to establish herself as a nation, in view of the polytheistic peoples who constantly threatened her national existence which was bound up in her religion, again I hold Israel could not and did not found and foster a national art of her own.
But do not assume from this that Israel individually had no art. Archaeological re- - search and the undisputed talents of her descendants leave no doubt on that score. But the condition and circumstances at a given place and period even more than inherent talent determine the. existence of a natınnal art
A people that produced the poetry of the Bible, the paeans, the psalms, the fine frenzy of the prophets, the voluptuous yet chaste imagery of the Canticle of Canticles, possessed the dormant creative force to produce a great national art, but its dominant ideal determined otherwise.
With a strong love of the beautiful, with great manual skill, with a genius for conception and creation, Israel was yet forced to borrow the symbols of her successive conquerors for her own embellishment.
The long years of the Diaspora after the. disruption of Judea by the Romans found the Jews scattered over the whole of the then known world. Robbed of his national existence, hounded and dispersed in foreign lands and alien climes, hemmed in for long weary years behind the gates of the Ghetto, building walls himself around his religion and his customs to hold them inviolate against the inroads of his Gentile persecutors, the Jew had neither the heart nor the leisure to develop the fine arts. To be sure, he clothed his beloved Thorah in fine vestments, and ornamented it in cunningly chased gold and silver, and illumined his Hagadah and scrolls; but all this was of a composite art borrowed from the consummate art of his Gentile neighbors.
What has our age offered as Jewish art? Practically nothing. Jewish artists or rather artists who are Jews we have by the legion. And why should we not? Why should not a people that has assimilated the art inspiration of all the great nations of the world, in turn create?
Russia’s greatest sculptor, Antokolsky, was a Jew; Holland’s favorite painter, Josef Israels, is a Jew; one of the founders of the French school of Impressionists and its most genial exponent, Emile Pissaro, was a Jew; in every school of art, in every land, we find among the eminent painters and sculptors Jews; an Ezekiel, a Mosler, a Loeb in America, a Solomon J. Solomon in England, a Lieberman in Germany; but they are all artists who happen to be Jews or Jews who happen to be artists. The fact that nıost of them have painted or sculptured a work of art embodying a Jewish subject, does not make it Jewish art. Ismael Ghent has painted the Jew of the Orient with such sympathetic intuition and skill that he may be considered one of the best painters of Jewish subjects. And yet Ismael Ghent,— whose Christian name, so Hebraic in character, is but a reminder of the fact that his father, brush in hand, haunted the Orient before him, —this Ismael Ghent is a German Christian of noble lineage. Such a painter, as have most of the Jewish artists who have treated of Jewish subjects, has approached his subjects purely objectively. Tt is no more Jewish art than Daniel Deronda is Jewish literature.
And yet of late a new school has sprung up,—and it has come from the East,— which really bids fair to be Jewish art. They are the young painters and sculptors, mostly Galicians and Russians and Poles, who having been brought upon Hebrew lore in the reeking confines of the Ghetto, are depict- ting the Judenschmers they have felt and are feeling Their cuning hands have mastered the technique of their art, be it in Moscow or Munich, or Berlin or Paris, but the heart which inspires their brush or mal- let pulsates in Palestinee The wandering Jew in them pauses, not to portray his impressions of the foreign lands and stranger ceustoms, but to depict his own sufferings, his own Heimweh, his own aspirations, Such art is Jewish art; for it is subjectively Jewish.
In those earlier days, when the nations were still in a state of formation, distinctively national art could only take its feature