No. 6 — Separate Edition — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
...Zionist idea there has arisen so immense a profusion of new concepts and catchwords, new endeavours, questions and debates, new parties and objects of contention, such a profusion of literature and of waste paper, that anyone hitherto unprejudiced who wishes to find his bearings in this tangle may well grow as dazed by it all as if ten thousand mill-wheels were turning in his head. And then there are a great many good friends besides, who honestly exert themselves to increase the confusion, to turn everything topsy-turvy, to hide the great beneath a thousand little things, and whatever other gratifying activity of the kind there may be. And many, too, who are in earnest about the cause, our own partisans and agitators themselves, commit errors at every step, pave the way for new misunderstandings and create fresh confusion. And none of them is to be reproached, for in our agitation we are unhappily still not marching under common marching orders; each must seek his own way singly and fight it through as best he can. We have reared our wonderful Zionist edifice, a castle for all our national ideals, and anyone who is set squarely before it, so that he can survey it in its entirety, must be convinced of the harmony and beauty of the whole, of the fitness of all its parts. But naturally each of us, the artist as well as the scholar, the working man, the rabbi, has his favourite nook in this palace, his room in which he especially loves to dwell and to work. And many by degrees know only the one path to their own armchair; and the friends who ask admittance they now lead thither through side doors, through crooked corridors and dark winding stairs, instead of conducting them up the broad open staircase, explaining to them the plan of the whole, and then showing them the way to their own wing.
I hold this to be the essential thing in our work of recruitment: always to look to the whole, never to lose the general view. And since that is so desperately hard for anyone who has long stood in the movement and, according to his inclination and individuality, continually occupies himself with some speciality or other, the Congress, the party leadership, must issue a plan, an unequivocal directive, so as at last to make the agitation independent of chance, of the personal inclination and talent of individuals, and to shape it into a uniform, purposeful and methodical one.
It is almost incomprehensible that hitherto next to nothing has been done in this direction. For Congress after Congress it has been emphasized that this is one of the most important matters for us, a vital question for our movement, and at the very first Congress the demand for such a plan of agitation was actually put forward. On agitation depends what extent our organization will yet attain, and further, too, what elements will come to us, and by whom the instruments of power that we have created may in future be used. Zealous recruiting without a plan may perhaps bring the party a quantitative strengthening; but only a propaganda working methodically and systematically on principles recognized by the Congress itself can give us the assurance that the tribune we have erected will never, for all time, be seized by such as are unworthy of it, and that our Congress and our organization will remain what they are: the representation of the Jewish people, which has recognized its nationhood and its strength and is ready to work and to fight for its existence, for its future and for its land.
And one thing more I should like to stress here. We have devoted much time at our Congresses to the question: What present-day work may we pursue? Our young, newly won friends besiege us with an irrepressible eagerness for work: Give us something to do, create a field of activity for us! We have weighed this question, what answer we should give to those laudable stormers, often and in many ways, and hardly any other point on our agenda is wont to produce so many differences and heated debates. The last word of wisdom was always: Steep yourselves in the Zionist problem! Increase your knowledge of Judaism! But that is a matter of course, the natural duty of the Zionist, and there is no need to speak of matters of course. The young people want something else; they want to turn their newly acquired knowledge to practical account as well. More still: docendo discimus, there is no better method of learning than by teaching! I maintain that by taking propaganda methodically in hand a wide and rewarding field of activity can be opened, and that at the same time the very best will thereby be done for the deepening of Zionist understanding. The best present-day work is agitation, is the propaganda of our idea!
To be sure, this must be rightly understood. If we really see in propaganda the best present-day work, we do not have in mind activity as claqueurs at meetings, nor the greatest possible exertion of the lungs, bravura in collecting tinfoil or cigar-tips, or the inclination to pin harmless passers-by into a corner for the purpose of extorting a shekel; we speak only of that agitation which seeks to work through the spread of enlightenment and knowledge, through conviction alone, the purposeful and methodical agitation for which we first wish to win the proper basis. (Applause.)
Propaganda and agitation are two different things. Propaganda is the theory, agitation the practical application. The propaganda of Zionism means the spreading of the great fundamental ideas on which Zionism is based, of the general views and feelings out of which we have arrived at our positive results. We carry on agitation when we strive to strengthen our instruments of power, when we enlist new shekel-payers, found new local groups, sell shares or collect for the National Fund. In itself, then, one could pursue the one or the other alone. One could content oneself with seeking only to help the great Jewish-national idea to recognition, or perhaps with proclaiming the renaissance of Jewish culture and art; but one could also seek one's ambition solely in issuing as many shekel receipts as possible or in selling olive trees.
Now I believe that above all we must come to an understanding that we reject the one without the other. We shall indeed rejoice when our great ideals are gradually embraced by ever wider circles, including those who still hold aloof from our work; only I have, in general, a certain distrust of so-called moral successes, and when I read "the moral success was tremendous", it strikes me as anything but reassuring, for as a rule that is the euphemistic expression for a fiasco. Above all, however, we must guard against the opposite practice, and protest that, through a solely at the obtaining
