Page 6 — "Die Welt" — No. 12
(continued from page 5)
…self-respect which we possess as Jews, we could not foresee, that a Jew could arrive at such a degree of blindness. It is true that the day on which we had to live to see this will be a day of shame in the history of our German Jewry, and that we shall have much, very much to do, by the common labour of us all, to make good that in which one man has sinned.
But this time it shall not go as at other times, when the sin of one is made a reproach to the entire Jewish people! We know that this initial attempt will everywhere be received with laughter. For at the very last the Professor contrived to forestall, in any event, his arguments being taken seriously, when he plaintively laments how many chairs for the Science of Judaism could be founded with the money of the Colonial Bank! The reader must, on reading that, be seized by a feeling of general and liberating mirth. But the matter touches us more nearly! The shame done to us, in that a Jew wrote this, touches us deep in our hearts! We have but one hope, the hope that this glaring case will open the eyes of thousands who stood aside, that they will perceive whither that road leads, and that henceforth they will go with us on the road which we follow upright and with firm step. Far, infinitely far beyond the borders of our party rings the cry of indignation! May it not die away; rather may men remember this pamphlet of Geiger's and take to heart the warning that lies in it. May those who stand lukewarm towards our great cause beat their breasts and confess to themselves that they share the guilt of this shame. Then in future men of this man's stamp will no longer be able to pose as representatives of German Jews; then the blackest reaction will no longer be suffered to be preached under the flag of Liberalism.
If it comes to that, then this pamphlet of Geiger's will have brought a blessing instead of a curse.
To-day, however, we solemnly protest against this word of Professor Geiger's — not as party men alone — for the shame strikes us not as Zionists but as friends of true freedom and tolerance, without regard to our position on the question of Zionism. We protest against this manner of fighting. We condemn it as unworthy of a Jew, of a German, and of a man of liberal mind. We demand that such a man be shut out for ever there where earnest men strive for truth, for right and for freedom!
Questions of the Day and Points at Issue in Zionism.
By Dr. D. Pasmanik. (Continuation.)
Now, however, there are people who are not merely for Uganda alongside Palestine, but who are simply against Palestine, who make of Territorialism a philosophy of life. Any country, only not Palestine! But whoever has followed the literature of the Russian Zionists more closely knows that this philosophy is of quite recent date and in its nature recalls the philosophy of the fox to whom the grapes hanging too high are too sour. Since they cannot have Palestine at once, they have become Territorialists. Were we to obtain this land to-day, nothing would be left of the new "philosophy of life." It therefore scarcely deserves detailed consideration. We will occupy ourselves here with one single point only, because it is probably of more general significance.
Palestine, some Territorialists assert together with their standard-bearer Mr. Zeitlin of the "Hador" and "Hasman," is the land of reactionary, religious culture, the land of orthodox Rabbinism. But since one wishes to create a modern Judaism, one must have a new land. "The Jewish proletarian cares only for economic interests." It sounds so fine and yet so hollow! I should like to remind the dear opponents of Jewish romanticism of a most real fact, which throws so glaring a light upon the actual feelings of the Jewish proletarian, and that of the most radical, that all declamation must cease. This fact is as follows:
Investigations into the economic condition of the Russian Jews have proved that the Jewish workman finds employment in the factories only with great difficulty, even in the Jewish factories. One of the chief causes of this phenomenon is the Sabbath rest, which is strictly kept by all Jewish proletarians, even by the a-religious and anti-religious workmen who are under the influence of socialist propaganda. Rather starve, but keep the Sabbath rest! In cities such as Warsaw, Lodz, Bialystok, etc., the rabbis have no influence over the proletarians, and yet so much "romanticism"! So the Jewish proletarian does not care merely for "economic interests"! The "Bund," then, despite its propaganda of many years, has not been able to kill Jewish romanticism. No, the Jewish proletarian, who does not merely discuss in the abstract but also feels in the concrete, preserves in his heart the whole romanticism of healthy Judaism. And now, how can people who stand upon the ground of the materialist philosophy believe that the Jewish colonisation of Palestine, which will after all transform the whole economic life of the Jewish people, will nevertheless preserve the ideology of the Golus? Jewish romanticism will remain, but not the romanticism of the enslaved and hunted Jew of the Golus, but rather the proud romanticism of the self-conscious and free Jew, which has always belonged among the highest and most precious possessions of mankind, e.g., the democratic social legislation of the Bible and the highest ethical ideals of the Prophets. And if we now wish for a moment to consider the matter from the standpoint of practical politics, we must surely not leave out of account that the romanticism of a whole people, at any rate of its great majority, is a quite real power with which the most crotchety materialists have to reckon. All the more so, as we have seen that even in the most advanced Jewish proletarian there still lurks a good piece of Jewish romanticism! We need a land which shall possess a special power of attraction for all elements of the Jewish people, so that a vigorous national life might be founded; for a nation is not a class, but embraces all classes.
What land equals Palestine in power of attraction for the whole Jewish people?
A territory will attract only the hungry, even a territory with autonomy, just as America, despite its absolute political freedom, attracts only the poorest among the suffering Russian Jews. But since the poorest are not in a position to found a commonwealth of their own by their own strength, the whole affair will logically turn out to be a philanthropic undertaking. With philanthropy, however, one founds no national commonwealth, no Jewish State. Only Palestine can bring about the harmonious union of Jewish labour, Jewish intelligence and Jewish capital, three elements indispensable to the creation of a national-Jewish commonwealth.