No. 15 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
- the work of the present must take account of all the needs of the masses — the material and the spiritual.
The correctness of these principles cannot be proved deductively, but must necessarily be proved inductively; and indeed we wish simply to let the facts, as we observe them with our own eyes, speak for themselves.
Ad 1. We have in our organisation various groups which differ from one another in many respects. And if we single out the most extreme groups, we have on the one side the group of the Misrachi, that is, of the orthodox Zionists, and on the other the Poale Zionists, that is, the group of Zionist workers, who pay homage to the most advanced ideas. On the one side we see the Misrachists organising themselves, holding world congresses and striving after an influential position within our organisation. On the other, the workers are beginning to gain more and more ground: they have their newspapers, their societies, their organisation. From the standpoint of the Zionist statesman, that is, of one who wishes to build up Zionism as a national movement embracing all groups of Jewry, and to whom all the interests, all the energies, all the currents which together make up a whole people are dear — and such a one Dr. Herzl was — this phenomenon can only be welcomed. One can only wish that these two extreme groups may develop well, each, of course, within its own periphery. The Misrachi has a great field to till. The messianic-orthodox mass can be brought to Zionism only through the Misrachi group, at least for the time being, in the present material and cultural condition of this mass. We must say it openly: either we renounce this mass altogether for a very long epoch, that is, until, under the influence of economic changes and long-continued cultural influences, it brings more understanding to the ideas of freedom, national rebirth and self-emancipation; or else, if we wish to have the support of this enormous mass for our work at once, we must reckon upon the Misrachists.
A no less extensive field of labour lies before the Poale Zionists. In Russia alone there exists half a million workers, that is, factory workers, journeymen and apprentices, unskilled labourers, commercial employees. Among this mass Zionism, if it is to lead to conscious and organised activity, can take only the specific form of Labour Zionism. The form of propaganda hitherto employed among the working elements has indeed given us Shekel-payers — and those, too, but few in number — whereas what we need are organised and disciplined Zionist battalions. If we do not soon win this mass for our ideas, we are certain to lose it, for it will gradually be converted to the ideas of international or of old-Russian socialism. This assimilation from below is far more dangerous for national Jewry than the assimilation from above, that is, of our financial and intellectual bourgeoisie. We go further still: Zionism will become a true national movement only when working Jewry in its whole totality becomes its bearer; only then will it assume real and stable forms, only then shall we have societies as firm as rock, hundreds of thousands of Shekel-payers and a whole host of devoted and self-sacrificing agitators for our national idea.*)
We are of the opinion, then, that these two extreme groups not only have a right to exist, but are positively and absolutely necessary for the spread of Zionism in height and in depth.
Now the question arises whether and how these contradictions can be reconciled, that is, whether the Zionist organisation as a whole will not be compelled to decide for the one group or the other.
(To be concluded.)
Communications of the Vienna A.-C.
In several journals appearing in Russia, and also in an article in the Vienna Jewish periodical "Die Wahrheit", which is a translation from the Warsaw "Hazophe", the administration of the Kishineff Orphan School in Palestine has been criticised and Mr. Ussischkin, engineer, has been held responsible as the author of this project, while from a letter of Mr. Ussischkin to the editors of the "Hazophe" the responsibility of the Zionist Actions Committee for abuses alleged to exist is inferred.
To this it is remarked:
The monies acknowledged in the "Welt" for the Kishineff victims were sent to the disposal of the Actions Committee, and the latter declared in the "Welt" that it intended to apply them to the Kishineff orphans. One day it was surprised by the communication that Mr. Belkind, on behalf of a Kishineff committee, was travelling to Palestine with a number of orphans, and in fact he arrived in Vienna shortly afterwards with some 30 orphan children. The Actions Committee was thereby, without having been previously consulted, placed before a fait accompli, and could do nothing other than resolve to apply the monies collected for the Kishineff orphans to those sent to Palestine, this especially in view of the fact that a part of these monies had been given expressly for the education of such orphans in Palestine. A committee was at once set up in Palestine itself and entrusted with the supervision of the education and maintenance of the orphans. Further, the Greater Actions Committee resolved to attach the orphanage to the model farm, which is to be established from other means. For this establishment of the farm the necessary arrangements have already been made, and for the direction of the orphanage an academically trained schoolmaster from Germany, versed in Hebrew, has been engaged.
The head of the school has been instructed to examine the truth of the facts adduced in the journals concerned and to report thereon to the Actions Committee.
*) At first glance the reader may think that we regard the Jewish proletariat merely as the object and not as the subject of Zionism, that is, as if we were of the opinion that the Jewish working mass exists for Zionism and not the other way about. Reserving the discussion of this question for another occasion, we should like to remark here that the national-Jewish ideal has been formulated not by our proletariat, but by our bourgeoisie.