The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 6 · June 1910
215printed page
scan 29 of 54
Facsimile · scan 29 of 54
Scan of p. 215
Text · transcribed from the scan

The English Manifesto

A number of young Zionists in England have drawn up a manifesto, which our contemporary, the Zionist Banner, of London, declares is representative of "the new spirit in the movement." The manifesto is said to have the support of many leading Zionists, and steps are to be taken to have it considered by English Zionist societies with a view to the adoption of the practical proposals which it contains. In order that our readers may be informed as to the various healthy currents of thought in the movement, we give the manifesto in full. It was drawn up by Norman Bentwich, Harry Sacher and Leon Simon:

"There has recently been issued from Berlin a manifesto signed by a considerable number of Zionists who adhere to the cause which was championed at the ninth congress by the Russian delegates. We who have subscribed the present document desire to express our solidarity with that cause, to present it to the mass of English Zionists in its true character and to lay before them some reasons why they should rally to it. The ninth congress, by general admission, was unsatisfactory and indecisive. It revealed two powerful parties in conflict, neither strong enough to carry out its will.

"From the beginnings of the Zionist movement, there have been two principal parties in the movement; the Russians and Galicians have constituted the kernel of one group, the Germans the kernel of the other. During the last three years the cleft between these two groups has widened. The Russian group is the most considerable in the Zionist movement by virtue of its numbers, the financial sacrifices it makes, its moral prestige, and its intensive Jewish culture; but for three years it has had no share in the control of the organization. The direction of the movement has been entirely in the hands

of representatives of the German group. That is an arrangement which is indefensible and which was certain to lead to strife.

"The leadership of the movement lost touch with the most vital element in Zionism, and in doing so it not merely ceased to be democratic but ceased to have a policy which corresponded with the convictions of the great body of Zionists. Under any circumstances such a situation would hamper and defeat Zionism; but if it is allowed to persist, in the face of the new order in Turkey it will inevitably lead to disaster. An enlargement and reform of the directing body of the movement and a clear-cut program of work for the reconstituted Actions Comite are indispensable. It is a duty to see that the necessity for these changes is appreciated by Zionists everywhere, and that the way is prepared for their adoption by the tenth congress.

"The following is an outline of the form which, in our opinion, these changes should take:—

PALESTINE.

"Work in Palestine must be the central feature of our program, and the basis of our whole policy; on that point all sections of the movement are agreed—at least in theory. But in order that our work in Palestine may be practical and may contribute to the end that we have in view, one condition is essential. The movement must be represented in Palestine by a body of men who are capable of deciding what are the best and most profitable activities that Zionism can undertake, and of seeing to it that any schemes on which it is decided to embark are properly carried out. At present there is no means of discovering with any reasonable certainty which of the many schemes put forward are worthy of support, and which are not. We look in vain for any authoritative guidance from Palestine itself; we have a number of conflicting opinions, none of which has any greater claim than the rest to be accepted.