was a thorough review of his activity in Palestine. In reply to Jacobus Kann he was a thorough master of the art of controversy. Kann had been criticising the work in Palestine as being unsystematic and reckless of consequences. To us who are far from the center of discussion, to whom many of the points of criticism are not at all clear, the discussion seemed to be revolving around questions that involve little of principles, but much of party differences. Kann asserted that certain investments had been made without adequate preparation; as a result, moneys have been lost. Ruppin replied, saying that certain investments had to be made for the opportunities were there, and that as much preparation as could have been made had been made; that if values had diminished that was part of the risk involved in undertaking work in Palestine; nor did he think that it was proper to assume that Palestine investments per se meant losses or items of account that should not be counted as assets. It was evident that Ruppin had made a thorough study of the land, and knew what he was talking about; but it was also evident that Kann knew what he was talking about; and that granting a bit of truth on either side, the Congress could not decide on such intricate matters of fact. In effect, the criticism of the “opposition” was in the nature of a criticism by stockholders of the report of their manager; you could not, in a Congress, make that criticism the basis of an “opposition.” Ruppin was given a rousing vote of confidence and the opposition had to content itself with having presented its criticism to the Congress delegates.
VII.
It had been expected that the plan for a Jewish National University would be subjected to controversial debate. But the Congress did not divide on the subject. The Poale Zionists were opposed to the
idea of a University; there were delegates here and there who also felt that such an institution was pre'mature;: but after Ussischkin had ‚made his remarkable. address, the vote was unnecessary. Ussischkin’s words are worth recording. He said, in conclusion: “The preSent year is such a jubliee year for our people as no other people has lived to 'see. On this day, the 9th of Ab of this year, it is 2500 years since the enemy destroyed the Temple and drove our people into exile. It is now 2500 years since we wander from land to land, from tongue to tongue. We stood atthe grave of the Chaldeans, the Persians, the Greeks, the Romans and many other peoples, before whom the world once trembled. We, a small handful, have remained alive and today, 2500 years since we went into exile, stand here as the representatives of our people and take counsel as to how to accomplish our national revival. Twenty-five hundred years it is since our national Holy of Holies, the Temple of God on the Mount Moriah, was destroyed, and today we stand here animated with the idea to erect on Mount Zion a Temple of Culture and Science. This plan is the rehabilitation of our newly awakened people. And it will be realized.” \
Ussischkin then announced gifts to the University, which made Dr. Weitzmann's able paper superfluous, and the discussion that followed certainly irrelevant. Four hundred thousand marks were pledged by Zionists present and absent. The motion to refer the matter to a special commission, which shall report to the Annual Conference, which shall have full power to proceed, was carried by a unanimous vote.
VIII.
In passing it may be said that of all the personalities at the Congress, Ussischkin was the most striking, although not the most attractive. He is a man capable of be-
