Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 4 · 22 January 1904
6printed page
scan 6 of 20
Facsimile · scan 6 of 20
Scan of p. 6
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 4.

Meetings? Resolutions?

Under this title the "Hazefirah" writes: In order to confuse ideas and to distort the naked facts, it is now being announced that the district leaders have "assembled" and have "resolved" to publish and to explain the "true" Charkow protocol. What the leaders will print and publish is unknown; we know only what has happened up to to-day.

A National Committee has been founded in an illegal manner; Ussischkin was placed at its head in order to defy the leadership of the party; resolutions were adopted which are illegal; a delegation was illegally sent to Vienna.

In view of these occurrences the "Committee for the Protection of the Organisation" came into being.

Only what has happened comes into consideration here, not what the leaders intend to do. The announcement that a hundred persons attended a meeting*) and resolved to put into print Ussischkin's address on the practical work to be done in Palestine is beside the point. What is to be done in Palestine within the framework of the Zionist Organisation — that the Congress alone has to decide.

The Austrian National Committee, which wishes to defer its protest until the Charkow protocol shall have been published**) — is right. It ought not to protest even after the protocol becomes known; the whole thing is a matter for our local organisation.

The state of affairs is perfectly clear: Dr. Herzl does not recognise the National Committee, just as he did not recognise the delegation; he would not receive it as such. Dr. Herzl stands at the head of the defenders of our Organisation, inasmuch as he declines to take any cognisance of the whole Charkow affair.

We repeat with all emphasis: Charkow does not exist for us. Everything must be brought back to the normal former footing.

It is from this point of view that we regard the present "resolutions." What do they concern us? The publication of the "true" Charkow protocol, whether in this or in another version, leaves us cold. We are concerned only with what has happened: the protocol which the National Committee sent out to the district leaders.

Do we not know, then, what the duties of the district leaders are? Is this institution so very new? Last year too, and two and three years ago, there were district leaders. As they have worked hitherto, so must they continue to work: to carry out the resolutions of the Congress in the interval between Congresses — no more and no less.

All "resolutions" of district leaders going beyond this limit are null and void from the outset.


Jewish and Non-Jewish Charity.

When one reads of the many considerable endowments of our Jewish millionaires, one might suppose that there were no more Jewish poor in the whole wide world, no Jewish misery and no Jewish want. No other and more cogent reason can be assigned for the readiness of our philanthropists to give enormous sums for humanitarian and cultural purposes of an interdenominational character, unless we are to set down their conduct as a psychological riddle. And yet the contrary is the case. To-day, as at all times, there are many Jewish poor and, alas! such great Jewish distress, and what distinguishes it from the distress of those of other confessions is only the circumstance that the Jewish poor are still more wretched, their situation still more deplorable. We therefore stand before a riddle whose solution, if it is to satisfy us, is very hard to find.

Thus a few weeks ago we could read in the Hungarian-Jewish papers the notice that the interest on an endowment of 2 millions was shortly to be paid out. The endowment in question is that of Ignaz Wechselmann, who died last year in Budapest and who, besides this magnificent gift, left other very considerable legacies as well. In accordance with the intentions and dispositions of the testator, the interest on the above-mentioned legacy — 80,000 Kronen — is to be given in sums of 200–400 Kronen, one half to Jewish, the other half to non-Jewish teachers, men and women, who have laboured for 25 years at any school in a national and humane-moral (not antisemitic) spirit.

Nothing is further from our mind than to reproach this high-minded friend of humanity, who by his benefactions has himself raised the fairest and most enduring monument, for this consideration of his towards the teachers and educators of the people of the other confessions as well. Judaism has never made any distinction between man and man, and Jewish law, as cannot be emphasised enough, has conceded equal rights to every man. And the much-decried Talmud, which cannot be reproached enough with cruelties and injustices towards those of other faiths, commands among other things this cruelty too: that the poor and needy of all peoples and creeds should have the same right to relief and other assistance as the Jewish. It is not religious narrow-mindedness that forces these reflections upon us, and by no means the circumstance that we should grudge the non-Jewish teachers the small subsidy which in many cases they have well deserved.

But we ask: this case, in which a Jew has given great sums for humane purposes of an interdenominational character and also for expressly non-Jewish purposes, does not stand alone, nor is it of record only in the most recent past. Legion is the number of Jewish gifts for general human purposes, and that already at a time when the donors themselves, as Jews, were still excluded from any share in the benefits of the humanitarian institutions they endowed. We now ask: is this idealism, which ever and again opposes nothing but magnanimity to injustice, honoured in even the remotest degree, or repaid in kind, by the circles to whom this idealism is of benefit? By no means. Jewish charity, great as its achievements in the field of humanity already have been, has not succeeded in mitigating in the least degree the unjust hatred of Judaism; the Jewish millions have not been able to banish the old prejudice even with regard to the donors themselves. The charitable acts of the Jews were always received, and are still received to-day, without any gratitude being felt for them. We look in vain for Christian legacies whose benefits are directly accessible to Jews as well, and very small is the number of Christian endowments whose provisions regarding their enjoyment exclude any distinction of confession.

And yet it would be only just if the relation with regard to mutual gifts of a humanitarian character stood the other way about. For, in the first place, owing to the small number of Jews in proportion to non-Jews, the Jewish endowments of an interdenominational character benefit the non-Jews in by far the greater part, whi-


*) A meeting of the Charkow conference members recently took place in St. Petersburg.

**) According to a report in the "Hazofe."