Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 8 · 22 February 1901
7printed page
scan 7 of 16
Facsimile · scan 7 of 16
Scan of p. 7
English · AI translation, checked against the German

"Die Welt" — No. 8. — Page 7.

(continued from page 6)

…a deputy of liberal mind and loyal to the constitution, can come forward with warmth for those rights of the Jewish people which are guaranteed by law but have by no means yet passed into practice.

Even if the success of Jewish Realpolitik should not within any foreseeable time show itself in a special Jewish club, this at all events will be attainable: that the Jewish deputies of every party camp join together in a free Jewish union, in order upon occasion to rise as one man when it is a question of the Jewish national rights, unhappily threatened at every hour.

The example of the Jewish deputies — assuming that a proper selection be made among the Jewish candidates and the chaff separated from the wheat — will work fruitfully upon the Jewish national spirit and the Jewish national consciousness. What a gain for Zionism, which would prepare the homecoming into Judaism before the return into the land of the Jews!

Let one only think out the idea of a Jewish organisation to the end, and one will become aware what an abundance of the most glorious fruits Jewish Realpolitik might bring forth. The social policy which in Dr. Menczel's conviction alone brings salvation would have in the Jewish organisation the widest scope, and the "political" Realpolitik and the "social" Realpolitik would go together as sisters.

So much for the elucidation of my standpoint, which I have already indicated in an earlier number of this paper.

Dr. Menczel has now undertaken to reduce the Jewish-political tendency ad absurdum. In his view every Jewish policy is from the outset hopeless; it will founder, he says, upon the Galician district-captain, who curtails for the Jews the freedom of elections. With this argument Dr. Menczel would play his chief trump. It would surely be superfluous to enter upon a serious refutation of this objection. Dr. Menczel forgets that Realpolitik reckons with an organised body of electors, with whom there is no dealing just as one pleases. A good organisation commands an independent press, not edited by venal hirelings of the pen, and such a press, like stout and not tongue-tied representatives, is the best defence against encroachments.

Further, it stands nowhere written that the Jews in Austria must, on account of the national postulates of the Germans and the Czechs, stand at any price in opposition to the Government. A purposeful Jewish Realpolitik might in time bring the rulers of the State in Vienna to understand that it were time to wave off the district-captain so much dreaded by Dr. Menczel. After all, the Galician district-captain is a speciality which with time will lose much of its peculiarity.

What, then, is the political programme of Dr. Menczel, if indeed a programme can be deduced out of his negations! From a few sentences of his "Rejoinder" which might be taken more seriously, two things are to be gathered. First, Dr. Menczel holds every attempt at a Jewish Realpolitik in Austria to be hopeless, whence the political attitude would be the private affair of each individual; secondly, he recommends close attachment to the Germans.

Upon the question what prospects the Jewish-political tendency has, I have already expressed myself.

But against politics being declared the private affair and matter of taste of each individual I must indeed set myself, and as a Zionist quite particularly. What we have for years condemned in the repulsive assimilationism might creep in again upon us by a back door. We know very well to what confusions political partisanship leads. To be a Zionist means to be a Jewish Nationalist also. A Jewish Nationalist who in Bohemia grows heated for the Czech extravagances, who in Moravia supports German Progressive anti-Semites for the weal and profit of the German Gemeinbürgschaft, who in Galicia is enthusiastic for the Polish national hopes, who in Bukovina warms towards the Roumanians or the Christian Germans — what a sorry picture! It is quite another thing when an organised Jewish party makes a compact with another party than when one Jew or several, according to their pleasure or even their private advantage, make themselves over, skin and hair, to some particular national group in the land. A compact upon a uniform plan under a common leadership is for us — because we come forward as a compact, respect-commanding, independent group — more honourable and more advantageous, since our conditions must then be respected.

I ask now: what honest Zionist will refuse his help to an attempt at uniting the Austrian Jews upon a political basis? It seems to me that, if it should come to the deed, Dr. Menczel too will give up his oppositional standpoint of sheer contrariness.

Now I come to the casus belli. I and my friends are not so perverse as to refuse recognition to the importance of German culture and the German language. We know that a centralised Austria needs the German language as a medium of intercourse, and it occurs to nobody to narrow the domain of the German language in Austria. But we Jews have no need to write the preservation of Germanism upon our banner. It is not at all necessary that we should upon every occasion — even an unsuitable one — strike up a hymn to Germanism. For German speech and culture the Germans shall and will provide well enough themselves. As against a Germanism almost everywhere saturated with anti-Semitism, we stand in need of a sharper emphasis upon our Jewish standpoint. That is already more than a question of advantage; that is already a matter of honour, which we take very exactly. In two provinces, in Moravia and in Bukovina, we are far more necessary to the Germans than, conversely, the Germans to us. The Germans in Bukovina admit this to themselves with gnashing of teeth. We need only a well-organised Jewish party and a prudent, unselfish leadership in order to secure to ourselves political and economic advantages. But the condition is always that we do not upon every occasion say in meetings and write in Christian-German papers how intimately we are bound up with the Germans.

Intimately bound up!

It would be laughable, were it not at our own cost! Throughout the whole Empire the Germans repudiate the Jews with emphasis. The lexicon of abuse of Deputy Wolf, which we came to know on the occasion when he attacked President Abrahamowicz, attained this climax: scoundrel, swindler — Jew. With that he meant to strike Herr Abrahamowicz dead. Even the German Progressives cannot digest three Jews of the most watery sort. How, then, are we to fill our mouths with German culture and the German language?

In a local Christian-German paper there was to be read a few days ago a remarkable indictment of the Jews: the Jews, it is said, are to blame for German anti-Semitism, because in Galicia they give themselves out as Poles and in Moravia as Czechs, instead of conducting themselves as — Germans. The article closes with a hymn to Deputy Leon Rosenzweig, who, in spite of the moral kicks that he pockets, still cries with enthusiasm: "I am a German, and I will not have my Germanism disputed away from me." This arch-stupid article may proceed either from Herr Rosenzweig himself or from a Christian German who goes out fishing for Jews. The few Germans in Bukovina who give themselves a liberal air are in sore embarrassment over the latest secession in the German Progressive Club. Since Judaism has a universal character, it will hardly do to lure the Jews here with the sweets of Germanism and out yonder to fight the Jews off with passion. Therefore the German gentlemen and their hirelings grow very nervous indeed when nationally feeling Jews remind them of the open anti-Semitism of the Germans in the Empire and of the quietly smouldering anti-Semitism in the province. Only people of a narrow horizon can still deceive themselves about facts which are manifest.

In one respect there exists no divergence between Dr. Menczel and myself. The value of a sound social policy is beyond dispute. Hitherto nothing has been got beyond enquiries into the raising of the economic condition of the Jews in Galicia. Of theories we have enough; now let a beginning be made at last with the practice.

Political progress has always been the precondition of economic progress. We have nothing to expect from anybody but from ourselves. If we will in earnest, we shall be strong — but it must be the firm will of a whole people.