The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIX, No. 2 · August 1916
1scan
of 26
Facsimile · scan 1 of 26
Scan of scan 1
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

DEVOTED TO ZIONISM AND ALL JEWISH INTERESTS

ESTABLISHED OCTOBER, 1901

VOLUME XXIX.

Published monthly by The Federation of American Zionists, a corporation under the laws of the State of New York, 44 East Twenty-third Street. President, Dr. Harry Friedenwald; Chairman of the Executive Committee, Louis Lipsky; Honorary Secretary, Bernard A. Rosenblatt; Treasurer, Louis Robison; all of whom may be addressed at 44 East Twenty-third Street, New York. Telephone, 1071 Gramercy. Cable address, Maccabaean, New York. Publication office, 44 East 23d St., New York.

VIEWS AND COMMENTS

The Hotel Astor Conference

THERE had been assurances given that the Hotel Astor Conference, held on July 16th, would strike a compelling note of peace. The controversy had taxed the strength of contestants and the patience of spectators, and it was felt that a proffer of peace by the Hotel Astor Conference would force the Congressists to compromise and strike a truce. The delegates to the Hotel Astor Conference, however, did not know what peace meant; at least, the resolutions adopted, while sounding the praises of peace, in reality did not point the way. They seemed to indicate a lack of understanding of the actual conditions that confronted the Conference. It could not be expected that the Congress executive committee would ignore what had been done at the Philadelphia Conference, especially as the Philadelphia Conference had, practically, laid down only the principles of a democratic Congress, and left its executive committee free to meet any organization or group of organizations that wanted to enter the movement. The Hotel Astor Conference, however, adopted a resolution committing the Conference to a permanent organization, to the calling of a Congress, and wholly ignored the existence of the Congress Organization Committee. When Mr. Justice Brandeis, Judge Pam and Mr. Sanders appeared, the resolution was ready for presentation. It was clear that the peace-makers had decided for themselves what sort of peace they wanted, and were not going to be deterred by anything the Congress Peace Committee would say or offer. To assert, therefore, that Mr. Justice Brandeis was too unyielding in his remarks is to ignore the fact that the Hotel Astor Conference had already decided what to do, and that nothing he could say would alter the resolution presented by the Conference’s Resolutions Committee immediately after the Congress Committee had concluded its argument. I was present practically all day Sunday; and aside from abstract observations on peace, I did not notice one thing done

that indicated a genuine desire for actual peace, co-operation, union of forces, etc., until Judge Mack arose to move ä reconsideration of the resolution adopted in the afternoon. When he arose, it became clear that what had been done was not a peace measure, but a declaration of war. The attitude of Mr. Marshall also indicated the belligerent intentions of the Conference. However, I ascribe the acrimony displayed at the Conference, the bad manners, the loose talk indulged in, and the lack of dignity where dignity was expected, to the fact that the Conference really wanted peace but’ lacked the grace or savior faire to go about seeuring it. The Conference was loud and strident, but behind its resoluteness was fear of the outcome, of the numbers massed against them, fear that all they were contending for the Jews of Amerıca had alreadv renudiated.

The Terms of Peace

THIS was shown by the immediate breakdown of all pretentions in the appointment of a peace committee. Mr. Marshall refused to allow the direct appointment of a committee on peace, but as soon as the Conference adjourned, he, as chairman, appointed such a committee. The committee appointed was composed of men who sincerely desired peace. I venture to say that the personnel of the committce was the best evidence of the folly of the Conference, for the Conference could have appointed that committee in the morning, and in the afternoon, in all probability, could have brought in the treaty of peace. The Conference of Peace was held on Tuesday, July 18th. The results of that Conference have not been made public. But it is safe to say that once having confessed their inability to withstand the Congress movement, every thing else was simple. They were not standing out on principle. They were standing out against the Congress on matters involving methods and the exercise of judgment. Once they began to discuss practical questions, it was found that nothing in reality stood in the way of peace except a desire to protect the minority against the anticipated acts of the majority in the Congress. They had already conceded the Congress itself; they would join in it. They had already conceded the date of the Congress; they would abide by the decision of the Philadelphia Conference. The plan of elections had not been worked out, but had to be based on democratic principles; they were prepared to concede the democratic principle. What were they fighting about? First: They did not want a permanent Congress. But if a Congress convened once, and the second time to hear the report of its executive committee, what power on earth could prevent the Jews of America the use of the same machinery to establish a permanent organization of American Jewry? Second: They did not want the Congress to adopt resolutions endorsing certain theories, or philosophies or programs of Jewish life. That is, they objected to the right of the