Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 15 · 14 April 1905
4printed page
scan 4 of 20

Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 15

On the East Africa Question.

By Dr. E. Simonson.

(Continued.)

But not only an economic, but also a cultural experimental station could a colony built upon this foundation become for us. Above all, as a nursery for Jewish Jews. It is not without reason that Herzl's Alt-Neuland has been censured because life there bears no individually Jewish features, because its people are not Jews but Central European stereotypes. Well, in a Jewish colony with laws of its own making, the type of the present-day assimilationist Jew will very soon die out. A breed of upright Jews will grow up, who will take the laws of their life from their own nature, who will break themselves of the habit of looking askance, in that they will no longer ask first, at every undertaking: What does the Christian gentleman think of it? It is precisely these types who are for ever objecting to us Zionists: "I should not like to live always among nothing but Jews." Nor should I, so long as they are of the kind who speak in this way. But I should indeed like to live in such a colony among Jews who are whole men, who have cast off that misunderstood cosmopolitanism which corrodes themselves and others, but who are the friends of all men and all peoples, because they have first found again themselves, their own personality. There Peter Schlemihl will find his shadow again and then, as a whole man, make ready for the homeward journey. There a stock of pioneers will grow up for the future settlement of Palestine, and I express the confident conviction that in such a colony the number of Shekel-payers will be equal to the number of inhabitants.

But not only an experimental station for specifically Jewish culture, but also for the general culture of mankind could the colony become for us. For a raising of our present half-culture to true, whole culture can come about neither under the yoke of capitalism nor in the slavery of communism; only through the union of an individualistic economic system with a socialistic — not communistic — socialisation of the land can this goal be reached. Only upon this foundation can a solution be prepared of the most sublime and greatest problem of mankind, which is identical with the problem of true culture, which signifies the ultimate goal of all human development: the problem of individual life, the problem of the free personality. In his political romance "Freiland" Theodor Hertzka has attempted, successfully as I believe, to show how the solution of this problem would shape itself of its own accord in a society organised on the principles of land reform, and from this point of view the book is the most significant of all political romances. Here, of course, there can be question only of a solution of the problem for the community as a whole, such as corresponds to the age-old altruistic instincts of the Jewish national soul. For individuals have found the solution for their own persons in all ages. I have never been able to understand how conscious Jews could find satisfaction in attaching themselves to all manner of new fellowships which believe they can come to terms with the problem of individual life by solving it, with genteel exclusiveness, for their own person or group. This solution has often been found since the days of Epicurus; what it often requires above all is particular care in the choice of one's parents. But the Jewish national soul, which received Plato's sublime thoughts with enthusiasm and has readily assimilated to its nature much else from the Greeks and from foreign peoples, rejected with unerring instinct the new fellowship of Epicurus, as alien to its innermost nature, with such abhorrence that to this day the name "Apikaures" counts as the worst of insults and as the designation of an apostate.

Thus the new colony may become for us a cultural experimental station as well. But why should this economic and cultural experimental station not be possible in Palestine, like the agricultural one? — In the last number of the "Jüdische Rundschau" we once more had occasion to attempt to understand the trains of thought of Mr. Feiwel and his closer friends concerning the possibility of Zionist work in Palestine without a previous security under public law. The attempt has once again failed in my case, and no doubt in that of others too. The thinking of these gentlemen moves along lines which recall the pretty children's song: "But if the pot has a hole, dear Liese, dear Liese? Stop it up! stop it up! dear Heinrich, stop it up! — But if the Sultan gives no security under public law? Then we stop up the hole with small-scale work. But if the Sultan, or indeed any Pasha, can disturb this at any time, as soon as it attains any appreciable extent? Then we build a platform in the country from which we can negotiate with him. But if he will not allow the platform to be built from which we could confront him as a power? Here we have happily arrived once more at the question: "But if the pot has a hole?" The clear answer in our case: We therefore need a previous security under public law before we stake considerable forces, is indeed avoided by Mr. Feiwel, just as by the Vilna Conference and the Chowewe-Zion. A platform such as Mr. Feiwel desires we have, after all, in Russia. Let us then negotiate with the Russian Government as power to power! Work of this kind without a legal foundation Mr. Feiwel calls a Do ut des policy! But such a Traveiller pour le roi de la Turquie is in reality only a Do policy without the des!

We see, then, that what since Herzl has been recognised as the foundation of Zionism, what, precisely as the decisive factor, brought about the clean separation between Zionism and Chowewe-Zionism, namely the demand for a previous security under public law through political and diplomatic activity, that this must still to-day remain inexorably the first fundamental condition. I need not enter more closely here into the question of policy, for what is necessary on that head has already been said by Zlocisti in the "Rundschau" with heart-refreshing clearness. It belongs, once and for all, to the nature of political and diplomatic activity that it does not lie in the market-place, but in the hands of a few leaders, in whom a confidence must be placed that is not graduated and regulated according to the successes which the balance-sheets of a few months or years do or do not reveal; and the Zionist party shows a deplorable lack of discipline and political maturity when emanations such as the protocol of the Vilna Conference, or the article by Dr. Felix Pinkus in one of the latest numbers of the Bruenn "Volksstimme", may venture into publicity. If anything, these utterances show with full sharpness how necessary and useful was — and still would be — the strong hand of Herzl, which so often led to attacks upon our departed leader. "Chamberlain offered us East Africa in order to draw us away from a coalition with Turkey." That is the profound policy which Dr. Pinkus considers it necessary to have printed on good white paper! In this connection I must also single out here and now one point from the protocol of the Vilna Conference, to which I shall return later. Here the men who always had so superior and disdainful a smile for Herzl's political activity have for the first time come before the public with a political deed of their own, in passing the following resolution: "The Congress