No. 17 — "Die Welt" — Page 5
(continued from page 4)
...Palestine, is an error. Seventy souls came into Egypt and formed the Jewish people. Fewer than 50,000 Jews returned from Babylon to Palestine to build the second Temple. The real difficulty lies in the non-Jewish population, and the solution of the question lies perhaps in extending our idea of Palestine to its still desolate hinterlands. Even the Palestine of Deuteronomy stretched as far as the Euphrates, and Solomon's dominion is said to have extended from that very river to the land of the Philistines and to the border of Egypt. The whole region of Mesopotamia is historic soil for us. And even if the masses of the Jews were scattered in other lands, they would nevertheless have a centre, whether they chose to regard it as a national or a merely religious one. (To be concluded.)
On the East Africa Question.
By Dr. E. Simonson. (Conclusion.)
The latent forces which the colonisation of the territory offered to us is to set free reside not solely, nor even chiefly, in the Zionist party, but in the Jewish people. Immediately after the Sixth Congress the fear was expressed that the plan would bring us, as camp-followers, great numbers of Rachmones-Zionists. This fear has proved exaggerated, in so far as an influx into the framework of the party organisation is concerned. But the attractive power of the idea in awakening interest in the welfare of the Jewish people has already shown itself, and, once its realisation is assured, will extend to further large circles hitherto indifferent and hostile. Influential men, eminent in material and intellectual respects, who fought Zionism with bitterness, are now ready to devote their energies to the founding of an autonomous Jewish colony with Jewish laws. These opponents, then, already stand to-day upon the ground of furthering essential elements of the conception of national Judaism. It is my urgent wish to see ten million Jews become, for the present, such Rachmones-Zionists; for thereby the direction of movement is given, in which they will move, with the necessity of a law of nature, towards Zionism, and above all away from that road which, by submergence, withdraws them or their children for ever from Jewish nationhood. For the latent forces are there and only await release. These latent forces consist in the Jewish national consciousness that still slumbers in the subconscious of the greater part of the people. Not all will yet arrive at Zionism. But there will nevertheless be, on an altogether different scale, a fruitful soil for Zionist work and agitation. When the intellectual élite of our people no longer stands wholly estranged from our ideals and without understanding of them, then the attractive power of the Zionist idea will first come into its full effect. Though many may at first be driven only by success to draw nearer to the cause of their people, from their midst there will be released an inexhaustible well-spring of material and intellectual forces which will redound to the benefit of Zionism. Whoever has once come so far as to take part in the work of Zionism on one point cannot stop half-way. If not the first, then surely the following generation will take notice of the intellectual currents within Judaism, will perceive with astonishment that Judaism is in truth something other than a conglomerate of antiquated usages. It will immerse itself in our great and sublime past and in the promising renaissance of the present, and will draw from them an understanding of our future. Whoever does not perceive that only by this road is a truly effective Zionist agitation possible at all, to him the law of evolution, of historical development, has not become a living possession, however constantly he may have it on his lips.
I should like to point to a classic example. There still clings vividly in my memory the tremendous impression which the reading of the first edition of Herzl's "Jewish State" made upon me. Like a searchlight the pamphlet illumined my inner self, and although I had never before heard that such thoughts lived in any head, I yet felt as though I had always been a Zionist. At one passage only did I feel as if touched by a cold breath. It was the passage where he left open the choice between Palestine and Argentina for his Jewish State. But he became a Zionist because he had to become a Zionist, once he had become a Rachmones-Zionist. For us, who had come from a more Jewish milieu, a Zionism without Zion was from the very outset neither thinkable nor feelable. In him, too, the Jewish consciousness was present, even though it lay buried under a deeper layer of the rubble of assimilation. But it did become a living force, once the Jewish distress had acted as a releasing tension and had produced a fall of energy in the direction of Zionism. And he was a Zionist such as there was none better — not even among the Nay-sayers — in those heaviest hours of his life when, in the Neilah mood of the departing Congress, after eight years of devotion without example, he believed himself compelled to assure us once more expressly: .אם אשכחך ירושלים תשכח ימיני•
For the reasons adduced, I also do not believe that the Territorialists have inwardly renounced Palestine for good, that it does not, more or less consciously, still hover before them as the final goal. If these forces first place themselves at the service of the chartered company that is to be formed, they will be working for Zionism.
With the new forces that will flow to Zionism, new opportunities for work will also open up. For in the present situation the objection that the African colony would draw working forces away from Zionism cannot hold good, if only because we do not have sufficient opportunity for work even for the forces already at hand. For what under present conditions is called work is in many cases nothing but the expression of a consuming inner restlessness, of the wish that something must be done. And such work is often like the web of Penelope, save that Penelope acted purposefully in so far as she wished by this method of work to prevent something, whereas here something is meant to be achieved by it. In this connection I must once more return to the minutes of the Vilna Conference.
What steps before the public there with the pretension of a programme giving direction is, apart from a few suggestions deserving of thanks, nothing but a collection partly of truisms, partly of impossibilities. When, for example, it is demanded that "the executive organ of the Congress must, without departing from the fundamental principles of Zionism, take the initiative and endeavour to bring about the union of the activity of all Jewish colonisation societies for intensive, common, systematic work in Palestine", that is indeed a very good wish, but it is surely a greater Utopia than the obtaining of the Charter for Palestine within one year. Condemned to failure under existing conditions is also the demand "that the nationalisation of the Jewish people become in fact, in the most intensive manner, one of the chief tasks of Zionist work in the Diaspora". Even with the best of reasons, and though I spake with the tongues of angels, I can convince no one until I have brought him so far as to listen to me. But that, as I have shown, can come about far more surely by the detour through Africa, through the first success of utility.
That personal motives, too, were not absent from the Conference despite its seemingly objective form is shown by the demand that, through initiative and material assistance, a new Jewish newspaper be founded in Palestine. As matters stand, that would mean nothing else than cutting the thread of life of Ben Jehuda's Haschkafah. And that after Ben Jehuda, with this instrument, in twenty years of self-sacrificing work for culture, has achieved that out of the children of the Chaluka schnorrers there has grown up in the land a generation of young Zionists who love honour and culture. And why? Because, according to his best conviction, he recommended the acceptance of the English offer. From the founding of a rival national library they have apparently refrained for the present, although Chasanowicz, too, is a Yes-sayer.
Gentlemen! It is of course quite impossible even approximately all the forces to fore-
