The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 7 · July 1919
208printed page
scan 30 of 36
Facsimile · scan 30 of 36
Scan of p. 208
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

speare and enjoy him. No wonder he could not resist the temptation to include a chapter on “Maimonides as a Master of Style.” In brief, then, the author has got together between the covers of this volume a vast amount of information and thought, wonderfully digested, and produced a work that must prove indispensable to any one interested in the maaninao nf Tewich histarv. Nn Kı

A New Imprint of a Zionist Classic

With the Zionists in Gallipoli. By LIEUT. COL. J. H. PATTERSON, D.S.O. George H. Doran Company. Second edition. 301 pp.

ZIONIST without a copy of this first classic of a militant Jewish renaissance is like a Greek without his Homer. There cannot be the slightest doubt that in the traditions of the Orient, from the Mediterranean littoral to Tashkent and Samarkand, wherever Jews and Moslems live and thrive on their own soil, the story of the author and his Jewish paladins will be linked with those of Suleiman Malek, Iskander, and of the Colonel’s countryman of the Lion-Heart. The exploits of Gallipoli, as told in this fascinating volume, will be sung at the shores of the Dead Sea and in the hills of Moab long after the present generation of Zionists will be gathered with their fathers. The muleteers of Gallipoli were only a handful of Russian-Jewish refugees, picked up on the streets of Cairo—the poorest and least considered of Israel, gathered under the British flag in a critical moment of the war in the Near East. But it is not too much to say that these floating wrecks of the Russian debacle, in a very real sense, have brought deliverance into the world for fifteen millions ‚of Jews in the dispersion—including those who disown the tenets of Zionism; those who acknowledge them in lukewarm fashion; those who float on the top of human prosperity in America; those who groan at the bottom of human misery in Poland. Without this handful of drifters trying a hazard of new fortunes under the British flag, the Balfour Declaration would never have been pronounced. For what else is the Balfour Declaration but a recognition of international Jewish sentiment considered as an asset of the belligerent Entente? And how could this erstwhile intangible but always powerful sentiment have won official recognition if it had not crystallized in the resolve of these laurel-laden adventurers to help in combating the Turk on his own soil? °

Col. Patterson tells us that his narrative of the Zionists ‚of Gallipoli has been written during the enforced idleness of a month of illness. That probably accounts for the somewhat loose-jointed and over-excursive ways of the book. A gallant soldier, on his bed of sickness, reviews the most significant episode of his life. But this episode recalls other episodes—the entire current of his’adventurous life, in fact—and he cannot forbear dwelling upon them in the retrospect. In his pages he arrives at Gallipoli, via South Africa, Col. Roosevelt, Yellowstone Park, Stonewall Jackson, the Southern Confederacy, Gettysburg, and so on. Our gallant Colonel, considered as a narrator, seems to have gone to school in Cairo with those improvisatori of the Arabian Nights’ Entertainments, who enfold tale within tale, ad infinitum. For all that, no good-humored reader will. feel like quarreling with the Colonel because his book reminds one of an autobiographical magazine series rather than of military reports. If the latter are more apt to be terse and to the point, books written in the style of the former are likely to be more readable; and if the personality of the author is spread all over the book, overshadowing in spots the fate of the regiment under his care, the 'reader will be glad to get acquainted with an attractive personality. His chief lineaments, as seen in his self-portrayal, are those of Sergeant George in “Bleakhouse”

—of a brave, obstinate, truth-telling, generous Briton, whose personal alliance with the fortunes of militant Judea is only the earnest of a national alliance to come. J. F.

Two "Guides to the Perplexed"

The Eastern Question. An Historical Study in Earopean Diplomacy. By J. A. R. Marriott, Member of Parliament for the City of Oxford. Second Edition Revised. Clarendon Press. Pp. 536.

Ten Days that Shook the World. By JOHN REED. Boni and Liveright. Pp. 371.

YOR that vast American public whose information on F foreign topics is chiefly derived from newspaper reading, the problems of the Balkans rank—in the phrasing of Thurlow Weed—among the “devil’s own incomprehensibilities.” These bewildered contemporaries are now afforded, for the first time in English historical literature, a brilliant, fully documented epitome of Balkan history considered as a key to the disclosure of European politics, from the fall of Byzantine Constantinople to our own days. Mr. Marriott’s book is not planned as a mere chronicle of the Balkans. It is conceived and written, in a masterly fashion, as a history of European interests, moves and counter-moves originating with the Turkish inroads upon Continental Christendom and the slow rise of vassal Rajahstates, first to autonomy under Turkish Suzerainty, and then to independence. Terse outline-stories of Turkey, Serbia, Bulgaria, Greece, Montenegro, Albania, and the two Danube principalities known now as Rumania are incidental to the plan. Eleven maps, rendered truly informative by correct emphasis and the omission of bewildering irrelevancies, show Balkan developments from Roman days to ours. With the appearance of Mr. Marriott’s book, ignorance of Near-Eastern history, in its bearings upon ihe movements of mankind, has ceased to be an excuse in public argument.

Another sorely needed “Guide to the Perplexed” is John Reed’s volume entitled “Ten Days that Shook the World,” meaning the ten days that overthrew the Kerensky regime and established Soviet rule in Russia.

The title is, in a sense, a misleading one, doing injustice to this valuable volume. It is a sensational and thrilling narrative of that fateful decade of days, in Mr. Reed’s best reportorial style, full of flashlights thrown upon misrepresented individuals, and obscure incidents. But the book contains much more than a reporter’s notes upon the brief climax of a long strife. It contains, in the initial chapters, the first veracicus and intelligent account, in the English language, of that strife itself, and of all the political and economic groups of Russia taking part in it. Mr. Reed’s performance may be termed a veritable Encyclopzdia of the Russian Revolution of 1917-18, or, more correctly speaking, the first part of such an Encyclopsdia, a companion volume to be entitled “From Korniloff to Brest-Litovsk,” being pre-announced in the author’s preface, to appear shortly. The twin-volumes studied as may be suggested, after a preliminary acquaintance with Mr. Olgin’s “Soul of the Russian Revolution”—will go far to dispel in the public mind that exceedingly noxious vapor of misinformation about Russia which is daily arising from the Pontinian swamps of a certain part of our press. True, Mr. Reed is a partisan, and so is our metropolitan Tory press. With this difference, however: Mr. Reed, well-informed and instinctively veracious, avows his partisanship plainly. Our Tory-press affects airs of lofty impartiality and repeats, day by day, untruths publicly.exploded about every ingredient that goes into the great Russian mix-up, reactionary or revolutionary. Under the eircumstances, one need not be an unqualified admirer of Soviet rule to admit that Mr. Reed, with his latest book, has done an important public service. M.H

Two Hundred Eight

July, 1919