Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 6 · 9 February 1906
7printed page
scan 5 of 24

No. 6 — "Die Welt" — 7

(continued from page 6)

…be able to help — for, and this is indeed the fundamental thesis of the "Woschod" and of "liberal" Russian Jewry — the Russian Jewish question can be solved only in Russia. We heard these words long before the Russian Revolution. Since the reign of Alexander II they have been repeated to the point of weariness. Alexander III came, and with him the time of terror. The "Woschod" and its following in Russia, the politics-shy philanthropists of Western Europe, sang in touching harmony the song of the future, the song of a free Russia. Anti-revolutionary and bourgeois at the bottom of their souls, they listened with suspense to the thundering battle-strains of the Russian Marseillaise. . . . "Let us shake the dust from our feet, the dust of an old world; hateful to us are the golden idols, and hateful the despot's palace" . . . And they heard the approach of the coming storm, and they hoped. The storm came. It raged as no storm of revolution has ever raged — it rages still. It was a struggle of life and death, but a barren one. No revolution has lasted so long, no Moloch has demanded so many victims. And when we draw up the balance, when we now hear the voices of those Jewish circles which formerly expected everything of the Revolution, we hear a tremor in their voices; their answers are vague, indefinite. They have not been able to grasp the peculiar phenomenon of Russian life; perhaps they have never understood Russian history.

And now, after the Revolution, Count Sergei Yulievich Witte, who is the hope of all Jewish Liberals, sits and looks on idly while in Homel, in Chodorkow, in Berschad, in many other towns of the Rayon, a brutalised soldiery in league with the police demolishes Jewish houses and murders Jewish men and women. Count Witte and his Government have postponed the Jewish question ad calendas graecas. Let but the Duma assemble. . . But the Duma cannot assemble. Dark powers are working against it. The Reaction wants no Duma at all; the Revolution wants no such Duma. The one party, the "Blacks," will probably boycott the Duma because they desire autocracy; the others, Constitutionalists and Radicals of every shade, will boycott it because they recognise only a Duma elected on the basis of the "four-storeyed" formula. The one pulls the cart of State to the left, the other to the right — and the cart is still stuck in the mire. Can anything be expected for the Jews from such a revolution? Can the proletarianisation of the masses, the impoverishment of the middle class of the Jewish population, in any way be checked by the victory of the Revolution? . . . A strong wave of despair has seized upon Russia. A depressed mood prevails in the land. A darkness, upon which the flames of the Jewish pogroms or of the "pacification" of the Baltic provinces cast a flaring, horrifying light. . . .

It is a revolution without beauty. "Our revolution," a Russian publicist wrote lately in the "Novosti," — "proceeds in just the same manner as our whole philistine vegetating. It passes by like a dark nightmare. There is much heroism in it, but no heroes; many fighters, but no leaders; much madness, but no enthusiasm. . . We hear on all sides that the Russian Revolution is the crest of an immense wave which will sweep away the old social order and shake the whole world. What an aberration! Our revolution is a revolution out of books, and therefore it will bring nothing great. . . . Our revolution does not carry Europe away, because it has no beautiful enthusiasm; it frightens like a tragedy, it repels like a nightmare." . . .

Perhaps this despair is premature. But in a land where, even while the iron is hot, such outbursts of dull despair — more than justified by reality — are possible, in a land where the idea of freedom, of personality, has no soil, — the fruit of the world's freedom cannot grow, the great world-questions cannot be solved.

The Jewish question is a world-question. The Jewish question is not a national question such as the Polish or the Lettish. It is more than that. Those peoples need merely to be rehabilitated; we must create new conditions, new circumstances of life. The question of the other nationalities in Russia will be solved as soon as their autonomy is recognised. To us no autonomy will be granted. . . . Count Witte has already made haste, as the "Times" is able to report, to forbid the "Congress of the Jews," i. e. the projected Jewish Diet which was to have given expression to the national constitution of Russian Jewry. And even had this Diet come about! What could it have accomplished, what could it have effected? Speeches would have been made — but speeches are no protection against pogroms, against impoverishment. There is arising within Russian Jewry an immense problem, graver still than that of the want of rights: that is the proletarianisation of the masses. From the standpoint of economic materialism it is perhaps desirable; from the standpoint of Jewish life it is a catastrophic phenomenon. Our friend Dr. Kellner has aptly remarked it in one of his aphorisms: "The greatest crisis in the Judaism of most recent times is not the Enlightenment, nor yet antisemitism, but the rise of the great cities." . . . Jewry is moving towards an economic upheaval, a transformation in which it has broken the old forms but has not yet found new ones. And this problem the representatives of Marxism among the Jews have already perceived — with the exception of the "Bund." So too the "Itoists," who built their whole theory upon it. Only Mr. Lucien Wolf, who speaks of all things with the enviable assurance of a dilettante, does not know it, and expresses — in the name of the Ito — his opinion that the Russian Jewish question will be solved in Russia itself. If the Ito stands on Mr. Wolf's ground, where then is its right to exist to be sought?

No — the Jewish question cannot be solved in Russia, not even the Russo-Jewish one. If the Revolution has as yet produced nothing positive, it has forced this recognition upon all who will and can understand. —


ON THE QUESTION OF AUTONOMY.

II.

A glance at the history of our people has shown us that the autonomy movement is no new phenomenon, that it is rather a regression, a return to conditions of life and society which were once already a reality. The word "regression" is meant to contain no reproach and no judgment. The forms of life are not so manifold and inexhaustible as might appear; they move in a circle. From a given premise the same conclusion regularly follows. Questions of a political nature are often mistakenly judged by their ethical, ideal value. The Liberals of the old school cannot hear certain words, such as "national," "struggle," etc., without discomfort. They judge phenomena not by their real worth but by the degree of their kinship with the humanistic ideals. In no small part this moralising conception of political questions is a contributory cause of the dismissive