No. 13. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
…seekers can have? We mean, that is, not the leaders but the mass. The mass will surely see in this action the vitality of Zionism. Only let the defenders and champions of the resolutions of the Vilna Conference for once declare openly and clearly that they too in fact see in the realisation of the Warburg proposals "an immediate help in a high degree," and do not, together with Herr Ussischkin, demand the alteration of the statutes of the National Fund in the sense of limiting its activity to Palestine to the exclusion of the neighbouring lands. Only then will a ground be prepared for the reconciliation of the opposing views, all the more so as thereby a part of the Zionist ideal itself is in fact realised.
These neighbouring lands belong wholly to Palestine, not merely geographically but economically as well. But whoever does not live merely from hand to mouth, and can cast a glance into the future, still somewhat veiled, understands that the economic advancement of the neighbouring lands must have a great — favourable — influence on the further development of Palestine, while on the other hand practical activity in the neighbouring lands would greatly strengthen Zionism.
In any case we can draw real benefit from this activity only if at the same time we also work in Palestine.
(To be continued.)
Turkish Land Tenure.
By Dr. Leopold Kahn.
Mülk and Miri Land.
III.
As already mentioned earlier, the chief distinction among the categories of land lies in the two legal forms first named, namely: Mülk ground and Miri land. The former is the older, original form; the latter is the later one, which came about historically. The Koran does not yet know the institution of Miri land; for it only Mülk exists. Therefore the legal relations of Mülk grounds with respect to acquisition, and transfer by contract and by inheritance, are governed chiefly by the Koran and ruled by its laws, under which, moreover, they are placed on an outright footing with movable goods and treated like them. The category of Miri land and its legal origin are for the most part to be traced back to the time of Soliman the Great, and since then it has grown steadily in extent, so that the category of Mülk, at least as regards landed estates, is continually dwindling, and nowadays in many provinces forms only a rare exception.
In concept these two categories are sharply distinguished in their nature. Mülk land stands in the complete ownership of a private person. Apart from the restrictions fixed by law out of public regard for the interest of the Treasury and the common weal, such as exist in all other states as well, the owner may dispose of it freely, may sell the Mülk land, encumber it, give it away, make it wakf, and bequeath it both by law and by last-will disposition (by testament). Miri land, properly speaking, belongs as property to the State alone, or, more correctly expressed, the superior ownership of it belongs to the State, and private persons can acquire only rights of possession and usufruct in it. These rights of possession and usufruct may indeed, since they comprise the chief powers of the right of ownership, likewise be sold by the possessor, encumbered, given away, made wakf (the last only under certain restrictions and in respect of certain usufructs), and inherited according to the provisions of the law, but only according to these. A disposition by means of testament is entirely excluded in respect of Miri land. But both the enjoyment and the transfer, of whatever kind, are subject to the control and the approval of the authorities appointed for the purpose. Neither sale nor gift, nor any change in the cultivation of the land concerned, nor the erection of buildings upon it, may take place without the express authorisation of the said authorities. All these restrictions flow from the fact that to the State, more correctly to the State Treasury (beit-ûl-mal), the superior ownership ("rakkaba") is and remains reserved.
Mülk land, like Mülk goods in general, is changed into Miri land by a natural process, namely when, for want of legal and testamentary heirs, it becomes escheated, kaduk (machlul). Miri land too can, in two cases, according to Art. 32 of the Land Law, be converted into Mülk, that is, 1. when a locality, town or village is founded on State domains with the authorisation of the Sultan, 2. by virtue of the procedure of the temlik-i-sahih, that is, a grant of concession with express bestowal of full ownership. This is, as it were, a contract of sale between the Sultan, who counts as owner of all the State domains, on the one hand, and him who is to acquire the land as his full property, as Mülk, on the other. The latter has to pay for it to the beit-ûl-mal¹), the State Treasury, the actual price of the land if it is in a poor condition, but otherwise double its true value, whereupon he receives a written title of ownership, the "temliknamé." Such transactions are, of course, among the very greatest rarities.
Historical: The ambiguous blessing "By thy sword shalt thou live!" which the patriarch Isaac bestowed upon his first-born son Esau, was given by the Emperor Constantine to the Catholic Church as its portion, but was also laid by Mohammed in the cradle of Islam. The Mohammedans, who in accordance with the precepts of the Koran felt themselves called to conquer the whole world for Mohammedanism, and who, after subjugating the north and north-west of the Arabian peninsula, subdued Asia Minor and Palestine in their triumphal march, regarded everyone who did not profess Islam as an enemy, Harbi²), if he would not be converted to Islam. They regarded it as a mercy if they let the obstinate unbeliever live, in return for which he belonged to them with his person and his property.
In the first period, then, in accordance with the Koran, they let Mülk ownership as such stand, and made only the essential distinction that he who accepted the Koran was treated as a brother and had to burden his land only with the tithe. This, naturally, was not something disgraceful, but on the contrary something honour-
¹) Beit-ûl-mal also designates the subsection in the Ministry of Finance which is charged with supervising the inheritances falling to orphans and with collecting heirless estates for the Treasury.
²) Perhaps related to איש חרבי = חרב
