Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 4 · 27 January 1905
14printed page
scan 14 of 20

Page 14. — "Die Welt" — No. 4.

(continued from page 13)

…of the school of Mendelssohn and am aware that I expose myself to a reproach on the part of the nationally minded Jews, who hold the Mendelssohnian tendency in abhorrence. But it is so nevertheless. The real idealists, the dreamers in the true sense of the word, were in fact the Mendelssohnians. These men believed in the word humanity, and therefore there was for them no nation. They dreamed as Saint-Simon dreamed, as Comte, as all great thinkers and dreamers of the ages. Mendelssohn was the son of the period of Enlightenment. Political servitude on the one hand, and in the distance the dawning rise of the sun of Enlightenment, of "humanity"! Could Mendelssohn arrive at a national-Jewish theory? He could not, by force of circumstances, by force of the dialectical development of history, which consists in contrasts. Nationalism can arise in a national state, in a great, strong country. How could it arise among the German Jews when it was not yet awake among the Germans themselves?

An anti-religious man would have cast off Judaism altogether. Mendelssohn was a religious nature, and he sought to bring his Judaism into harmony with the spirit of the age.

Was Smolensky, then, right in his attacks upon Mendelssohn? Was his polemic against him sound? Yes and no. Yes, in so far as he — Smolensky — gave expression to the new thought that was germinating in Judaism, even though in this critical manner. No, since Smolensky saw only the finished ideas, only the accomplished facts, and not their causes, the attendant phenomena. He saw the falling away of the Western Jews from Judaism. And he asked himself: "Whence this phenomenon?" And he answered: "Mendelssohn is to blame for it." But he was mistaken. The causes lay deeper. Life is stronger than ideas. If the German, the French Jews became estranged from Judaism, it was for the reason that it had nothing more to offer them. To him — Smolensky — the ideologist of the new Judaism, which he built further upon the old, it was incomprehensible that a European culture could work so strongly and mightily. And yet he, after all, could not offer the Jews much. Neither a ripe plan for their material distress nor a deep spiritual theory concerning the question of questions, "the question of the "What" and "Why." Nationalism without a national philosophy, or without a philosophy of the nation, is not for the intellectuals; nationalism without national existence is not for the masses. Both these things Smolensky divined, but did not carry out. He grasped intensely the necessity of these two ingredients of the idea of a people, but he had not creative power enough to approach them, to decipher the riddle. Many and great questions Smolensky touched upon in his essays: "Am Olom," "Ejs l'taas," etc., the question of the essence of Jewish morality, of the Jewish religion. But it may be said that his thinking, in comparison with the thoughts of a Krochmal, nay, of a Michael Beer Levinsohn, was no step forward.

But one quality distinguished Smolensky, and that made of him the most brilliant agitator: the sharpness of his language and the courage to say everything. That is what matters. It is not given to everyone to say what is new, to create what is great. But to say everything, to say it with frankness, courage, fervour and warmth of feeling — that is a great merit.

This merit is Smolensky's due, and therefore he is perhaps the most sympathetic among the Hebrew writers. A youthful soul, always inspired, sincere, clinging with love to his idea, enthusiastic and kindling enthusiasm.

His style, too, is such: full of temperament. He was, in fact, an artist's nature, even if no artist.

We touch herewith upon a side of Smolensky's creation and activity which played no small part in his life's work, that is, his art, his works of fiction. I have said Smolensky was no artist. Because he had no feeling for measure, for delicacy, for nuances. One finds in him no gripping descriptions, no snapshots, no psychological deepening of the problem. His language, too, does not wholly correspond to the content. Many subjects are naive and, to our way of thinking, psychologically impossible. In the novel "Kwurat Chmor," to choose an example, a human drama is depicted, the persecution of a loving pair by fanatics, etc. And why the whole tragedy? Because the hero of the tale has committed a youthful prank and has purloined from the honourable society of the "Chewra Kadischa" its noodles, which it had had brought for a carouse. Such a psychological explanation of a novel, such an artistic interpretation of life, is simply inartistic. If one compares Smolensky as a narrator with Mendele Moches-Sforim, or even with Dii minorum gentium, with his closer collaborators and friends, such as Brandstätter, Braudes, etc., one must acknowledge their superiority.

But in one thing Smolensky had the advantage of these writers: the joy of creation and a great imagination. He was the richest in imagination among all Jewish writers of fiction, with an imagination that was turned upon the outward life.

And not that alone — he had also more warmth of heart, more greatness of soul than his contemporaries or predecessors. Kalman Schulmann wrote and translated novels, but when he described love — then his descriptions smelt of the Vilna Ghetto. Mapu's poetic reconstructions of the old Jewish life of Palestine breathe the spirit of Kowno, of Lithuanian Jewry, of the — how shall I say — the "pre-March" time. Smolensky described and depicted this very Ghetto life, these very old, outworn, archaic conditions. But his descriptions are, in spite of their defects, fresh, European, modern. As I have already emphasised — Smolensky's merit in respect of Jewish literature consists in this, that he was the first European in it, or strove to be. And that is no small merit. c.


A Gleaning.

"I see in the fact that a man is a Jew by his descent not the least thing unworthy; on the contrary, if I were of Abraham's seed, I should fall into great danger of pride at being of so high and princely a race as that of the patriarchs was, of blood so noble in the history of the world as the blood of Israel. Were I a baptised Jew, I should, even as a Christian, set store by the connection with the ancient Jewish race."

The historian Heinrich Leo in the postscript to the "Hegelingen," 1839.


Wholesale Butchery and Butchery.

We know that the Jew is a very valuable person for people who find themselves in political embarrassments. Parties or party leaders who are conscious of some guilt and seek an object upon which this guilt trans-