The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVII, No. 1 · July 1915
11printed page
scan 10 of 42
THE MACCABAEAN FOR JULY
11

given the power of selecting the national organizations whose delegates are to compose this conference, has with him the resolutions, I think it would be fair to read them.

Magnes: I regret that I have none.

Lipsky: I have a copy of the resolutions.

Magnes: Before Mr. Lipsky reads these resolutions I would ask that the letter accompanying the resolutions be read.

Letter read by Mr. Lipsky (see page 17).

Magnes: I must confess to some slight surprise that in the presentation of the question is was found unnecessary for the Federation chairman to present the communication received from the American Jewish Committee for consideration by this convention. It would seem to me that in the consideration of so important a subject all of the elements concerned might well receive careful, calm deliberation. The letter has now been presented. The letter asks the Federation of American Zionists as one of the so-called national, that is, country-wide Jewish organizations of the United States, to have elected or appointed, as it sees fit, seven delegates to a conference of national Jewish organizations to be held in the latter part of October for the sole purpose of considering the Jewish question as it affects the Jews of belligerent lands. The complete number of delegates to this conference, which is supposed to be a deliberative conference, is not to exceed 150. The number 7 was fixed as the maximum that any organization was to have. The American Jewish Committee: the Federation of American Zionists; the Union of American Hebrew Congregations; the I. O. B. A. and, if I remember right, perhaps one or two others of the large and important organizations of this country, was supposed by the Committee who had the matter of representation in charge to be entitled to the maximum number of delegates. For that reason the Federation of American Zionists has been asked to elect or appoint, as it sees fit, seven of the delegates to this conference. If I remember right, there are about forty other national Jewish organizations that are up to the present time included in the list of organizations to be asked to be represented at the conference. This list of forty is by no means complete; this list of forty can well be added to. In order to eliminate from the discussion of a conference called ad hoc, and not necessarily of a prominent nature, the large questions of Jewish organizations and Jewish life with which Jews of America particularly have to deal, this conference is to be called solely, so it says, for the purpose of considering the Jewish question as it affects not the Jews of America, but the Jews of belligerent lands. Among the belligerent lands is Palestine, and naturally the Jewish question which affects Palestine is also a legitimate subject in the discussion at this conference.

Now, Mr. Chairman and delegates to this convention, from all appearances it would seem that in urging you to accept the invitation thus offered. I am maintaining a somewhat unpopular cause among you. It would seem that you have already made up your minds that the one thing that can be done for the complete understanding of the Jewish question and for the relief of the Jews of the world and for the solution of our problem, is the calling of some large democratic Congress, the basis of which is not yet clear to you.

I am willing to plead this unpopular cause; I am willing to plead it because this conference as proposed by the American Committee, is an attempt to secure unity among the Jews of this country, and, whatever be my opinion as to the American Jewish Committee, whatever be my views as to the work of its representatives, I, for one, am always ready, have always been ready, and I hope always will be ready to plead the cause of unity among the Jews of this land and of all the lands of the world.

My belief in unity has, I regard it, a sound theoretic basis, and whereas I do not want to trouble you with my philosophic considerations at the present moment, I do wish to say this: That in my view of Jewish life, what is necessary is an organized Jewish people; an organized Jewish people all over the world; an organized Jewish people in the Goluth with the center of organization in the land of the fathers. I believe in trying to bring about the complete harmonious organization of all parts of Jewry. There are Zionists, and

Zionist literature is full of this view, who have absolutely no hope for the Goluth, who have absolutely no regard for the efforts that are put forth in the Goluth in order to strengthen Judaism there and in order to organize the Jewish people there. I am not one of these Zionists, I am one of those who realize that the life of the Jewish people is not yet being lived in Palestine; that the life of the Jewish people is here in the Goluth. I am one of those who has some belief in and some love for every manifestation of the Jewish spirit, however petty it may appear to some, and I, for one, as a Zionist, am not ready and never have been ready, in my Zionist theory, to exchange some future life in Palestine, which should alone be the life of the Jewish people, for all of the life of the Jews throughout the lands of the dispersion. I believe that the Jewry of the future will be so organized that the Diaspora will influence Eretz Israel and Eretz Israel will influence the Diaspora. I believe that it is the duty of every Jew to be a Jew in the Diaspora working for the development of Judaism there and to be a Jew for Palestine working for the establishment of the center there. I have very little patience with that type of Jew who will have nothing of Palestine, or with that type of Zionist who will have nothing of the Diaspora. Now that this theory has a basis, it would seem to me that the organization of the Jews of the world must be carried on along two general lines, that in the Diaspora no one party must furnish the basis of Jewish life, but that all of the Jews must endeavor to find a common platform upon which together they can work out the Jewish life of the countries of the Diaspora. Furthermore, that in Palestine it is the Zionist organization, and, later on, the Jews of Palestine who must furnish the authority as far as Palestine is concerned. As to Palestine itself, I suppose there could be no difference among us that the Zionist organization should be regarded as authoritative, that it should be our endeavor to persuade all of the other Jews who are not Zionists, to recognize the Zionist Organization as authoritative for Palestine. to recognize the Zionist Organization as that agency which has made Palestine its particular care.

On the other hand, it must be the duty of every one of us, Zionists and non-Zionists, conservative and radical, Jews and non-Jews, rich and poor, it must be the business of all of us in the Diaspora to try to find a common basis upon which we can work out our Jewish life in the Diaspora. Now, how is that to be done practically? I hold no brief for the American Jewish Committee. I hold no brief for its members. I know some of its difficulties, perhaps as well as you do, and yet, I am bound to say that the American Jewish Committee is the one organization in the Jewish life of this country that potentially, at least, affords this common platform for all kinds of Jews. The Zionist Organization does not afford that platform, and it cannot, because the test of Zionism is required, and rightly so, for the building up of a Jewish center in Palestine, and no other specific organization, as far as I am aware, affords this common platform upon which all Jews, of whatever kind, can work together. It is the American Jewish Committee, alone, with all of its faults, that has made the one serious attempt to give to the Jews of this country a common platform upon which all of them might work together. Therefore, Mr. Chairman, it would appear to me that it is the duty of the Zionist Organization, in the first place, to endeavor to join hands with those Jews who have already been laboring to bring about this unity; but, in the second place, Mr. Chairman, I believe that the Zionist Organization will be committing a wrong against itself if it engage too much in the particular local politics of the Jewish life of the country.

The Zionists as Zionists. as you have rightly pointed out, must, and should, and we are glad to say that they do, take part in most of the Jewish activities of the land, but the Zionist Organization, Mr. Chairman, has been formed for a primary purpose. The Zionist Organization has been formed, primarily, for Zion. Let us beware, Mr. Chairman, in pursuing the nationalistic tendency. that is, in engaging too much in the local politics of the Jewish life of this country. At this great moment we forget our primary object. My own idea is that the Zionist Organization ought