same time, the gentlemen of the American Jewish Committee decided to call a conference. They attempted to defeat the popular wishes of the Jewish people, and this is not the first time that they have done this. They have done it again and again. They killed a similar popular movement started ten years ago, at the end of the Pogroms.
Prof. Israel Friedlaender: I wish to take this opportunity to make a personal comment, and I believe that an observation of this kind ought to be made at this time. I am not going to discuss the case as it stands before us, but I must say I was greatly pained by the way in which Mr. Louis Lipsky brought up this great question. He spoke of the members of the American Jewish Committee sneeringly as being “prominent gentlemen.” If prominence means anything, it means, in this particular case, service to Judaism for many years, and I think it is wrong that at a body representing so many Jews, the leaders of the Jews of America, however wrong they may have been, should have been spoken of in that tone. Among those “prominent gentlemen” I have heard the name of Mr. Jacob H. Schiff, Mr. Julius Rosenwald, and others who only a few moments ago were mentioned among the most important contributors to our Palestinian funds. To these “prominent men” also belongs Dr. Magnes who has sown the seed the prints of which we are wathering today. They may be entirely wrong; I do not mind telling you that about a week ago we had a meeting of the American Jewish Committee, and I took the liberty of criticizing a great many things criticized today. You may disagree with those gentlemen; you may entirely disapprove of the methods they have adopted, they may be entirely wrong, but I plead for courtesy, for tolerance, and I plead, above all, for the recognition of services that have been done for Judaism by these men, and I beg of you to adopt another tone.
Äuyibks Ir. Suolis-Cohen: If there is any question before the Jewish people ihat question vught to be deliberated upon, discussed calmly and with wisdom. I therfore trust that we will not take any action, but that we shall postpone it until a time when it can receive that wise, calm, deliberate consideration to which it is entitled,
Dr. Harry Friedenwald: It seems to me that the matter under consideration ought to be left to the convention of the Federation of American Zionists, and not to this body. The Provisional Zionist Committee was created for a very definite purpose, to take the position of the general Zionist organization as an international organization. I should therefore ask you whether it is proper for us, in this body, to consider a matter which should be left to the Convention of the Federation of American Zionists?
Judge Leon Sanders: I cannot be silent if the American Jewish Committee is insulted in the manner in which it was today.
Lipsky: I ask the floor on a matter of personal privilege. I regret that the delegates have taken my manner of speaking as an insult on the American Jewish Committee. I protest against using this manner of speaking to prejudice the calm discussion of this question. It is not fair to make an argument out of an incident or phrase not at all intended in the way in which it has been interpreted.
Judge Sanders: I want to say that I am one of those who was originally in favor of the convening of a congress, or conference, of the representatives of the national organizations throughout the country for the purpose of considering all questions. I have spoken upon this question at the Kehillah; I also had occasion to speak about it at the American Jewish Committee. It is easy for us to decide this question as we wish to do, without taking into consideration the conditions of the people on the other side, who will be affected by our decision, I want to say that the American Jewish Committee has also taken definite steps to ascertain from men on the other side as to what, if any, effect it will have upon their future, anything that may be said or done on this side. I am in favor of a conference, and I trust we will have one, but I am not in favor of having one of those great, big mass meetings which would necessitate the hiring of Madison Square Garden, for that will be a mass meeting, and only those on the program will have an opportunity to be heard,
and the rest will merely ratify their action. A conference of 150 men is quite sufficient. Is there any difference if it is called by the American Jewish Committee or the Zionists? Is the American Jewish Committee going to have any greater representation than any other body? Is there a single Jew living in this country who is not a member of some national organization? And if, on the other hand, you propose to have every little organization represented, it is impossible to have a proper representation.
A. H. Fromenson: It is necessary to point out that the invitation read by Mr. Lipsky was withheld because he did not wish to expose the breach of good faith of which the American Jewish Committee has been guilty in dealing with this matter previous to the Kehillah Convention. The resolution at that convention called for a congress at which should be elected delegates from all Jewish organizations on a democratic basis. We now find we will have a hand-picked conference.
S. C. Lamport: I belong to the organization which was characterized in quotation marks and without them, but I think I can safely say that that particular sort of adjective was not justifiable, because I am not prominent. Where is all the enthusiasm which you showed this morning when unity seemed to strike the keynote of the gathering, and, if you live up to that, how can you come here this afternoon and take a crisis such as this and handle it in such a fashion?
Edw. Cahn: Dr. Magnes took about thirty minutes in explaining the resolution, and I know that he is a very clear thinker and a very lucid speaker, and he does not usually take thirty minutes at explaining a proposition, and repudiate the major portion of it at the end. Now as to the question as to who is to call the congress, that is a very important matter, and not a matter of name and honor, and Judge Sanders justified his assertion that he was just a visitor by his seeming unfamiliarity with the subject. I am in favor of the resolution as offered by Mr. Lipsky.
A Er a a De er ER al 4 Eh A OF ee Er Fr A Leon A. Kohn: The whole discussion has come to be, will the congress called by the American Jewish Committee be a democratic congress and expressive of the opinion of the Jews of America. The objection has been made that the American Jewish Committee is not democratic. I myself am not clear and I do not understand why a committee headed by Judge Levy is more democratic than one formed by the American Tewish Committee.
Judge Mack: It seems that you who have been Zionists so long have forgotten things which a man like myself, who has been a Zionist for a short time, is niore likely to remember. TI do not know if anyone can tell whether one-third or a majority of the Jews are Zionists,. We know there are a great many Zionists and anti-Zionists. We qnow that a great many non-Zionists are on the point or within a short time will be on the point of becoming Zionists. It is a very natural evolution. Four or five years ago I was an anti-Zionist. My contact with Dr. Levin and some of the others gradually gave me another point of view. It is only very recently that I have become a Zionist. There are a great many more men in exactly my position. Men you may call prominent, men unlike myself, men of wealth, other men who, because of their work in Jewish matters, are deserving men, prominent in the Jewish community. It seems to me that what we Zionists want to do is to draw those men to us, to draw other men to us, every Jew to us. We don’t want to do anything that is going to arouse a feeling of antagonism against us. I am not going to defend the American Jewish Committee. All that I am going to say is this: The American Jewish Committee, in taking this action, in calling this conference, has not done something against its own convictions. The convictions of most of the members, at least, of the Executive Committee, including my own convictions, are against an enormous congress, because while some day, at some time, a congress of the Jews of this country may be very advisable, at this particular moment, in connection with the war question, I, for one, believe that a large democratic congress will be very inadvisable. I think that every member of the Executive Committee of the American Jewish Committee is in favor of a conference not exceeding I50 men, because what they believe