and form from the representable concepts of the national religions; for religion and state were one and inseparable. In our days such conditions are not sine qua non; and various distinctive schools of art have sprung up which borrow their precepts and concepts, some from laws of Aesthetics pure and simple, some from mere technical considerations, some from local conditions and traditions.
So a consideration of the possibility of the formation of a future distinctively Jewish art, need not be utopian. An interesting experiment is being tried to-day in Jerusalem. An art school has been founded there—to be sure a school of applied arts. but all art began that way—called the Bezalel, after the constructor of the Tabernacle of the Wilderness. It is under the direction of two of the group of East
European Jewish artists, Professor Boris Schatz, who was Antokolski's assistant and Ephraim Mose Lilien, perhaps the foremost distinctively Jewish illustrator of to-day. The school's object, and an eminent one, if only from an economic-sociological standpoint, is to propagate the domestic art industry in Palestine. But the special interest lies in the fact that the conditions which prevailed in the formation of primitive school of art will here obtain: A native if not national soil, a native language, for the teaching will be in pure Hebrew, and national ideals if not national surroundings.
It is not my province to prophesy, but I venture to state if ever there is to be a Jewish art approaching in distinctiveness and intensiveness, the great national schools on which all modern arts are based, such a Jewish art must arise from just such surroundings.
The Point of View of V. Stassov, Russian Art Critic
It has been recorded in most of the histories of art that notwithstanding all their talents and abilıties, the Jews have never given to the world any great painters or sculptors; that their very nature, their character, and their frame of mind, fornıulated in the course of many centuries, have acquired traits which are detrimental to creativeness of this sort. Nobody ever thought of denying the Jews their aptitude for science, for medicine, for music, for the art of actıng,. for industry, for commerce, but nobody had at the same time recognized in the Jews any qualifications for the plastic art. That is a strange and queer historical fatalism which deals out talents to some nations, and denies talents to others, as though man is not the same everywhere at all times, and as though certain moral or creative shortcomings were not merely the results of unfavorable and accidental circumstances which temporarily check the human genius in its growth and flight......
To repeat the absurdities about the inar-
tistic nature of the Jews is permissible to-day only to the blind and ignorant, or to those who are possessed of the same intolerance and fanaticism which people were wont to ascribe to the Jews themselves. Unfortunately, there are still many people like these among us.
During the second half of the Nineteenth Century, there came a time for research and discoveries in ancient Jewish art. And Israel stepped out of the darkness into the light, enriching us by thousands of new facts. The science of ancıent Jewish art, though but young. has already yielded rich fruit, and the museums of Paris and London have been adorned with new and interesting departments—the Jewish departments. There are characteristic models of sculpture, precious articles and ornaments. Are not all these creations of art? Is it possible to deny the artistic taste, the creative artistic power of the nation that has originated all this?......
At the present time the existence of Jew-