Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion, Jerusalem Edition · 1919
114scan
of 139
Facsimile · scan 114 of 139
Scan of scan 114
English · AI translation, checked against the Hebrew

Mount Tzvi

…these are his words: One may raise the difficulty: why does he not establish it as a case where he became impure and afterwards cut his finger, or another blemish, for impurity is permitted for the community etc.; and one must say that he does not hold that it is permitted entirely, but rather that it is set aside etc.; then the prohibition of one with a blemish no longer takes effect; end of his words. It is explained from this that, according to the one who says impurity is set aside, although it is permitted to offer in impurity, nevertheless the prohibition of impurity is not regarded as though it did not exist, and another prohibition that comes afterwards does not take effect. According to this there is room to argue that in the prohibition of a menstruant, granted that this impurity issuing from her body causes her to be forbidden to eat the Passover offering, nevertheless it is possible that the prohibition is on account of impurity through the dead alone; for since she has become a menstruant, she reverts to the original prohibition of impurity through the dead. And it is forced to say that, in the end, the prohibition of menstruation is what prevents her from eating the Passover offering; for in the case of one who became blemished on the Sabbath he is likewise not liable on account of the blemish, even though the truth is that without the blemish he would not have been forbidden in the Service; rather we say that since he became blemished, we say in turn that he had already been forbidden on account of impurity. If so, here too, since she became a menstruant, we say in turn that she had already been forbidden in the Passover offering on account of impurity through the dead; and behold, Maimonides decides that it is set aside for the community, and the prohibition stands as though it were there from the outset. And this is not the place to elaborate.

To Determine the Place of the Altar.

In the book Seeking Zion and in the Responsa of Maharatz Chajes it is written: And for this reason prophets were needed at the building of the Second Temple to testify to them about the place of the altar; that is because in the First Sanctuary was fulfilled "Raze it to the foundation", and no trace remained; but in the Second Sanctuary it was not so, as is found in the Midrash on Lamentations, that the western wall remained to this very day. And now we can reckon the place of the altar, when a just reckoning is made according to tractate Middot, and from the western wall we can discern the place of the altar, thirty-two cubits; end of quote. And I wonder at these words of theirs, for behold, the Jerusalem Talmud lies set out before us (Yoma, chapter 1): They asked Rabbi Eleazar: Are the later generations more worthy than the earlier? He said to them: Let the Chosen House be your witness: our fathers removed the ceiling, "and he uncovered the covering of Judah"; but we have broken through the walls, "who say, Raze it, raze it, to the foundation thereof". Hence it is explained expressly that, on the contrary, this verse was said of the second destruction. And likewise in our own Talmud (Gittin 57b) it is explained that the verse "Raze it to the foundation" was said of the Second Sanctuary and not of the First.

In the Responsa of Maharatz Chajes, and likewise in the book Hatan Sofer, both of them aimed at one thing: to prove that it is possible to determine the place of the altar at the present time too, from the fact that we hold as the halakhah that one is liable today on account of slaughtering outside, because it is fit for inside; and if we were not able today to determine the place of the altar, it is plain that there would be no ground to hold one liable for slaughtering outside, since it is not fit for inside; end of the substance of their words. And this proof I do not recognise, apart from what seems to me from Tosafot (Zevahim 61a), that even according to the one who says it did not sanctify for the time to come, the essential ground of his exemption from liability for slaughtering outside at the present time is only by reason of being set aside, and because he holds that living animals are set aside; but not because we lack them today and have neither Sanctuary nor altar, for on that account it would not come under "not fit for inside", as I wrote above. Now apart from this, behold, we stand by the view of Maimonides, according to whom in truth they offer even though there is no House, and the place of the altar is sanctified and standing, only that we do not know