No. 10 — "Die Welt" — Page 7
(continued from page 6)
…State power, as well as the number of official posts, increase with the exploitation of railways, mines, etc., whereby the ruling power of the engineer or the railway administrator far surpasses that, for example, of the Imperial-Royal head forester.
With regard to the "municipal administration" I concede, for example, to a police commissioner a higher ruling power than to a notary.
- I very readily grant you that the Jews ought not to beg for a place at all. Every kind of Schnorrerei they should leave behind in the Ghetto.
Concerning Jewish national policy in France I may permit myself no judgment, yet I believe that the anti-Semitism there suddenly blazing up so brightly makes an objective judgment difficult for the French Jews.
For Germany the Judentag will perhaps bring about a decision; for Austria the interesting articles of Dr. Ebner and Dr. Menczel show that there too the positive answer has not yet been given.
You see, then, much esteemed Doctor, that for various countries we are both against the abstention of the Jews, and it rejoices me greatly that my contradiction has moved you to a comprehensive answer, to the greater part of which I had assented beforehand.
Here, too, then, it has been proved: "Du choc des opinions jaillit la verité.
With high esteem,
with Zion's greeting, yours, who holds you in high regard,
G. C. Polak.
* * *
II.
Jewish Realpolitik.
Discussion Dr. Menczel — Dr. Ebner.*)
Closing Word of Dr. Mayer Ebner.
Much esteemed Herr Editor!
You have most kindly granted me a few columns of your paper for the defence of my Jewish political standpoint, for which, in the interest of the cause I represent, I owe you my best thanks.
A polemic has never yet convinced an opponent, and, if I am to confess it frankly, it was not at all my concern to convert Dr. Menczel to my view.
On the other hand, however, I know myself at one with thousands of my fellow members of my people, for whom the happily coined formula "Jewish Realpolitik" is the expression of a long-cherished conviction. The political impotence of the Jews in Austria, the complete defencelessness in the face of the most shameful attacks on the part of full-grown louts, the actual want of rights, the shameless disregard of the laws where we are concerned, have long been a burning wound in our heart. The hopes of Zionism cannot console us over the present moment. When the Jewry of Austria shall organise itself in order to seek the best possible employment of its political rights, Herr Menczel may confidently stand aside.
What is to be possible in Germany (see the article of Dr. Friedemann: "Judaism and Liberalism" in No. 9 of the "Welt"), is it not to be so in Austria? The half per cent. of German Jews is to create a Judentag and a Jewish political organisation, while the four per cent. (of the total population) of Austrian Jews are to remain inactive, because Dr. Menczel in his prejudice will find no pleasure in our tendency!
If it went according to Dr. Menczel, we Jews are to romp about, as hitherto, in all the political camps. Here German, there Polish, elsewhere Czech; here thrown out at the door, there in again at the window; here spat upon, there trodden underfoot — everywhere miserable tools for alien interests. Why then wax wroth over the much-abused assimilationism?
In Germany the watchword of a Jewish policy from case to case, id est a policy of interests, is taking hold of the widest circles. No one takes offence at a "do ut des" policy, since this formula is in truth the principle of every political party. But what is to be done? The "finer taste" of Dr. Menczel revolts against this kind of politics.
The "local-political Bukovina affair, to which I granted a broad space in my second article", Dr. Menczel has passed over; probably he has his reasons for it.
The reference to the Ruthenians limps, as does every comparison. Dr. Menczel will not himself wish to maintain that the Jews stand as low culturally and politically as, regrettably, the Ruthenians do. Without exaggeration it may be said that every larger Jewish community shows a higher figure of intelligence than the Ruthenians of a whole province. For the rest, I am convinced that the good endowments of the Ruthenian people will take several stages of culture at once.
To the matter itself I hold that I have nothing further to add. Against Jewish Realpolitik no serious opponent has entered the lists. The voice that made itself heard is that of the spirit which denies.
A further war of words I hold to be superfluous. The matter itself is far too important for it to linger any longer over individual persons. For me this polemic was only a brief episode, and I am sorry that it has become so unpleasant for Dr. Menczel.
Assuring you, much esteemed Herr Editor, of my high esteem, I sign myself, with Zion's greeting, yours
Dr. Mayer Ebner.
German Chronicle.
The Frankfort "Zionist Association". The "Zionist Local Group of Frankfort-on-Main" adopted unanimously at its meeting of February 9th, 1901, after a lively discussion upon the question of the convocation of a "General German Judentag", the following resolution: "The numerously attended meeting held to-day by the Zionist Local Group of Frankfort-on-Main declares the convocation of a General German Judentag to be a necessity. In the expectation that it will contribute to the safeguarding of our threatened civic rights, to the revival of the feeling of solidarity, and to the raising of a justified self-consciousness, it demands that the delegates be determined by universal, equal, direct and secret election of all the Jews of Germany."
"Zionist Association" in Cologne. At a meeting convoked by the "Zionist Association of Cologne" and attended by some 500 persons, Herr Rosenberg, advocate (Bonn), and Herr Gustav Wolff (Cologne) spoke upon the Jewish debate in the Prussian Chamber of Deputies and upon the necessity of a "General German Judentag", which, as a representation of all tendencies within German Jewry, should contribute to the safeguarding of civic rights and to the raising of a justified Jewish self-consciousness. The speakers, who entered a lively protest against the manner in which the Minister of Justice and the Chamber of Deputies had placed themselves towards the Peltason interpellation, and who at the same time repudiated the unmanly declaration of the Cologne Jewish community board, met with lively applause. A corresponding resolution was adopted with all votes against four.
Commercial Organisations.
Berlin. On February 10th, 1901, there took place in Richter's Hotel, Burgstrasse 12, the constituent meeting of the "Jewish Commercial Union". After a report delivered by Herr A. R. Hartmann, in which the speaker set forth the necessity of the founding of a Jewish commercial union and the aims of the same, the constitution of the union followed by the adoption of the following programme: The "Jewish Commercial Union" has for its object the cultivation of Jewish self-consciousness and of the national Jewish sentiment, as well as the raising of the social position of the Jewish merchants, and in particular of the commercial assistants. The union stands upon the ground of the Basle Programme. The meeting thereupon elected a Statutes Commission consisting of seven members, which on February 24th laid the draft of the statutes before the general meeting. After the adoption of the statutes the election of the executive followed.
*
*) Cf. Nos. 4, 6, 8, 9.