majority to bind the minority on general propositions. Zionists have been contending all the while that it was not their intention to have the Congress adopt sentimental, theoretical or platonic resolutions of any kind. They had been asserting that the Congress should give general directions to its executive committee as to the action to be taken. If with regard to action, certain ideas relating to Palestine were feasible or practical, they should be considered purely as practical not theoretical measures. We were advocates of the American method of legislation to meet a concrete situation. They were thinking of the Austrian or German method and general propositions. We felt that nothing relating to action in Palestine or for Palestine or for the Jews in relation to Palestine need be expressed in a formula, but must be expressed in concrete, practical terms. That being so, the theories held by the majority in the Congress were bound to affect their consideration of every concrete proposition, but the minority need not and would not be bound by any thing but the practical form of the action contemplated. In effect, our opposing friends, wearied of the fight, wanted to capitulate, and did so as gracefully as they knew how. Once having conceded the principle, there was nothing more left to fight about. This does not mean that the Congress Committee makes no concessions. It has conceded some thing for the sake of peace which fundamentally is wrong, although practically it makes not a particle of difference. The Congress Committee, if it makes the concessions mentioned, abandons the principle of the right of a majority of Jews to organize themselves, without being hindered in their efforts by a small minority. The Philadelphia Conference stood for an open program. This did not mean, in reality, that every thing Jewish would be reviewed by the Congress. It meant that if a majority of the delegates present wished to take action, nothing stood in the way. By conceding the point as to permanence, the Congress Committee abandons the principle of self-government and the right of the majority to govern to an extent, but in all other matters relating to practical work for the attainment of full Jewish rights, the Congress is to be the paramount authority, practically unlimited in its scope.
Justice Brandeis' Resignations
JUSTICE BRANDEIS has found it necessary to tender his resignation as honorary president of the Jewish Congress Organization Committee and as a member of the executive committee of the American Jewish Relief Committee. He remains, however, honorary president of the Provisional Zionist Committee. His resignation from the committees mentioned was forced upon him by the action of the Hotel Astor Conference. Not that that Conference was the direct and only cause of his resignations. It merely revealed a state of affairs in Jewish life which would have compelled Mr. Brandeis, sooner or later, to with-
draw from such aspects of Jewish activity, where he could not with propriety inject his personality. The Hotel Astor Conference was interpreted as an indication of the determination of a certain party in American Jewry not to endure the participation of Mr. Brandeis by forcing him to be the center of controversy whenever he appeared. Viewing the situation from that angle, it may be inferred that the unseemly attack upon Mr. Brandeis was premeditated. Mr. Brandeis had decided to appear as one of a committee to present the views of the Congress movement, relying upon the delegates there present to protect him against disorderly conduct. He felt that he could depend upon the assembly not to do anything that would open the way to criticism of himself as a member of the United States Supreme Court. He felt that since his elevation to the bench his usefulness to his own people had been enhanced, and he preferred not to jeopardize that usefulness by being a party to controversy. His opponents were determined not to respect his office in Jewish matters. The same tactics would have been employed at the very next opportunity. They were prepared to go the limit in their personal animosity. His retirement naturally followed. The Hotel Astor Conference could have prevented this retirement, at this time. It could have taken official notice of the disorder created and dissociated itself from it. The onus then would have rested upon the disorderly elements. But the Conference preferred not to take notice of the breach of decorum and thus assumed full responsibility for the consequences. We regret that at a Jewish meeting so little respect was paid to the dignity of Jewish public life, but we have no doubt that insofar as Zionist interests are concerned, Mr. Brandeis' resignation from the committees mentioned will not in the least affect his usefulness; on the contrary, his affiliation with the Zionist organization will be of even greater significance and value.
A Secret Conference Needed
THE question has been asked: Why was the American Jewish Committee so strongly against a Congress, and why did it so often use the argument that there was danger in an open Jewish assembly? The answer has now been given by the Hotel Astor Conference. That Conference showed clearly that the American Jewish Committee feared that some of its own members would not know how to behave themselves in public. Private conferences are safer, for there are no reporters present. From many points of view, the Hotel Astor Conference was an exhibition of bad manners and bad management. It was organically anarchistic. It was fundamentally rowdyish. Your real snob is an intolerant fellow, who cannot stomach views with which he does not agree. Your real autocrat will not endure free discussion. Your real despot does not understand a situation where he has only an equal right to the floor. The snob
therefore shouts when he is contradicted. The autocrat denounces when he sees others given the floor which of right belongs to him. The despot therefore takes the floor as many times as he can snatch it from a friendly chairman. But in one respect the Hotel Astor Conference overstepped all expectations. It was conceded by all, foes as well as friends, that the men of the Conference understood American conventions, that they would be mindful of the decencies of public life insofar as they might affect public officials. But in this respect, too, it was a lamentable exhibition. The treatment accorded Justice Brandeis was wholly indefensible. Mr. Brandeis appeared by special invitation on a mission of peace. He spoke coolly, without feeling, simply presenting the case of the Congress. He wanted to retire because he did not wish to be the center of a controversy, but remained at the express invitation of the chairman. It would not have been becoming the office which he occupies to engage in a public argument on any question. Having remained, it was the duty of the Conference to protect him against any situation that involved the dignity of his position or that compelled his silence under insult. It was not as a Jewish representative only that he appeared. The dignity of his office—as many of the men present well knew—was part of his personality. By deliberately ignoring this fact, the Conference deliberately showed disrespect not to Mr. Brandeis, but to the United States Supreme Court. It could have allowed him to retire, and discuss what he had said in his absence. It could have discussed what he had said in his presence temperately, with discretion, scrupulously avoiding drawing him into any discussion or engaging in personalities. But this was not done. Instead a number of the delegates, in tone, gesture, and manner of deportment, indicated that they wanted to provoke him into reply, that they wanted to have him forget the dignity of his position, that they wanted him to descend to their level. They knew well that he could not do this and would not do this, but these disrespectful men knew that if he did not do this, in the public view he would have to share the responsibility for their contemptible misbehavior. That was the act of a rowdy. After such an exhibition these men will find it difficult to pass unchallenged in the company of gentlemen. It really becomes a serious question whether, before the Congress is convened, some of the elements in the Hotel Astor Conference should not be sent to school to learn how to behave in public.
Protecting the Minority
DR. MAGNES confessed, at the Hotel Astor Conference, that he feared the Congress would become a Zionist Congress, and thus commit a minority of American Jews to Zionism. It became necessary, therefore, to protect the rights of the minority. They wanted to enter the Congress, but with a constitutional protection which would estop the majority from taking action on matters they
