The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 7 · July 1919
209printed page
scan 31 of 36
Facsimile · scan 31 of 36
Scan of p. 209
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

The Case Against Bolshevism

Bolshevism. By JOHN SPARGO. New York. Harper & Bros. Pp. 389.

N anti-Bolshevistic account ef Bolshevism, reasonably A free from newspaper fables and sufhiciently broad in historical scope to see the American reader safe through the labyrinth of Russian internal politics, has been for a long time a desideratum. We have clearly before us a complete bill of particulars, to be pleaded to by Soviet rule and its upholders. Chapter One gives the historical background—the struggle against Russian autocracy, from its inception under Alexander II to the bloody December days of 1905, when autocracy won the first round in the battle against the Moscow insurrection. The second chapter, entitled “From Revolution to Revolution,” deals with the Russia of the four Dumas from the opening of the first, to the outbreak of the war in August, 1914. “The. War and the People” (Chapter III) covers the national war-debacle that led up to the dethronement of Nicholas Il. “The Second Revolution” (Chapter IV) chronicles all too briefly the fall of autocracy. With Chapter V (“From Bourgeoise to Bolsheviki”) the author enters upon his real theme—the post revolutionary class-struggle and the Descensus Averni from the rule of the Miliukoffs and Rodziankos to the dictature of Lenine and Troieky. Chapter VI, a long and comprehensive one, details the losing battle of bourgeoise-rule, the fall of the Coalition Ministry, the rise of the Bolsheviki to power, their war-moves, their agrarianism, the Czecho-Slovak episode and the internecine strife of the Bolsheviki against the other Socialist factions. “Bolshevist Theory and Practice” (the seventh and last chapter of the book) contains Spargo’s chief indictment against terrorism and class-war, as practiced under Soviet rule, both, as the author aflırms, against the tenets of Marxism, properly understood. This chapter and the appendices in the back of the book abound with curious information on the machinery of social and political coercion, as wielded by a triumphant rule of the erstwhile weak over the erstwhile strong. “Dictature of the Proletariat” is a term much bandied about in contemporary political discussion. What its workings are like may be studied in the works of both John Reed and Mr. Spargo. Whoever will go to the trouble of studying them both—a well repaying one—will be able to make up his mind, on luminous information, rather than prejudiced belief, about the most remarkable event of the age. M.W.

New Wilsoniana

The Peace President. By William Archer. New York. Henry Holt & Company. Pp. 123.

A Frenchman's Interpretation of President Wilson. By Daniel Halévy. John Lane & Company. Pp. 283.

O F bookmaking about President Wilson there is no end. With our President the cynosure of liberal hopes in both hemispheres, a flood of books is necessary to slake the public thirst for information about his early career, his literary output, his personal traits, his politics, speeches, commitments—anything and everything likely to throw light upon the Man of the Hour.

Two new items of a long list of recent Wilson books have reached this office: a brilliant, succinct survey of the Man and his Works—both literary and political—by William Archer, "The Peace-President," and "A Frenchman's Interpretation of President Wilson," by Daniel Halévy, the latter a fine specimen of French scholarly courtesy in accounting for the President's war-moves, which, before the summer of 1918, must have been sometimes irritatingly perplexing to the Gallic intellect. Mr. Halévy's book is the more

discursive of the two, venturing upon historical parallels, adducing historical precedents and essaying throughout to make Frenchmen see the rationale of apparent American vagaries. "The Peace-President," on the other hand, takes Anglo-American political intelligence for granted. Both volumes are eminently readable, both are luminous summaries of tangled events, both abound in happy quotations from dimly remembered pre-Presidential performances of Mr. Wilson. To American readers whose time and purse compel a choice, we recommend "The Peace-President," for a reason given above, viz., that the volume assumes a certain elementary inventory of civic information in the reader.

F. J.

Babette Deutsch

“Banners.” By BABETTE DEUTSCH, New York. George H. Doran & Company. Pp. 104.

READERS of THE MACCABAEAN, who have enjoyed reading the verses of Babette Deutsch in these pages or elsewhere, will be glad to learn that Miss Deutsch has now gathered a volume of poems.

Perhaps in only one or two poems has Miss Deutsch reached a first-rate achievement in this collection, but there is throughout an undoubted charm, both of spirit and manner, that makes this one of the most pleasant of the season's publications. Miss Deutsch strikes the enthusiastic note of youth. She is in love with the world, in love even with grief and with the not infrequent beauty of sorrow. In form she seems to waver between the two schools of today—those that hold to the conventions and those that scorn them, but even her free verse does not run wild, being held in bounds usually by delicately varied rhymes that recall the similar work of Arnold and Browning. Echoes of course the reader hears—of Meredith, for example, in such poems as "Severance." The Greek Anthology especially is recalled by "A Girl" and elsewhere, but here Miss Deutsch may have been influenced indirectly through the work of the group who call themselves Imagists.

How much is Jewish in coloring in these verses? Not very much, and by a paradox frequent enough among writers of Jewish extraction (witness Emma Lazarus) the pagan world of the Hellenes has perhaps attracted Miss Deutsch more than the culture of her own people. Yet here and there a distinctly Jewish note is struck. One seems to hear it in "Distance," with its picture of two pale old men sitting by a squalid window playing chess. It sounds more audibly of course in the "Psalm for the New Zion," in which the poet cries:

"Lift up your voices, daughters of Zion!Sing and rejoice with cymbals.Bind with fillets of silver, with leaves of goldAnd flowers of lapis and coralThe brows that are smiling,Sound the low drums now.Blow the pipes for the dancing.Zion is risen again,Zion as a queen who was sleeping,Zion as a conqueror home from the heavy wars,For the years of your exile are done.From the footless route of the dunes,From the aching dark of the Ghettos,From the place of the scourge,Emerging,A moving river of faces,Proud blood that dumbly shouts,You returnTo the tents of your fathers,To the fields that mock the sunset skies with their beauty,To the mountains that rise like the sisters of happy giants,The mist-woven mountains of joy." M. W.