The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 6 · June 1910
216printed page
scan 30 of 54
Facsimile · scan 30 of 54
Scan of p. 216
Text · transcribed from the scan

The result is that there is no such thing as a Zionist plan of work in Palestine; there are only different plans of individual Zionists, none of which is binding on the movement as a whole.

"In order to end this state of things, it is necessary that there should be an authoritative advisory body in Palestine itself, which, with a thorough knowledge of the local conditions, could guide the activities of the movement into proper channels. Such a body should have been called into existence long ago; we must work for its appointment at once, or at least ensure that this chaos of conflicting schemes is not allowed to continue after the tenth congress.

ORGANIZATION

"It goes without saying that the Zionist organization in Palestine, which we have just shown to be necessary, must have at its head a member of the Smaller Actions Comite. And not only Palestine itself, but the Russian Zionists, who have always been the staunchest supporters of practical work in Palestine, must be represented in the leadership of the movement. It will be an imperative duty of the tenth congress to secure this extension of the executive, which will involve the removal of the headquarters from Cologne to some centre where the various forces can unite.

"At the same time the organization of the movement should be so remodelled as to make each member of the Smaller Actions Comite responsible for a definite branch of Zionist work. The adoption of this principle (which would not, of course, do away with the collective responsibility of the whole executive for the policy of the movement) appears to us to be necessary in order to secure the co-ordination of Zionist activities, and to put an end to the semi-independent position of the National Fund and the Jewish Colonial Trust.

"This reform would also, in our opinion, tend to give the movement a democratic character. That it has not that character at present is perhaps its greatest source of weakness. The will of the ma-

jority of Zionists must prevail, and the leaders must know that they are there to carry it out.

"The increase in the numbers of the Smaller Actions Comite, to which we have already referred, is a step in the direction of democracy. But it is no less essential that the Greater Actions Comite, which is a representative body, should have more power than it has at present. The time which elapses between successive Congresses is too long to permit of effective control of the executive. The Greater Actions Comite should meet more frequently, its members should consult the Zionists, whom they represent, on important questions before its meetings; it should be entitled to demand that the Smaller Actions Comite carries out the decisions at which it arrives by a majority of votes, and no important new departure should be made between Congresses without its sanction.

IMMEDIATE REFORMS

"The immediate reforms, then, for which we stand, and which we desire to see carried out, as soon as possible, are these:—

1. The construction of a representative body of Zionists in Palestine, under the direct control of a member of the Smaller Actions Comite, which shall be competent to advise on schemes of work in that country, and whose recommendations, when approved by congress, or (between two congresses) by the Greater Actions Comite, shall have an absolute claim on the support of all Zionists. 2. An increase in the Smaller Actions Comite, which must include representatives of Palestine and of the Russian Zionists. 3. The establishment of the headquarters in some centre of Jewish life. 4. The assignment to each member of the Smaller Actions Comite of the duty of superintending a definite branch of Zionist work. 5. The strengthening of the Greater Actions Comite in such a way as to enable it to represent and enforce the views of the mass of Zionists in the intervals between Congresses.