8 — "Die Welt" — No. 6
(continued from page 7)
…attitude of our liberal Jews towards Jewish-national endeavours of every kind. But it is a misunderstanding on the part of the Liberals; it is a doctrinaire clinging to words and formulas; it is a freezing in the ice of concepts. If we wish here to illuminate the question of Jewish autonomy from this standpoint as well, it is for the reason that, by the light of the contrast between our conception and the liberal one, the nature of the question will become clearer to us. It is perhaps a tilting at windmills, for the Liberal party has now lost all power and all standing, and liberal Jewry most of all. But we do not wish to take the word "liberal" in its narrow party sense. "Liberal" is a general concept, one above party. But because it is too general, because it is merely a scheme, a "method," this concept can embody itself only in other, more limited but for that very reason more definite and clearer forms. And one of these forms is Democracy, to which the world belongs, the present and the future. Democracy stands to Liberalism as Deuteronomy to the Decalogue; it is its amplification, its commentary. "Equal rights for all" — says the Hillel of Liberalism, "all the rest learn for yourself." And what is this "all the rest"? This amplification and elucidation the programme of Democracy offers us. Whereas Liberalism speaks of the individual, of man in himself, Democracy extends the sphere of its concepts to peoples and community as well. And it arrives at the principle of nationality, of free nationhood. What does nationality mean? A community of men who wish to live freely, according to their own will, by their own determination. "The existence of a nation," Renan once said, "is a plebiscite continued day by day" (Renan: Qu'est ce qu'une nation? Paris 1882). It is of course a paradoxical and one-sided assertion. A people lives not merely because it wills, but because it must. An individual can do as he pleases with his life; a people has no will over itself. But one thing is certain: the more developed a people is, the higher, the more cultivated, the more mature the individuals who are its constituent parts, the sooner can one speak of a free nation consciously striving for independence. Fichte once said it in his classic, lapidary language: "There must be a law determining at what stage of culture men no longer form themselves into a new people! . . . . When being-a-people has already entered into their natural being and consciousness." — Once a people has reached this stage, every violation of its national individuality would also be a violation of the principles of freedom, of Democracy. Democracy and national development are inseparable. This we were told some half a century ago by the grand master of European Democracy, Ferdinand Lassalle: "However much men may differ as to the special content of the concept of Democracy," he says ("Der italienische Krieg"), "all democratic factions will unite in this, that this concept, reduced to its most general expression, means nothing other than: autonomy, the self-legislation of the people within. . . . . The principle of free, independent nationalities is therefore the basis and the source, the mother and the root of Democracy as such. Democracy cannot trample the principle of nationalities underfoot without suicidally laying hands on its own existence, without depriving itself of every ground of theoretical justification, without betraying itself in principle and from the very foundation."
When Lassalle wrote these words, national consciousness had not yet grown strong to so high a degree as is now the case. The Socialists of the second half of the last century even dreamed of the abolition of all national barriers, the cancelling of all particularities in a higher unity. And that was for them the dialectical development of the idea of nationality. But time has guided development into other paths. Instead of vanishing, the particularities intensified, forced themselves upon the consciousness of the peoples, became a factor of power in politics. Theory followed life. Social Democracy has in this respect radically changed its views; it has become — volens nolens — national. Pernerstorfer is perhaps the sharpest and most decided representative of this idea within the Socialist party. He says: ". . . . All culture is national . . . . Socialism and the national idea are not only no contradictions; they necessarily belong together. Every attempt to weaken the national idea must, if it succeeds, diminish the wealth of the human race . . . . Socialism seeks to organise mankind, not to atomise it . . . ." These views are shared also by other eminent representatives of German Social Democracy, such as David, Calwer, etc.
Thus neither from the standpoint of Liberalism nor from that of Social Democracy can the idea of nationality be attacked or rejected. Why then do the Jewish Liberals and Social Democrats take up so curtly dismissive an attitude towards the idea of Jewish nationality, of Jewish autonomy? We will not speak of those who in cowardice do not wish to "make themselves known." These gentlemen, à la Byk, or the "comrades" of the "Arbeiterzeitung" in Vienna, have indeed no other motives than inner servitude; they are afraid of the light of truth. They prefer to be laughed at and chicaned as Germans or Poles, etc. (in inverted commas), rather than to profess themselves Jews proudly and openly. They are like that hunchback in the well-known anecdote who believed that people did not see his hump so long as he did not tell them of it. They are given over to ridicule. But there are also serious men who, with serious, well-considered motives, come forward against the Jewish national movement and its realisation. They admit the existence of a distinct Jewish character, of a Jewish vernacular. But that, in their opinion, does not suffice for a national life. Be it noted, we are speaking here not of Zionism and its opponents, but of Jewish national autonomy in the countries where they dwell; in Austria and in Russia the waves of this movement run high. In Austria the Jews demand provincial autonomy and Jewish electoral curiae; in Russia they go still further in their demands and dream of a Jewish Diet, of a federative relation to the Russian Empire.
And the curious thing has appeared once more. The very same elements of the Jewish people, Democrats and Socialists, who regard it as self-evident that the old centralist State must give way to the modern decentralised, federative one, who demand autonomy for all the peoples of the earth, grow hesitant as soon as these principles of theirs are applied to Jewish conditions too. The same "Bund" which is for ever speaking of "national self-determination," which has spun out unfathomably deep theories about it, mocks at the idea of a general Jewish organisation on a federative basis. Whence this inconsistency? It is no doubt to be sought in the concept of nationality, which admits of various interpretations and is variously understood. The old concept of the nation was that of uniform descent, religion and language. There are still to-day jurists of constitutional law who do not recognise Hungary and Germany as national States, for whom not the will of the individuals living together, but unity of blood and community of language are the most decisive factors. Thus for them America is no national State. And they are right in so far as they apply the old criterion to the concept of the nation. By this theory it is not difficult to deny the existence of a separate Jewish nationality. For the Jews, after all, have no language of their own! But