Page 12. — "Die Welt" — No. 40.
(continued from page 11)
…stein! He wields the blade for his old Black-Red-Gold! The citadel has long been taken; at a hundred points the enemy has broken in and made himself comfortable inside. He stands unsuspecting at his post before the gate, without turning his head. Si fractus illabatur orbis, impavidum ferient ruinae.
But the respect we have for the lofty idealism of Dr. Vogelstein lays certain obligations upon us. — We have grown accustomed not to answer every pamphlet directed against Zionism, but only when it really contains new arguments or a particularly ingenious manner of refutation. — Now if we did not know who the author of the present pamphlet is, we should perhaps not exactly be compelled to answer. We should indeed even suppose that the brochure came from someone who does not know Zionism at all, or at any rate has read nothing about it but the Rabbis' Protest of 1898 and a distorted newspaper report of the last German Delegates' Conference. — But since Dr. Vogelstein signs as author, for many years a champion in the fight against Zionism, we are compelled to take the work seriously. A man like Vogelstein, we must assume, will not combat a movement without knowing it, — that is to say, without constantly following its development, literature, etc. If he now lays this indictment before public opinion, apparently as the ripe fruit of years of laborious study, then friend and foe alike must assume that it really contains everything that can be brought forward against Zionism at all. If that is little, — then that is the best and most impartial testimony for us.
One thing more speaks for the high valuation of the little book. Dr. Vogelstein first had his work appear in the "Mitteilungen des Liberalen Vereins für die Angelegenheiten der jüdischen Gemeinde in Berlin" (Communications of the Liberal Association for the Affairs of the Jewish Community in Berlin). I am probably not mistaken in assuming that the contributors to these "Mitteilungen" in general regard it as an indiscretion when one reads their articles. But since the publishers have produced an offprint and put it into circulation, — certainly without any malicious intent against the author, — the Association has thereby also plainly valued the pamphlet as the most outstanding achievement in the struggle against Zionism, — as the pamphlet against Zionism kat' exochen!
So, I believe, we are sufficiently justified if we discuss the Vogelstein pamphlet in all seriousness.
Dr. Vogelstein, too, believes in his introduction that he must justify his taking up the word against Zionism at all. Zionism, after all, so many think, must soon collapse of itself. But Dr. Vogelstein no longer believes in our dissolution within any foreseeable time, and therefore holds the rescuing deed, such as his little book represents, to be necessary. Nevertheless he repeats the phrase about the dissension within the party, about the planlessness of the Zionists, about the struggle in our own ranks. This may be dealt with in a few words.
The prophecies of our speedy and inevitable end are as old as Zionism itself. We have also been declared dead countless times. — But we enjoy, as according to the proverb is supposed to be the rule with those declared dead, excellent health. Even purely in numbers we grow from year to year, and in our growth we have far outstripped the other Jewish organisations. So it will continue to be. In particular, after every Congress a funeral oration will be held over us in a certain press, as hitherto (after the Sixth Congress because we had fallen away from Palestine, after the Seventh because we had returned to Palestine), and always we shall go on developing, undeterred and sound. — But as regards the disunity, the following is overlooked: we form a community, as we maintain, not by choice but by necessity, — a national community. We are not a great skittles club, which is done for when the members' wives quarrel, but a whole working together for great national ends, — like a State or an international political conference. Precisely through the co-operation of all forces, through the adjustment of the various interests which can be achieved only in struggle, through the weighing of the materials supplied by representatives of all quarters of the globe and of all philosophies of life, can true success come to us. — I understand that an association of — well, let us say, of butchers — cannot exist if the members seek to impose the boycott upon one another, — but I believe that the only possibility of existence for a movement dependent upon great and long-term labours, such as the Zionist movement, is internal criticism alone, the continual struggle over the means alone. For it is only a question of this! Only for the sake of the means, only for the sake of the best way, do we contend at our gatherings. And we shall, as before, strike together, — but march separately, irresistibly, towards the one old goal.
Dr. Vogelstein himself, however, as has been said, has no real confidence in our natural dissolution, and "the dangers which, one might say, are prepared daily by Zionism for the whole of Jewry are so great that it seems urgently necessary to set them forth in a calm, purely objective manner, dispassionately and fearlessly."
So the fear of the dangers of Zionism has called forth the "fearless" exposition, — the fear of the dangers to the whole of Jewry. We are curious to learn what these dangers are, — which threaten either the totality of the Jews or the idea of Judaism as the author conceives it. For that perhaps disagreements of an economic kind for a fraction of the German Jews, — such as the author hints at on p. 8, where he uses the "fearless" turn of phrase about "German Jews who should anxiously beware," — that such things are meant is of course out of the question. To apply to these the expression "danger to the whole of Jewry" would be, — let us keep to Vogelstein's own expressions — "a monstrous presumption, as though the little band of German Jews, small in proportion to the total number of the Jews, represented Jewry." We shall see in detail where the author scents the dangers to the whole of Jewry.
We are especially glad that the author promises to make his exposition "calm," "objective" and "dispassionate."
Dr. Vogelstein then also declares, in all calm, objectivity and dispassion, that the ever
