The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 6 · June 1910
214printed page
scan 28 of 54
Facsimile · scan 28 of 54
Scan of p. 214
Text · transcribed from the scan

is any vitality in it. Dr. Magnes charged explicitly that there are no younger men and women to assume responsibility for the temple; that the young men and women are ignorant of Judaism, that they experience nothing of the joy of Judaism. that they are marrying outside the Jewish fold; that they have no self-respect, no pride of birth, no traditions, no hopes for their people; that the homes of the members are bare of piety and of the spirit of prayer. And what did this proud congreoation renlv ?

By advice of counsel, it refused to speak. By its silence it admitted the truth of Dr. Magnes's indictment and by its silence decided that it would not do anything to remedy the conditions. By its silence it abdicated as the leading Jewish congregation of the United States.

The opportunity was before Temple Emanu-El to give light and leading to the movement away from that form of radical Judaism which denies Jewish nationality and accepts as its basic principle a thoughtless adjustment to environment and a deliberate assimilation of alien ceremonies and symbols, thoughts and modes of life. Temple Emanu-El could have become the historic redeemer of American Judaism from the turbulent and unreligious anarchy that has been characteristic of Reform Judaism, so-called, in this country.

It will go down in the history of the Jews in America as the fearsome advance guard of the forces of assimilation. It might have strengthened Jewish ideals. It repudiated Jewish ideals by keeping silent when it should have spoken.

Dr. Magnes emerges out of the encounter with this wealthy congregation that boasts of its petty traditions, with greater power for good, with the confidence of every right-thinking Jew renewed and refreshed, with, we hope, a feeling of great-

er security and of greater freedom to do work for the cause of the Jewish people.

CALL FOR JEWISH SETTLERS IN PALESTINE.

The Young Turk, a Constantinople newspaper, makes a strong appeal to the government to take up the question of Jewish immigration:

"Turkey suffers at present from paucity of population, and under such a condition nothing could be done for our country. Very true, the country could be populated by Musselman farmers from Russia, India, and Bulgaria; but their immigration is very slow, and according to the latest census, their numbers are steadily decreasing; and so we are compelled to depend entirely upon the energy of the Jews.

“These people, coming here from countries where they are oppressed and persecuted, populate our deserted land and form peaceful inhabitants. If the Jews are interested in Mesopotamia their capitalists will surely come to our help. There is, in fact, no other remedy for the government, if it wishes to make good the constant deficieney of our budget. It should consider very earnestly the subject of settling Jews in the Ottoman Empire. The government should make a thorough study of the question.

"There is no doubt that the Jews would not only develop Mesopotamia but also Turkey and Palestine. If the government would be really in earnest, it could render the country a true and permanent service. We could greatly profit by the immigration of Jews, from their energy and culture, as well as from their leaders and their capital. Moreover, it is easy for us to draw the Jewish immigration to our country, as we are in possession of the magnetic point, namely, the Holy Land, which is holy to all believers, and to the Jews especially."