in the hearts of our kinsmen than people think. So there is indeed a prospect ...
I: Well then!
He: I have thought about the point more than once
