to be absolutely essential is a deliberative body. I firmly know that every member of the American Jewish Committee wants that body to be democratic, and that every member would prefer to see 150 men to be at that conference, elected in some way, if that were feasible, and it is for that reason that the resolution was adopted, although I know that in many cases, between now and November, it may not be feasible. What we want is unity in all Jewish matters, so so as to include those believing in nationalism, but do not forget that there is a large body of Jews as interested in all Jewish things as we are, who do not believe in Zionism, who do not believe in Nationalism, and who don't believe we are a people.
I agree with you, those men are utterly wrong. Shall we say that we alone are going to attempt that problem, and leave them out altogether? Some problems, perhaps, we must solve alone. All Jewish problems we should not attempt to solve alone, but every man who claims to be a Jew and who therefore is a potential member of the Zionist body, ought to be recognized by us as a Jew, even though he totally differs with us as to the Jews being a nation or as to the pos- sibilitv or desirability of having a Jewish state in Palestine.
Dr. S. S. Wise: I am not going to speak, but I am going to ask that you unite with me in suggesting that the Chairman of this meeting give us his own view of this great problem we are considering.
Brandeis: IT feel a natural hesitatior in expressing a view where there is so much difference of opinion among you, whose judgment 1 value highly. I am, perhaps, not so young a Zionist as Judge Mack, but he has been far more active in general Jewish affairs than I have. I feel this: In the first place, the fanguage, the very terms of the resolution under which the American Jewish Conference have called their conference, is one which does not meet the great need, and it does not meet the demands of those who were ınsisting that a congress should be called. The thing is to consider the Jewish question as it affects our brethren in belligerent lands, and, under the advice and suggestion of Dr. Magnes, we should be obliged to remove an ambiguity which exists in that language and insist that nothing should be said or done at that congress which might affect the question in which we are particularly interested. That presents an extraordinary infirmity in the call for a conference which ic before us.
In the next place, it seems to me that there is something specific and of moment in the fact that the term used is a term "conference" rather than "congress," the term in which the many people who had expressed themselves on the desirability of a general consideration and public discussion of the Jewish consideration had couched themselves. There is this further fact to be found in the language used:
In the resolution of the Provisional Committee, passed on May 9th, declaring in its opinion that a congress should be called at the proper time, the language is used that that congress should consider the problems of the Jewish people.
We cannot, under any circumstances, insist that all people, all Jews in America, are, or should be treated, as if they were Zionists, although we expect them, or the great majority of them, to beconie such if they are not so already. But it seems to me that while it may be extremely useful to men of wide experience. of ability, to discuss and to confer together on the great problems which are before us, it must be that those who undertake to speak for the Jewish people must recognize that there is such a thing as a Jewish people. It seems to me also that however valuable may be a careful consideration of Jewish questions aflecting particularly those of our brothers who are in the Jewish land, that our question, the question on which we must demand and work for unity, is not the questions that merely affect those in belligerent lands, but those which affect the Jews throughout the world, and that we must, therefore, at a proper time, and in a proper way, and under circumstances which will ensure that careful and solemn deliberation which the importance and gravity of these questions demand, that we must endeavor to come torether democratically, because that is the only wav in which
the Jewish people can be represented.
A N N N A 9 N BE What the number of members should be who will constitute a congress, whether it shall be 150 or more, or less, is a question which ought to be passed upon with great care and with a consideration of all the interests involved. But it seems to me that when the American Jewish Committee, however great their merits, and no one would be more ready to recognize them than I, when they undertake, themselves, to determine the number and the manner in which those delegates or representatives of the Jews of America should come together, knowing what had gone before, knowing the requests of this particular committee, which has appeared by its representatives before us, they took a step which, inevitably, in my opinion, would prevent that unity of action for which we are striving, and it is because I believe that in order that the Jews may solve their problems, there must be, in the first place, a solution recognized as representing the people theniselves, one in which we may hope for unity, or reasonable unity, among the people, that I do not see how it is possible to pursue the actions suggested, under circumstances which would necessarily create, under Dr. Magnes’ own advice. an extraordinarv difference.
ed ri Br udn a re ee nr re her un ee Te rt be 3 Suppose we have this conference, which it is proposed, shorn of a right to consider the question of Palestine. What is the unity which you may expect? You may have certain gentlemen of great wisdom and of great ability presenting the results of a conference which, for the purpose of attending to what they believe to be important outside of Palestine, are ready to relinquish ciaims of what we believe to be absolutely essential to the solution of the Jewish problem. It seems to me, therefore, that however much we, certainly some of us, respect individual members of the American Jewish Committee, however much we are convinced of the great services which they have, in the past, performed for the Jewry of America, we cannot assent to the correctness of the judgment which they have exercised and that if we undertake to give any advice, it would be to point out to them, in a clear and dignified manner, that the course which they have pursued and which they are proposing, is one which must defeat the purpose of unity for which Dr. Magnes has so eloquently and ablv pleaded.
Judge Mack: I did not understand that Dr. Magnes interpreted the resolutions as excluding the Palestinian question at all. What I understood him to say was that he himself would prefer to have the Palestinian question dealt with by a separate organization. My own interpretation of the resolution is that it includes all Jewish problems.
Dr. Magnes: In order that it may be perfectly clear, I should like to say that the resolution distinctly includes the question of Palestine, that the conference, as called by the American Jewish Committee, would include a discussion of the Jewish question as it affects Jews of the belligerent lands. As far as I, personally, am concerned, I should like to say that I should want the question of Palestine placed into the hands of the Zionist Organization, just as I would want the Jewish question affecting Jews of other belligerent lands placed into the hands of the Goluth organization. All that I want to point out is that I would like to repeat that this resolution does take into consideration the question of Palestine, but that was my own personal opinion.
When the vote is taken, I would like to have it made clear iust who is votine on the auestion.
Brandeis: Bear in mind that the question is not before this Conference directly for action. The resolution adopted by the American Jewish Committee was addressed to the Federation of American Zionists, and they only can act on that.
What is before this Conference is the resolution submitted by Mr. Lipsky, and I will ask the secretary to read that resolution so that there may be no possibility of confusion as to what you are voting on.