to make an appeal to all of the Jews of this country. If the Zionist Organization wishes to have a Congress, the Zionist Organization ought to call a Congress for one purpose, and that is to arouse the American Jews and to arouse the American people on behalf of Zion.
I believe that if the Zionist Organization now were to create a great demonstration on behalf of the idea of the regeneration of Palestine, that if the Zionist Organization were to ask all Jews whether they call themselves Zionists or refuse their belief in the regeneration of Palestine, for Jewish purposes, whether you want to do this through a Congress or in any other way, it is my belief that you will secure the almost undivided support of all sections of the lews of the country. The so-called “assimilationist'”” Jews are not Zionists, but these assimilation Jews have now, fortunately, through the influence of the Zionist Organization, understood what Palestine might mean for the Jews. We could gather under the banner of Palestine, if not specifically under the banner of the Zionist organization, the complete Jewish sentiment of this country, and it is my belief that the Zionist Organization, having mobilized the Jewish sentiment for Palestine, having crystalized it, should demand that, as far as Palestine is concerned, it should be regarded as the representative of the Jews, and that all of the Jews of the country should co-operate with us, as Zionists, as far as Palestine may be concerned. I would not want this Conference that is to be called to have in its hands the complete determination of what should happen to Palestine. I, personally, have not enough confidence in the Zionism of a large number of members of this conference to place into their hands the fate of Palestine; but I would say to them that they must cooperate with us, as far as Palestine goes; so have they a right to say to us, You Zionists must co-operate with the other Jews in so far as the other interests of the ]Jews of the world may be concerned.
Therefore, my concrete proposal is this: that as far as the Palestinian idea goes, the Zionist Organization should employ every means—a Congress, if you will, a Conference, a society, propaganda of whatever nature—to mobilize, to crystalize, the sentiment in the Zionist Organization, and that as far as the other questions of the Jews go in which other Jews have equal interest, that is, in which they have more power than we, as an organization, have, that we should co-operate with them to this end. I do not know the parliamentary form, but I think this invitation of the American Jewish Committee should come before this meeting for some kind of determination, and IT would leave to you the method of bringing this to a determination and to a vote by the Zionists here.
Brandeis: May I ask, Dr. Magnes, whether I am right in understanding you to say that the resolution with respect to the conference to be held at the instance of the American Jewish Committee excludes from that conference the consideration of those questions in which the Zionist Organization is specifically interested?
Magnes: It does not, as far as I am aware.
Brandeis: I understood you to say (was I correct in so understanding?) that you would not yourself ever submit to any such conference those questions in which specifically Zionists are interested.
Magnes: Yes, Mr. Chairman, provided that the Zionists were willing to co-operate with other Jews in the determination of questions other than Palestine. I should be in favor of the Zionist organization accepting this invitation with this particular proviso: that in Palestinian matters, the Zionist Organization invites others to cooperate with it.
Brandeis: And refuse to be bound by anything this conference mav conclude, so far as it affects Palestine?
Magnes: I would be in favor of it.
The resolution of Mr. Lipsky was then submitted for general discussion. The debate was limited to three minutes for each speaker.
Zuckerman: The difference between Dr. Magnes and the Congress advocates is the definition of the Jewish problem. The American Jewish Committee has violated all ideas of unity. We cannot go hand in hand with the A. J. C. who are anti-nationalists and anti-Zionists. The A. J. C. has no
programme, that is, its programme. How long shall we neglect the organization of the Jewish people? Now is the time to organize. We should not let the A. J. C. lead us. If we set the lead, the Jews of the United States will follow us.
Magnes: Might I make a correction? In order that the whole record may be perfectly clear, I should like to say that it is not the A. J. C. that has determined what is to be done; it is the A. J. C. that is simply calling this conference. The delegates to this conference will be men representing the various Jewish national organizations of this country, and it will be their task to formulate the program and to carry out the activities that the conference shall determine upon.
De Haas: I am very glad that we are going to be limited to three minutes in which to speak. I think this is a matter that could be clearly stated in three minutes because I do not believe in the interpretation of resolutions that need re- interpretation. The resolution submitted by Mr. Lipsky is clear and concise. He does not withäraw from the A. J. C. the right to co-operate with us, nor any other Jewish organization in the United States, and we do not feel that the issue raised by the A. J. C. itself should be brought up here because it raises a suestion which, out of sheer courtesy, I for one, did not desire to discuss. We assembled here through various organizafions, through the association with the 1. O. B. A., 1. ©. B. S. and a number of other organizations, and can fairly and honorably declare that we represent one-third of the total Jewish population of the United States, and yet we are honest enough and fair enough and square enough to work for the call for such a congress to be issued hy all the Jewish national organizations in this country, and that the basic principle upon which this congress shall be called shall be that which ihese organizations jointly and together agree upon, I am reminded that there is a street in the City of London, famous in the history of England, Tooley Street, famous because three men, living there, wrote a declaration for the English people, beginning “We, the neople of England.”
A. Goldberg: Dr. Magnes has given the best arguments for a congress to be called by us. We need unity. We work for the unity of the Jewish people. The A. J. C. has been acting in a manner that makes unity impossible.
Chas. Cowen: If we believe in any congress for the consideration of Jewish questions, we must put it in the hands of those who believe in a congress. The A. J. C. is on record as not believing in a congress. We have the right to choose our own Zionists to represent us, and even they are not all in favor of a congress. Our complaint against the A. J. C. is not that they are not Zionists, but that they misrepresent the whole Jewish people in the Diaspora. They can do us no harm in Palestine, they could not do us harm in Europe and in America. At the call of a congress, they fought and fought and fought, and then it was postponed. Shall we leave it in their hands? If the Jewish Diaspora is to influence life in Palestine, then we Zionists must influence life in the Diaspora.
Bernard G. Richards: Ten months ago, when the Provisional Committee was being organized, I had the privilege, together with others, at the Extraordinary Conference held in New York, to urge the calling of a general Jewish congress, to take up the immediate Jewish problems. Since that time, the catastrophe that has overtaken the Jewish people has spread to such an extent that it has been threatening to overwhelm one-half of the Jewish people. Since that time, the need oi a Jewish congress, the need of action of the American Jews along comprehensive lines, has become more urgent than at that time. In response to the sreat need of the hour, in keeping with the critical period in Jewish history, there has arisen through the country among the American Jews a movement for the calling of such a congress looking to the creation of a permanent democratic body among the Jews of America. This movement has spread with a popularity and sincerity, from city to city, from Jewish community to Jewish community, as no other movement has ever spread before. Society after society, lodge after lodge, fraternal order after fraternal order, proclaimed themselves in favor of this movement. At the