No. 4. — "Die Welt" — Page 13.
Review of Books and Periodicals.
The "Hazefirah," too, now takes its stand against Territorialism, in a leading article by Sokolow of the 11th inst. under the title: "Return to Zionism." In his accustomed telling manner he demonstrates that "Zion" and "Zionism" are something familiar, intelligible to all, a programme of reality, whereas "Territorialism" must be regarded as the opposite of all this. It is the "Golus," and worse than the Golus in so far as in the Golus we have, after all, ground beneath our feet, even though it be foreign ground, whereas Territorialism simply hovers in the air. The Zionists wish to rise again in their old home, like other peoples who have striven for the same goal and have more or less attained it. That is intelligible; this Zionist policy has its analogies in history. The Irish sacrifice themselves for Ireland, the Czechs wish to keep Bohemia, the Jews to regain Judæa. Peoples may raise claims to their own lands, but not to any land whatever. We do indeed form an exception, but Zionism strives to abolish this exception; we present ourselves to the world as a people and wish to be recognised and treated as such. The "policy" of the Territorialists finds no analogue in history. Before a world congress, say, the Zionists could come forward with a demand; the Territorialists would appear as petitioners who do not themselves know what they are begging for. We Zionists have taken such pains that all should understand us, that we should cease to appear as beggars and should come forward as a people demanding its land; the Territorialists begin the begging over again and imagine themselves to be "political Zionists." In conclusion Sokolow turns with sharp words upon the Territorialists, who wish to build a political system out of the Uganda incident and thus imperil the Zionist ideal, which is not our last, future ideal, but is and must remain the only one of all times, of the present also. "Political Zionism" is a useful and beautiful instrument which for the present awaits a man who will know how to use it. He who bestowed Herzl upon us will bestow this man upon us also; until then let us do what we can — but, by all that is dear and sacred to us, let us spoil nothing!
* * *
The Warsaw "Izraelita" reports upon a lecture by Professor Pogodin at the university there under the title: "The Jewish Folk-Song." The lecturer based himself upon the collection of Jewish folk-songs published some years ago by the "Woschod," and set forth approximately the following: The soul of the Jewish people is full of cares for daily life; taken up with the petty struggles of existence, it rises into higher regions only where religious questions are concerned. There it finds consolation in Messianic hopes. It is worthy of admiration that the unhappy conditions of existence under which the Jews lived did not stifle poetry in the people. The fancy of the Jewish folk-song is an exceedingly lively one. We see herein a confirmation of the general principle that the more wretched daily real life is, the richer it is in hopes for the future. Therein lies, in truth, the secret of Jewish energy, of that energy which brings it about that the Jews do not break down beneath the force of the blows of misfortune. Many a song which betrays aversion to military service may be explained by the circumstance that this service transports them into an unaccustomed, alien life, so fundamentally different from their own. The lecturer expressed himself with great appreciation concerning the love-song, in which he finds deep feelings that attain expression in infinite sincerity and unaffected form. The lover often wishes to lead home his chosen one without any "dowry," and is ready to endure hunger and cold with her, if only he may possess her love. The family life, too, is characteristic. "The Jews," said the lecturer, "since they are not recognised by their fatherland, have a strongly developed sense of family." Hebraeus.
* * *
"Unsere Hoffnung," monthly for the more mature Jewish youth, Vienna III/2, Unt. Viaduktg. 25.
The February number of this paper will, on the occasion of the 20th anniversary of the death of Perez Smolenski, be devoted almost exclusively to his significance in Hebrew literature. The number will contain a large number of portraits of the contributors to the "Haschachar," which in a measure illustrate the development of this Hebrew periodical.
A Palestine Panorama.
Three most favourably known Jewish artists, Messrs. S. Hirszenberg, Jehudo Epstein and Abraham Neumann, have resolved to undertake a journey of study to Palestine in order to execute a great work of art, namely a Palestine panorama painting. The painting is to represent an extremely interesting scene, namely the procession of the Jews to Jerusalem for the Feast of Pessach (Ole Regel) in the time of Herod the Great. The two first-named artists are painters of composition, Mr. Neumann a landscape painter. The gentlemen are at present staying in Vienna in order to pursue the obtaining of the credits necessary for this purpose. As we learn, Baurat Stiassny has taken up the project very warmly and has most readily placed the rooms of the Jewish Museum, which is under his direction, at disposal for the propaganda of this undertaking. In fact an exhibition of Hirszenberg's newest painting "Golus" (The Emigrants) and of Neumann's Palestine landscapes was arranged there, in order to bring the artists' manner of working nearer to the persons who take an interest in this magnificent undertaking. The exhibition was very largely attended on Saturday and Sunday. We shall bring an expert review of the exhibition in the next number. Baurat Stiassny is exerting his whole influence to secure the financial foundation of the undertaking here in Vienna. Should this, however, not succeed, the artists are resolved to win Jewish patrons of art for the cause elsewhere also.
Several esteemed members of the A. C., among others Dr. Alex. Marmorek, have promised their warm support. Z.
Feuilleton.
Figures and Thoughts.
I.
Perez Smolensky. *)
The question: What is a people, and what are the attributes of a people? is indeed, in its new form, of fairly recent date, but is nevertheless not so new. In the earlier periods of thought and creation also, various thinkers put this question to themselves. How do the moderns answer this question: What is a people? They give psychological, anthropological, and finally historical explanations. Now they explain the nation from the standpoint of race, now from the point of view of psychical continuity. How did the earlier inquirers interpret it? We have an answer of Renan's to this question: "Ce qui fait que les hommes forment un peuple, c'est le souvenir des grandes choses qu'ils ont faites ensemble et la volonté d'en accomplir des nouvelles." (What forms men into a people is the remembrance of the great deeds which they have accomplished together, and the wish to accomplish new ones.) A definition which is spiritualistic through and through. Here the concept of a people is grasped in its spiritual abstraction; it is not the place of abode that is decisive, not the various political circumstances, but the will. Does not Lazarus say the same? Not because thou wast born a German art thou a German, but thou art one if thou willest it, if thou acknowledgest thyself as such. And Lazarus was in this respect the pupil of the old Jewish idealists of the school of Mendelssohn. I say "idealists
*) See "Welt" No. 3.