Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion, Jerusalem Edition · 1919
112scan
of 139
Facsimile · scan 112 of 139
Scan of scan 112
English · AI translation, checked against the Hebrew

Mount Tzvi

…in this baraita, the answer of Rav Yehudah.

And see the Keren Orah there, who wondered at Maimonides for omitting this law, to put the white before the tekhelet (the blue); and he answered that, since we hold with the Rabbis that they are not indispensable to one another, they do not hold the putting-first either. And he went back and raised the difficulty that in the Tosefta mentioned above it does not imply so, for it is taught there: the tekhelet is not indispensable to the white, and nevertheless it is taught there that it is a commandment to put the white before the tekhelet; end of quote. Now according to what I wrote, that this first clause, that the tekhelet is not indispensable to the white, also follows Rabbi and was taught with regard to putting first, it is well resolved; and there is no need to elaborate on this.

Now, although I have arrived at a resolution, so that their words should not be contradicted by the Tosefta, yet for the converse too we have no compelling necessity that in the priestly garments the tekhelet is not indispensable. And apart from this, the view of the author of the Ma'or (Shabbat, chapter 2) is that even in the fringes the tekhelet is indispensable to the white, and he proves that this is also the view of the Halakhot Gedolot; see the Peri Megadim in the general introduction to the Laws of Fringes. And to this one may say that we, following most of the decisors, hold that the tekhelet is not indispensable in the fringes. Nevertheless there is still a little room for discussion according to what the Sha'agat Aryeh concluded (section 31), that a tumtum is exempt from the fringes on a linen sheet even from the white: although the tekhelet is not indispensable, nevertheless we require that it be fit for tekhelet. And if so, there is room to inquire for us, who have no tekhelet: since it is not fit for tekhelet, it is indispensable to the white. Now in the fringes one may say that according to the view of Nahmanides, that tekhelet and white are two commandments, it does not apply to say that, since it is not fit for tekhelet, it should be exempt from the white as well; but in the priestly garments, which are one commandment, there is room to argue that, granted it is not indispensable, nevertheless we require fitness. But it seems that in such a case, where the hindrance arises from a lack of expert knowledge, one may say that this does not come under "not fit", for certainly it is possible even today to find tekhelet for the commandment. However, in the essence of the matter which the book Seeking Zion newly taught us, that the tekhelet is not indispensable in the priestly garments because it is derived from the fringes, there is much room for discussion. For in the fringes themselves, granted that it is not indispensable, that means that the commandment of the white is not annulled by the lack of tekhelet; but nevertheless it is plain that he has annulled the positive commandment of tekhelet and transgressed it in a positive command, for with respect to itself, as regards the commandment of tekhelet itself, it is certainly indispensable; and if it is possible for him to obtain tekhelet, it is certainly forbidden to wear a tallit without tekhelet, just as it is forbidden to wear a tallit without white. And as for our wearing a four-cornered tallit without tekhelet, that is as the Mordekhai wrote (and it is cited in the Beit Yosef, Laws of Fringes), that the Torah did not forbid wearing the garment where it is impossible for him to put fringes on it. And at any rate, in the fringes themselves he has lacked the positive commandment of tekhelet; and consequently one may say that in the priestly garments it comes under "lack of garments", which certainly is indispensable to the Service. And how shall we say that, just as it is not indispensable in the fringes, it will not be indispensable in the priestly garments either? For even with regard to the positive commandment of the fringes it is certainly indispensable, and he has annulled and transgressed the positive commandment of tekhelet; if so, let us say in the priestly garments too that he has lacked of the priestly garments. And one may answer; and this is not the place for it.

In Bava Batra (60b): Our Rabbis taught: When the House was destroyed the second time, abstainers multiplied in Israel, who would not eat meat and would not drink etc. And the book Ein Eliyahu raised the difficulty: why did they not abstain when the House was destroyed the first time? And he answers that regarding the first sanctification there is a dispute whether it sanctified for the time to come, and according to the one who says it did not sanctify, the high places were permitted; which is not so with the Second Temple, for by all accounts it sanctified for the time to come and the high places are forbidden; end of his words. Now, as for what is obvious to him, that in the Second Temple it sanctified