Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 17 · 28 April 1905
4printed page
scan 4 of 20
Facsimile · scan 4 of 20
Scan of p. 4
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 17

(continued from page 3)

…dreamer and a demagogue, and in the end men of his own party reviled him as a traitor, and they broke his heart. He worked for his people, it paid him his wages, and he went home.

After Herzl's death! What pictures of terror were painted on the wall for us as the dreadful consequences of the so-called inevitable disillusionment that was to come! Well then! The stroke of fate, the death of Herzl, did indeed bring great mourning with it, but the Zionists formed all the stronger a resolve to hold together. The leading place will be filled. Herzl is dead, but Nordau remains; a great orator in many languages, a magnetic presence, a practical man with a soberer eye than Herzl, sacred to us through the bullet that sought his life. There remain to us the Congress and the Actions Committee and our institutions and our programme. For Herzl only beheld the Promised Land. He did not obtain Palestine for us. Rather he closed Palestine to us, partly because it was in the spirit of his policy that not a single Jew should settle in Palestine before we should have obtained the Charter from the Sultan, since otherwise we should be tilling the Sultan's soil without being able to draw any political advantage for ourselves; partly also because the business-minded Sultan placed fresh difficulties in the way of the Russian Jews' entry into Palestine, while the no less wily landowners drove up the price of land. There was indeed a moment when Herzl, under the rosy spell of an interview with the German Emperor, announced the near fulfilment of our hopes. But there was never a moment when it came true. The Sultan did, it is true, offer Herzl settlements in Mesopotamia, in the old Chaldean and Jewish lands about Palestine, but this was also the limit to which the Porte was disposed to go, as the famous Jewish traveller Arminius Vambery, a friend of Herzl and of the Sultan, informs us. Besides the Turkish claims, there prevails there the jealous battue of Russia, France and latterly Germany too. It is possible that a conference of the Powers may one day allay their mutual jealousies by bringing us to Palestine. Possibly, too, the difficulties would have been overcome if our millionaires had stood behind Herzl, and they may still be overcome when the eyes of our millionaires shall be as open as their hands are. But however that may be, Zionism has not failed. It has the great advantage of permanence over the Sultan, and over the Turkish Empire as well.

If the Turkish Empire wishes to prolong its days, it could hardly do better than to leave Palestine to a strong, modern, industrial people such as the Jews are. The Turks themselves are changing and will change still more. All observers agree that the Turks are a good-natured people, and that they too could be carried along by the current of modern development, political as well as industrial. But if their Empire goes out of joint, or if the Powers were ready to help us to come peacefully into possession of Palestine, we could profit by the opportunity only if we are united by Zionism. The carriage will drive along our road and we shall not be ready to get in. Who knows how often in the course of the eighteen centuries of our exile the carriage has passed us by? We have missed it every time. Perhaps Herzl's misfortune consisted merely in this, that he had not the good fortune. But Palestine means that one must wait and work. Anti-Zionists have called it a place that yields stones instead of bread. And that is partly true. But Zionism does not, after all, propose to leave Palestine in the same condition in which it now is, any more than England left Egypt in its old condition.

By irrigation and afforestation it can be transformed once more into a land flowing with milk and honey. Already the Jewish colonies make the wilderness blossom as the rose. Palestine must not be compared with green England, but with stony Sicily, and it can, in the opinion of Colonel Conder, become as fertile as that lovely island. In my speech on "The Commercial Future of Palestine" I set forth the industrial outlook of Palestine. It grows from year to year. The last consular report, of 1903, shows an increase of 25% in export and import in the course of a single year. The Damascus–Mecca railway is being built to the east of the Jordan and the Dead Sea, and soon Jerusalem itself will become a centre of trade. Situated on the coast of the Mediterranean, in the centre of the Old World, this land of ruins has still a future before it, and resurrection awaits it; and it would be an infinite pity if the future of this land were not bound up with the future and the resurrection of the people that has yearned for it through so many centuries.

But there is a difficulty which the Zionists dare not overlook, although they seldom bring it home to themselves. Palestine, namely, already has its inhabitants. The Pashalik of Jerusalem is twice as densely peopled as the United States; there live there, namely, 52 persons to the square kilometre, and not even 25% of them are Jews. We shall therefore have to be prepared either to drive the tribes that possess Palestine out of the land with the sword in our hand, after the example of our forefathers, or to grapple with the problem of an alien population, consisting for the greatest part of Mohammedans, and accustomed for centuries to despise us (?) At present we make up merely 12% of the population and possess merely two hundredths of the soil. A great part of the holy soil is in the hands of private owners and could not become ours at once even if we already had the Charter; whereas the Crown lands, which belong to the Sultan and could therefore be bought outright, are unhappily plains not free from miasmas and fever. And even these are already partly occupied by Mohammedans from Barbary and the Balkans. These appear infinitely greater difficulties*) than that which the anti-Zionist rabble makes much of — that nobody would want to go to Palestine even when we should already have obtained it, that everyone would wish to be ambassador in Paris — a jest which has lost its point since the Dreyfus days. It is, indeed, improbable and even unnecessary that all Jews should emigrate to Palestine or to a new Jewish State. During our old Palestine period we were already the most widely dispersed nation. We were found in Alexandria, for example, from the founding of that city in 332 B.C., and we even enjoyed there a certain measure of self-government. Ptolemy I. is said to have distributed 30,000 Jewish soldiers as a garrison over the whole of Egypt. The over-population of ancient Palestine was assuredly the cause of their overflow into Syria and Egypt and finally into all parts of the civilised world. The opinion that Zionism requires the return of all the Jews to


*) These remarks of Zangwill's will be answered after the publication of this article. The Editors.