and every Zionist is urgently requested, if he has any thing of value to contribute to the discussion, to send it to either one of the publications controlled by the Federation. Without this discussion beforehand, we fear that the convention will not have the time to arrive at well-considered decisions.
DR. MAGNES AND TEMPLE EMANUEL.
THE sermon delivered by Dr. J. L. Magnes in Temple Emanu-El on the first day of Passover, a review of which appears elsewhere in this issue, was the principle event of the month. It was heard by a crowded synagogue, and has since been read by every Jew who is interested in the development of a healthy Jewish religion in this country, as well as by those who are intensely concerned in the religious development of Dr. Magnes, the courageous preacher and the devoted Zionist.
The sermon was long in preparing. For three years friends of Dr. Magnes saw it coming. It was the inevitable consequence of a condition of affairs that had in it all the elements of dramatic conflict, and it had to have a dramatic climax. Dr. Magnes could not remain any longer as the occupant of a divided pulpit, where sermons filled with hope for the Jewish people alternated with contradictory doctrine, preached, so it seemed, with persistent regularity to offset the more hopeful message. It was an anomaly, in the first place, that a congregation like Temple Emanu-El, should have selected a man like Dr. Magnes to preach for it. His known views were out of harmony with their known theories of life. They were aristocratic; he was democratic. He was a lover of Jewish things; they were averse to having any thing specifically Jewish intruded in their midst. He had hopes for the Jewish people; they had vague notions of the universality of Judaism, which meant colorlessness in Jewish religion and in Jewish life.
All that might have been endured; the
field was inviting to the missionary, and Dr. Magnes felt the inspiration of his mission. But the congregation was so intellectually indifferent, that it did not see the impropriety or the intellectual incongruity of having two preachers in their pulpit representative of the two extremes in Jewish life; the one intensely Jewish, the other intensely reformed. Knowing Dr. Magnes, the wonder is that he had the patience to continue in a pulpit where this unseemly conflict could be permitted, and where the congregation was so obtuse to the implications it raised as to their moral eenfiısıon.
Dr. Magnes remained, and was a witness to the harvest of officially reformed Judaism in this congregation, with its fine traditions, with its heritage of sterling Jewish preachers. He saw how by cutting off from the main body of Jewish life and by establishing an aristocracy of wealth, minus duties and religious fervor, minus hopefulness in a Jewish future, this gorgeous temple, with all its fine trappings, its fine traditions, was on the road to extinction. And seeing all this, he was bound, sooner or later, to express his criticism of the religion or lack of religion, which produced these conditions, and to advise with all the fervor at his command, a reform of reformed Judaism.
Dr. Magnes reveals in himself, in this incident and in many others, the inspiring influences of Zionist thought upon the character of men. The golus Jew is the Jew who sits in the padded pew in Temple Emanu-El. His outlook is not in the direction of Jewish life. He is perplexed and confused by the various alien currents of life, into which he cannot enter, and because he cannot enter them, and because he longs to do so, there is created in him a spiritual confusion, which drives out of him all consciousness of religion, the sense of obligation to posterity, and all the finer qualities which are invoked when one relies upon the “protection of the fathers.” They are bound to become vulgarians, just as the new-rich, aping the manners of the
