Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 17 · 28 April 1905
3printed page
scan 3 of 20
Facsimile · scan 3 of 20
Scan of p. 3
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 17 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3

(continued from page 2)

…author rightly stresses strongly, can only be made possible by enabling a Jewish labouring population to exist on the land with the help of home industry and small private husbandry (the allotment of cattle and vegetable ground), which ought to be one of the chief tasks of the "Chovevei Zion," and in my opinion ought to precede the purchase, advocated by Mr. Ussishkin, of small parcels of land near the colonies and their distribution among the larger families or for the settlement of labourers.

The chief difficulty of the author's whole agrarian colonisation programme, which is, moreover, highly deserving of attention, lies in the disproportion between the great tasks and the small means available.

If no great means can be created, the progress of agricultural colonisation can naturally be only extraordinarily slow. Besides strengthening the National Fund in every way possible, besides giving moral support to the agitational endeavours of the "Chovevei Zion societies," now so closely allied with us, besides popularising the Olive Tree Donation or other donations still to be called into being for the afforestation and sanitation of the country, there remains only to encourage, as far as possible, private capital or the capital of the "Ica" to invest in Palestine: the latter by continued, untiring influence upon the members of the Council of that Society, the former by supporting the "Geula" and by forming plantation companies through the Bank — a point which Mr. Ussishkin has probably not yet sufficiently emphasised.

When, on the other hand, Dr. Pasmanik reproaches Mr. Ussishkin with speaking only of the colonisation of the colonists already present in Palestine, he does him an injustice, since the programme does provide the possibility for Jewish workers from abroad — in so far as they bring sufficient means — to settle as tenants in the co-operative colonies, and, in so far as they have no means, to work in the administratively managed agricultural colonies. On the other hand, however, one must not forget that — so long as the means of the Zionists remain as limited as hitherto — a colonisation of people without means on the part of the Zionists can be thought of, if at all, then only on the very smallest scale. When, therefore, Dr. Pasmanik puts forward the demand that the possibility of a mass colonisation in Palestine and its adjoining countries must be striven for in the shortest time, and further demands that the land to be lawfully purchased in Palestine after concessions have been obtained be colonised not merely with Palestinians but also with freshly immigrated Jews, then both must remain a pious wish so long as we do not dispose of quite other means than hitherto, or, on the other hand, so long as the "Ica" does not resolve to take up this colonisation on a large scale; for an immigration of masses of well-to-do Jewish farmers into Palestine will permanently belong to the realm of pious wishes. That for the present our shirt is nearer to us than our coat, that the Jew already settled in Palestine is more important than the one who is yet to immigrate, will seem only fair to everyone. As a programme, to be sure, one ought not to fix the very nearest resting-points attainable in the small work which the moment demands, but rather to choose goals visible from afar, even if perhaps realisable only after a long time. "Our Programme" is accordingly not the Zionist programme as such, but a colonising, predominantly agrarian programme of the Zionists for the present, in Mr. Ussishkin's sense; yet as such it is a not unimportant landmark in the history of the movement.

O. Warburg.


Zionism and England's Offer.

By Israel Zangwill.

II.

This ideal fired an ever-growing number of adherents; one Congress followed upon another, until the original number of delegates rose from a few hundred to thousands, and scarcely one country of our Diaspora merely boasts of its Zionist societies, scarcely a single one, from Newfoundland to China, from Cochin to the Caucasus. Russia, in which half of all Jewry lives and which harbours three-quarters of the Jewish question for its own share, is naturally at the head with the overwhelming majority of 1572 societies; then follow the United States with about 213, Roumania with 113, Austria (with Galicia) 200, England 80, Canada and South Africa 20 each, and some 10 societies are scattered among the English colonies, among them one in East Africa. Bulgaria has about 50, Germany about 40, Italy 15, Sweden, Norway and Denmark together 15, France, Switzerland, Hungary and the Argentine 10 each, Holland and Egypt 5 each. I have for the present no statistics for Palestine and the other Asiatic countries, but in the Holy Land itself a local Zionist congress has already taken place. I have already counted over 2500 Zionist societies. And among all these, in my judgment, the English societies are a stronger proof of our progress than the Russian, for not only is their proportion to the population somewhat higher, but they have also been founded by Jews who are free from the lower considerations of personal persecution. But Zionism does not remain at the stage of a debating society. Many dreams of the "Jewish State" have taken firm shape. The movement has a financial organ. The Jewish Colonial Bank has been founded in London, whose shareholders are to be found all over the world, and although the shares are almost exclusively in the possession of the poor, who often had to club together in order to buy a single share, the capital nevertheless exceeds a quarter of a million pounds. In spite of the fears of the anti-Zionists that we should swindle these poor people — they were fears that looked very like hopes — the Bank has even paid a dividend of 3%, and in spite of the materialism of which we were accused because we had set up a financial institution, this dividend was declined and returned by all our "dirty Shylocks." A National Fund of 200,000 dollars has been collected through donations and the sale of Zionist stamps, which the faithful stick on their letters beside the postage stamp. An Anglo-Palestine Bank in Jaffa and the Jewish Oriental Company give us a small foothold on the holy soil. Besides this, Dr. Herzl, in the course of the seven years that were granted him, succeeded in establishing personal relations with the leading sovereigns and statesmen of Europe, in travelling fearlessly through Russia, where not even American citizens can gain admission, in negotiating with the Sultan about Palestine, with the Egyptian Government about the Sinai Peninsula, and finally with the British Government about East Africa — in short, he succeeded in placing the Jewish question upon the tribune of international politics, and demanded in the name of his people from the world — no longer merely from the economies and mismanagements of governments — the solution of the Jewish question. This, surely, is no empty memento left behind by a dreamer when at the age of 44 he went down into the shadow of the tomb. Herzl is dead. He worked for his people as no man before him since Judah the Maccabee. His people called him a