No. 40. — "Die Welt" — Page 13.
(continued from page 12)
…more "stagnating" Zionism is a "monstrous offspring of fantastic vagueness," that the Zionists "falsify" the Jewish idea, — speaks just as calmly, objectively and dispassionately not only of "culpable" misjudgment and disregard, but further also of "monstrous presumption," of "crack-brainedness" and "madness," in order finally, calmly, objectively and dispassionately, to call for the boycott of his Zionist colleagues. It is good to learn in this practical way what Dr. Vogelstein understands by calm, objectivity and dispassion, for in his opinion we still have a very great deal to learn in this direction. He complains bitterly that whoever comes forward against Zionism exposes himself to the "most spiteful personal attacks and vilifications." — Hm. We are in principle quite ready to accept instruction, — but I fear we shall not easily acquire the calm and dispassion of which Dr. Vogelstein has given some examples above. Nevertheless I will give some further samples of that distinguished manner of fighting as it is employed against us. Professor Dr. Geiger suggests that the Zionists be deprived of their civic rights, and another gentleman of the dispassionate party recently urged upon the Government, in provincial daily papers, the expulsion of foreign Jews suspected of Zionism. — But these occurrences may be unknown to Dr. Vogelstein, — how is it, then, in Stettin itself? Hand on heart, Herr Doctor! You have more than once fought energetically for your convictions at the meetings, — have you ever been made the object of spiteful or personal vilification? Or has that ever happened there to another gentleman of your persuasion? Or do you remember the meeting two weeks ago, when one of your seconds used the freedom of speech granted him for unheard-of attacks upon Zionism and the speaker, exceeding every measure of parliamentary decency?! — It may be that in the heat of battle one of us too goes too far now and then, — but I should like to see the chairman who would not most energetically uphold the dignity of our platform. — And above all, such a tone as you set down deliberately in a book, in calm, objectivity and dispassion, in the examples cited, — we do not use even in excitement and in the hottest battle of words against opponents in whom we respect the earnestness of conviction. We wield a good blade and carry good weapons, — that is true; but your reproach we energetically repel, as disciples of the great Theodor Herzl, the master, who with all his objective sharpness always remained the impartial and noble-minded man. (To be concluded.)
On the Legalisation of the Jewish National Fund
Two Reports Delivered to the Annual Conference
II.
Report of Dr. BODENHEIMER, Attorney-at-Law
I had originally intended to give here only a quite brief account of the discussions with the English jurists, which might serve as a supplement and explanation to the printed papers before you. But the attacks of Mr. Bentwich, directed in part against me, compel me to go somewhat further into detail in order to clarify the position.
The idea of the National Fund has, as is natural and as was already mentioned by Mr. Bentwich, undergone various transformations. The fundamental idea had been laid down by the resolution of the Fifth Congress, according to which the National Fund was to be an inviolable property of the Jewish people, solely for the purpose of the purchase of land in Palestine. The commission appointed for its legalisation, at whose head stood Dr. Farbstein of Zurich, proposed, in view of the resolution of the Congress according to which Switzerland was to be preferred as the seat, a co-operative society under Swiss law.
I myself had at that time submitted a detailed plan in which a foundation under German law was advocated. Mr. Bentwich, on the other hand, proposed a Trust Deed, on the basis of which the administration of the property was to be entrusted to the Jewish Colonial Bank.
It is, however, incorrect when Bentwich asserts that this principle was accepted by the National Fund Commission; on the contrary, Bentwich found support for it only from Dr. J. W. Marmorek. This proposal was rejected chiefly on the ground of the objections of the Russian members of the Commission. At the session of the National Fund Commission held later in Vienna it was then resolved by a large majority to transfer the seat of the National Fund to England. Dr. Farbstein thereupon put himself in communication with the solicitor Dr. Grusemann, who furnished the opinion before you, in which he advised against a Trust Deed and recommended the formation of a company with limited liability. According to the statement of this expert, there exists in England no institution corresponding to the foundation of German law, for which reason the foundation was definitely abandoned. Dr. J. W. Marmorek, too, thereupon dropped the plan of the foundation. (Cf. Marmorek's statements before the Sixth Congress, Proceedings, p. 278.) Bentwich's contrary assertion is accordingly erroneous.
Mr. Bentwich, in spite of several requests from Dr. Farbstein to submit a plan of his proposal, gave no answer. The Commission therefore assumed that he had dropped his idea. This follows beyond doubt from the statements of Dr. Farbstein and Dr. J. W. Marmorek before the Sixth Congress. (See the Congress Proceedings, pages 260 and 277.)
In accordance with these preliminary labours, and after the Sixth Congress had definitively fixed the purpose of the National Fund, Dr. Kokesch and I myself were charged, after the death of Dr. Herzl which had occurred in the meantime, by the Annual Conference sitting in Vienna in August 1904, to go to England and there to legalise the National Fund as an English company with limited liability, but with the commission to make the attempt to obtain from the English Board of Trade permission to register the company without the word "Limited." In London all the plans for this legalisation were subjected by Dr. Kokesch and myself to a renewed examination, and Mister Armitstead too, the expert called in, advised against the arrangement of a "Trust Deed," although at that time he did not consider it inadmissible. After several conferences the plan for a Memorandum and for the Articles of the National Fund was then settled and submitted to the next session of the Greater Actions Committee, which resolved upon some alterations to the Articles.
Now whereas, after the preliminary labours, it was to be expected that the English Board of Trade would grant permission for the omission of the word Limited, there came suddenly a definite refusal of the application without any reasons being given. A later inquiry, too, whether permission could be granted in the event of an alteration of the Articles, was answered in the negative.
About this time Mr. Bentwich, who had hitherto kept silent, came forward again with his plan, and indeed in accordance with a re-
