The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 4 · April 1907
135printed page
scan 17 of 52
THE MACCABAEAN.

‚ish art is undeniable. The old prejudice has disappeared. The Jews are no longer regarded as abnormal in art, as an exception among the nations. Nobody denied the aptitude for art even in the savages, even in the ancient barbarıans and the American Indians, while the Jews were regarded in that respect as some unimaginable monster, —they, whose history has been so rich, who have lived for centuries a life which was now a terrible and cruel tragedy, now full of the most picturesque and most beautiful poetry, now amidst unspeakable despotism, now ın pastoral meekness. Such traits and elements as these have never passed without leaving traces; they always cast their reflection, and left their imprints in creations of art, and even if we did not have’a single relic of Jewish plastic art, their grand and profound Iyric poetry alone, the relics of their sacred songs which have been preserved ın many of the religious melodies of Christianity, should have convinced us of the profound poetic and artistic aptitude of the Jewish people......

Erase or destroy the energetic Jewish activity in art, and Europe, and for that matter the entire world, would grow darker by many degrees. But there are people, not only among the masses, even among writers and journalists, who still cling to the traditional absurdity of trampling upon Jewish artistic creativeness and ridiculing it......

Together with the small but increasing group of Jews, who, with the painters of other nations, are seeking to give expression to their national feelings and their imagination in the forms of original art, you will ind many Jewish painters who have forgotten that they are Jews, and it seems as though they were doing their utmost to show to the world that there was nothing Jewish about them. The gifted Dutch Jewish painter,- Josef Israels, does not seem to have noticed the thousands of Jews in Holland, but he has made all efforts to secure the gold medal ior paintings representing Dutch peasant women and children, not for paintings that wauld represent the humble

Jewish home and the halt-starved Jewish children. The gifted French Jewish painter, Levy, devoted himself to portraying Catholic subjects, although he should have known that tiere would be many able French and Jesuit painters to paint these subjects.... Our own Antokolsky, more gifted than all these artists put together, received the first prize for his “Christ,” which is indeed a fine work. But his “Christ,” though represented for the first time ın Jewish grab, is not a Jewish but a weak, sentimental figure ın the manner of the general European conception. And that was the same Antokolsky who started out so splendidly with his deeply national “Inquisition,” “The Dispute Over the Talmud at the Inn,” his life-like “Jewish Tailor” and the “Jewish Miser.” His powerful, original subjects melted under the beautiful, but enfeebling rays of the Italian sun! What sad examples of treachery to their national flag, to their people! I do not know how others look upon it, but to me such colorless anti-national products of .art are aımless and disazreeable......

Why had this national idea remained so foreign to so many of the Jewish artists? Dnes Jewish nationalism seem to them still poor and insignificant? Or has it no types, has it no beauty of body and soul? Why then, did the great European painters think otherwise, both the old and the new, those that were really great and original? Look at Rembrandt, look at Knaus! These two painters of unequal greatness, Rembrandt, one of the greatest geniuses of the world, the other only a fine talent; yet both of them saw with clear eyes what rich material for artistic reproduction there was in the Jewish life about them, and they did more than once what the Jewish painters should have done......

Although I am not a Jew, I consider it interesting and important to examine the rights and duties of the Jewish artists and Jewish art. It seems that some non-Jew had:to do this work since the Jews did not do it themselves......