Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 8.
(continued from page 5)
…welcomed Zionism with joy as a movement which showed that there was still life in Judaism.
And Provincial Rabbi Dr. Gronemann of Hanover is surely likewise of good family, by no means a "Russian Israelite". He recently, as the local "Israelitische Rundschau" reports, delivered the following address in the Hanover "Society for the Advancement of Jewish Knowledge":
"Gentlemen! I have appeared here this evening only as a listener, and not with the intention of taking part in the discussion, pro or contra. This one thing only would I say: that, without being a Zionist, I no longer see in Zionism to-day a danger, either from the religious standpoint or from that of German sentiment, as I formerly did in company with many colleagues, since it must be acknowledged that Zionism has entered upon moderate paths. The well-known declaration which the board of the Rabbinical Union issued in its time against Zionism was then, before the first Congress, entirely justified. If after the Congress the general assembly of the Rabbinical Union approved this declaration, this signified, in my view, nothing but an indemnity granted to the board. I am convinced that many of my colleagues share this view of mine, according to which it was then only declared that this pronouncement was justified at the time when it was issued. Towards the programme of the present-day Zionist party the German rabbis have, in my judgment, as yet taken up no position. While as an individual I still entirely reserve my own attitude, I may none the less express the conviction and the hope that an understanding will be arrived at between the Zionist party and the German rabbis. The condition is that friends and opponents of Zionism should endeavour to understand one another and to meet one another with confidence, in the conviction that both desire the best for Judaism."
So then, ye gentlemen anti-Zionists and train-bearers of the Liberal parties one and all: when ye say that "the German Jews will … have publicly to declare that they have nothing in common with the Zionist enthusiasts", ye err most mightily. As is well known, no man must "must". Or rather: men and things which have outlived themselves must, in obedience to an inexorable law of nature, die away. And in this case stands Jewish assimilationism, in Germany and elsewhere; it has outlived itself.
Iwri.
Jewish Realpolitik.*)
By Dr. Mayer Ebner, Czernowitz.
The political conditions in Austria have gradually ripened, even in Zionist circles, for which our Basle Programme is dogma, the perception that it is high time for the Jews of Austria to carry on a politics of the present as well. Zionism is to us consolation and hope, and all the enthusiasm of which our heart is capable we will henceforth also place in the service of the cause of the entire Jewish people. But prudence and circumspection bid us not look on with indifference while the million Austrian Jews have become politically wholly insignificant — the more so as resignation in political matters is the surest sign of intellectual backwardness and of the utter stagnation of a people's public life.
The discussion upon the question of a Jewish Realpolitik has become a live one. The heightened interest which is brought to this question is a proof of the gradual awakening from lethargy.
I am, it is true, no friend of forcing ideas and tendencies of thought into the Procrustean bed of definitions; yet, in order to give the discussion a foundation and to avoid misunderstandings, I would sum up the essence of Jewish Realpolitik in this cardinal proposition:
*) With this rejoinder of Dr. Ebner's to the observations of Dr. Menczel (Nos. 4 and 6) we continue the discussion upon the value of a Jewish Realpolitik in Austria.
Jewish Realpolitik seeks, by the wise employment of all existing relations of power, and in particular of the independent Jewish organisations still to be created, as well as of alliances to be concluded upon the principle of do ut des, to provide for an energetic representation of Austrian Jewry and of its national rights in Parliament, in the Diets, in the communal bodies and in the other general representative bodies — if possible by Jews.
Jewish Realpolitik sees in a sound social policy an excellent means towards political progress, which in its final consequence strives after nothing else than the economic prosperity and the freest development of the whole people as well as of the individual.
The representatives of this Jewish-political tendency have been brought to this view by the contemplation of the present sad conditions.
We witness the shameful spectacle that a stock of people in Austria which is distinguished by intelligence, by taxable capacity and by the cultivation of trade and industry is as good as not represented at all in the Austrian Parliament. It depends purely upon chance whether anyone is to be found in the House of Deputies or in the other representative bodies who will take the trouble to repel the frantic attacks upon our religion and our nationality. A quarter of a million Roumanians have their own club in the House of Deputies; the million Jews entrust the safeguarding of their rights to the magnanimity of Aryans or of Jews — exceptions I allow — who have neither feeling nor heart for their people and who by their shameful conduct bring us direct dishonour.
I know it from the lips of the only Jewish deputy (Dr. Straucher) how hard it has often been for him to procure the fifteen signatures necessary for the introduction of an interpellation, when that interpellation concerned a Jewish matter. The house-Jews of the Polish Club evaded him. The German Progressives as a rule would not let themselves be misused for Jewish interests, and only the Social Democrats showed understanding. Is not this a state of things as pernicious as it is shameful? Are we to look on idly until to hatred and contempt derision also is added?
If by chance a genuinely Jewish deputy strays into Parliament, he truly does not know what to do with himself. He is no Social Democrat and of course no Christian Socialist. His honourableness and his convictions restrain him from seeking and finding admission among the German Progressives per vim majoritatis. Lonely and forsaken he wanders through the wide halls. Those to whom he would most readily attach himself are scattered among all manner of clubs, so as to make good the prophet's word concerning the dispersion of Israel among the nations. The one sort are helots of the Poles, the others — with Lueger, Schönerer and Wolf — pillars of the German Gemeinbürgschaft.
What, then, is more natural than the endeavour to give the Jewish deputies in Parliament a rallying-point?
The objection is now raised that the candidature of a Jew upon a Jewish programme has in Austria no prospect of success. Now I need not point out at all that the men of Realpolitik will know how to reckon with circumstances. The German Professor Dr. Skedl stood in the constituency of Radautz-Sereth-Suczawa, with its Jewish majority, upon the basis of a Bukovina economic programme; he has joined the German Progressive Club, but in provincial questions will vote with the newly formed "Free Economic Union of the Bukovina Deputies".
In constituencies with an absolute Jewish majority a Jewish candidate will be able to come forward with less reserve than in districts with only a relative Jewish majority. In general Jewish deputies stand upon the basis of a general programme. Since the Jews have no national demands — of a constitutional or a linguistic nature — but these rather coincide with those of every constitutionally loyal, progressive, non-national party, it is made easy for the Jewish candidate to develop a programme which will be acceptable to all electors, and quite particularly to the Jewish electors, because the Jewish candidate — I am not thinking of people like Licht, Auspitz, or even Rosenzweig — as
