The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 5 · May 1910
179printed page
scan 29 of 52
Facsimile · scan 29 of 52
Scan of p. 179
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

EDITORIALS

WOLFFSOHN ON ZANGWILL.

Our readers will find much to entertain them in the address of David Wolffsohn, the chairman of the Smaller Actions Comite, which we print in full in this issue. They will also experience a feeling that Ar. Wolffsohn possesses more oratorical talent than many Zionists have given him credit for. Mr. Zangwill, who is one of the objects of his oratorical sarcasm, has forced this attack upon himself. He has been too voluble; and has too often overstepped the bounds of political sagacity in his numerous criticisms of Zionism. Had he gone ahead with his territorialist schemes, regardless of the Zionist movement, and continued in declaring, as he did at first, that he was a Zionist, but wanted a territory, he would not have aroused the justifiable anger of Zionist leaders in Europe, who now see in him one whose opinions are subject to partisan prejudices. Zangwill wrote not so many years ago a fascinating address on the Hirsch millions, which almost every Zionist has read, in which he ridiculed the efforts of the Hirsch committee in Argentine. He was an advocate of Palestine then. Now, without in the least undertaking an investigation of Palestine and without an endeavor to justify or explain his change of opinion, he condemns Palestine as useless, the Zionist movement as dead, and recommends an exodus to America.

Mr. Wolffsohn was justified in calling him to account. It is to be regretted that Mr. Wolffsohn employed Mr. Zangwill's own methods in discrediting him. It would have conduced to harmony if Mr. Wolffsohn had eliminated the many personal allusions that illuminate his address. But Mr. Zangwill is not the one who has the right to complain.

Mr. Zangwill is under the spell of imperialistic dreams. He sees things big, or he cannot see at all. We regret exceedingly that he has persisted in a course which makes almost impossible a reversal of his position and a further continuance of his services on behalf of the Jewish people. As a Zionist, the avant courier to those Jewish millionaires, who have Jewish sentiment and are only lacking in courage to accept the Zionist program, he has done incalculable service; but he vitiates the value of that service by needless attacks and ill-considered opinions that are inspired only by narrow, pettifogging notions of expediency.

THE PITTSBURG CONVENTION.

THE coming convention of the Federation of American Zionists will have a number of important questions to dispose of. We have reached a critical period in our growth, and it will require sober judgment and careful discussion to arrive at a correct line of policy to adopt for the organization of the movement in this country.

As matters stand now, we are confronted by anarchic conditions, loosely affiliated societies with vague responsibilities and a vaguer sense of discipline and order. It will be the business of the Pittsburg convention to decide whether there shall be a well-organized movement in this country, with a definite policy, or a continuation of the present aimless and ineffective disorganization which goes by the name of Zionist movement.

There should be a full and frank discussion among Zionists before the convention. Delegates should not come to Pittsburg with unformed and uninformed opinions. From now on until the convention let there be an animated discussion in our Zionist publication in order that the convention may know something of the task that confronts it. THE MACCABAEAN and Dos Viddishe Volk have their columns open for such a discussion