No. 4. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
…and finally from M. Kaplan, S. Sockheim, G. Silberstein and S. Solotnitzky. The societies "Bnei Zion" and "Bnoth Zion" in Baku associate themselves with the demonstrations of protest against the Charkow resolutions adopted by the other societies, and assure the leadership of their unshakeable confidence.
The society "Zemach Zion" in Jekaterinoslaw, Ussischkin's own district, recognises that the acquisition of any territory whatever, even one outside Palestine, by the Zionist Organisation on an autonomous basis is both end and means towards the attainment of Zion. The society holds it its duty to protest against the resolutions and demands of the Charkow Conference. The society requests that the shekel moneys be sent directly to Vienna and that the receipts be laid before the district leaders, until such time as the Vienna A.C. shall declare in the official organ, "Die Welt," that the shekel moneys are not being withheld by the Russian plenipotentiaries.
The society "Poalei Zion" in Ponievicz protests against the Charkow resolutions and the reactionary airs of the Russian district leaders, and expresses its fullest confidence in Dr. Herzl. The society "Agudath Hazionim" in Schaki declares itself against the well-known resolutions and inquires to whom it should address itself in Zionist matters until the next Congress.
The union "Agudath Osrei Zion" in Kischenew condemns the resolutions of the Charkow men and calls upon the participants in the Conference to lay down their mandates.
At the meeting held by the three societies in Nikolajew on the 19th of Tebeth, a reasoned protest against the well-known resolutions was adopted. At the same time the societies demand that the costs of the Conference be borne by the participants (with the exception of those who voted against the resolutions) and not by the Organisation. The declaration is signed by Messrs. K. Braun and L. Adler on behalf of the societies.
The society "Agudath Hazionim" in Kopust associates itself with the protests and demands that all the resolutions of the Congress be obeyed. A resolution to the same effect has been received from the society "Bnoth Zion" of Tuckum. The protest is signed by the committee of the society: Anna Kramer, Esther Kramer, Lea Gordon, Minna Klatzo, Lea Klienberg, Ella Kemfert, Minna Tauber, Fanny Sebba.
From the delegates to the Sixth Congress, the Rev. Rabbi S. J. Glücksberg (Pinsk-Wagsal), a lengthy communication has been received, which closes in a declaration of confidence in Dr. Herzl.
Dr. Dorfmann announces in the name of 35 Odessa societies that these reject the Charkow resolutions with indignation and call upon the gentlemen concerned to lay down their mandates. Should they not do so voluntarily, they would be declared to have forfeited their mandates at the next Congress.
The society "Hatikwah" in Odessa declares, in its letter to the central direction of the Zionist societies of Odessa (Dr. Sapir), that it will not send its delegate to the Central Bureau until due satisfaction shall have been given to our Leader. The Odessa delegate Joseph Berul associates himself with the protests against Ussischkin and the Charkow men.
The society "Scholaum Zion" in Kowno and the society "Agudath Hazionim" in Petrikau send declarations of confidence to the Vienna A.C. The first declaration is signed by the committee of the society, Messrs. S. L. Schinelowitz, M. M. Joffe, Sch. Ch. Lewin, M. M. Krupnik, H. Lewin, Ch. Altenberg, J. Nefft, G. Hurwitz, J. M. Wolff, M. Braun, D. Strossburg.
The second declaration is signed by the President, M. Feinkind, and the whole committee.
In the name and on behalf of the Craiova group of the Roumanian Zionist Federation, the President, Dr. Cohn, sends a lengthy and sharply worded resolution against the well-known proceedings at Charkow.
From Paris the delegate Dr. Nahum Slouschsz writes that he associates himself with the protest of the Vienna delegates. In his opinion our Organisation has for years been undermined and demoralised by ill-disposed quarters. It is high time that order and discipline were restored.
A considerable number of declarations have been received from England. The resolutions of the societies "Degel Zion" in London, the London Jewish Workmen's Club, "Poalei Zion" No. 2, the St. Georges District Zionist Association in London, the delegate V. Shapira, and the delegate M. Blumenfiehr (Liverpool) all turn very sharply against the attempts to discredit our Organisation and to disparage our Leader.
The delegates to the Sixth Congress, Harry Baker, Percy P. Baker, H. M. Miller (Belfast), J. Bernstein (Glasgow), and A. H. Abramovitsch, condemn the proceedings of the Russian district leaders who were assembled at Charkow, and demand that these gentlemen be deprived of their mandates.
In a similar sense run the resolutions of Messrs. S. Millner (Freiburg) and J. J. Philipp (Lemberg), of the society Zion in Raudnitz, of the delegate Bondy (Hořowitz), and of the Jewish People's Association in Prague (Dr. Kohn and Gach).
Dr. S. Daiches of Leeds takes up the cause of the Charkow men in a lengthy communication. Mr. H. Goldberg likewise favours a calmer view of the well-known resolutions, while the "Agudath Hazionim" in Britschani takes a position opposed to the resolutions, and the delegate Mr. Heinrich Rosenbaum also expresses a measured censure, without rejecting everything that was resolved at Charkow. On the other hand, he pronounces himself in the sharpest manner against the improper form of these resolutions.
The Austrian National Committee, having taken cognisance of a copy of the Charkow resolutions, and taking as its basis that part of them which Mr. Rosenbaum, advocate, of Minsk, a delegate to that Conference, acknowledged as authentic to Dr. Herzl at a public meeting in Vienna, issues the following declaration:
The Austr. N.C. recognises and disapproves, in the resolution whereby, in the event of Dr. Herzl's not accepting the ultimatum, a stoppage of the shekel moneys collected in Russia was contemplated, a manifest violation of the Statute of Organisation adopted by the Fifth Congress (§ 27), according to which the shekel is to be paid over to the treasury of the Inner A.C., and consequently a violation of the Zionist Organisation as a whole.
The Austr. N.C. disapproves of the form of an ultimatum in itself as an act of disloyalty. An ultimatum is presented to an enemy, but not to the freely elected Leader, whose services to the Jewish people hitherto lay upon us Zionists an ineffaceable debt of gratitude and suffer no doubt of Herzl's fidelity to the programme.
The Austr. N.C., in deep concern for the concord and unity of the Zionist world organisation, appeals to the Zionist conscience of the Charkow men and calls upon them to withdraw their illegal and disloyal resolutions and to seek the fulfilment of their wishes and grievances only by such ways as guarantee the integrity of our movement.
Vienna, January 19th, 1904.
* * *
