The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIII, No. 9 · September 1913
262printed page
scan 8 of 48
Facsimile · scan 8 of 48
Scan of p. 262
Text · transcribed from the scan

terness or exaggeration.* His reference to the Polish boycott made a deep impression and was reported in full in all the Vienna newspapers the next morning. While Mr. Sokolow delivered the criticism of life from a Zionist viewpoint, Dr. Schmarya Levin gave a glowing account in Hebrew of the renascence of Jewish life in Palestine. The absence of Dr. Nordau was indeed a loss, but Sokolow and Levin did their best to make up for it. The former spoke without passion, clearly, conservatively; the latter in his usual manner spoke with passion and fire. Together, they stirred the large crowd as it had probably never before been stirred.

V

The debate on the report of the Inner Actions Comite opened the proceedings of the Congress proper. After a desultory discussion, with speakers attempting to cover every point made, the discussion was limited to six general speakers, among whom were Aronowitz of Palestine, Sirkin of Odessa, Tschlenow of Moscow, Wolffsohn of Cologne, Motzkin and Weitzmann. This opening debate centered about the proposal made by the Inner Actions Comite to give the administration practical control of the financial institutions. It was coupled, however, with a motion to give the Inner Actions Comite its honorable discharge. Necessarily, with no definite motion before the house, great latitude was given the speakers. There seemed to be no objection to giving the Inner Actions Comite its discharge, as it is called. Wolffsohn had nothing to say against that proposal, nor had Sirkin, who spoke as a political Zionist.

It was on the bank control that a division of opinion was observed. Wolffsohn gave what was his one speech at the Congress in this debate. Although he is not a man of

deep invention, nor capable of sustained oratorical flights, his speech was by general indorsement the best argument in favor of continuing old control. The Bank was founded to engage in stimulating commerce and trade; its policy had to be based on the principles of banking and it could not be diverted into an instrument for the use of the Zionist movement regardless of the implied promise contained in its articles of incorporation. The shareholders of the Bank held their stock not as members of the Zionist organization. The Congress as such could not legislate for the Bank, which ought not to be made the football of parties.

Against this view Weitzmann protested. He declared that the Bank’s policy ought to be directed by the Congress through its elected representatives. The Bank must be madean instrument of the movement. What the Inner Actions -Comite proposed was not a radical change, but a return to,the method in vogue when Herzl was the leader. Weitzmann spoke the morning after Wolffsohn, but he could not efface the impresion made by the former head of the organization. The upshot of the discussion after two days and over had been spent was the adoption of the re solution giving the Inner Actions Comite its discharge, and the reference to the Permanenzausschuss of the bank question. In.effect, this was a defeat of the administration for they had insisted that they would not accept the discharge without being given the bank control. Such a procedure is, it seems, permissible in continental parliaments, but it was rather confusing and, at the same time, it was most impolitic and untactful for the Inner Actions Comite to employ it.

VI.

The second set debate hinged about the report of Dr. Ruppin for the Palestina Amt. Dr. Ruppin has all the qualities of a trained investigator combined with exceptional journalistic ability. His report

*The reader will find this address in full elswhere in this issue.