administration of a political movement, but we are not so sure but that there has already grown up a tradition strong enough to override all desire for change.
On the practical side London offers more facilities for the administration of the movement than Vienna; its tone is brisker, its methods quicker and its air far more realistic than Vienna. The average of results achieved by a London center should normally be larger than that possible in any continental city, but on the other hand the cost would be probably much larger. The administrative cost of a London bureau would be at least twenty-five per cent. higher than the present Viennese expenses, with a tendency to increase. London offers the advantage of absolute freedom and this is undoubtedly a most valuable consideration to a political movement.
We expect, however, to see the project for a London center opposed with great zeal, and perhaps some rancor. London is at present suspect Zionistically owing to its having been the point of departure for the British East African scheme. A fear is current that a London center might develop an African Zionism, and, though we regard that as an idle fear, some color has been lent it by the English insistence ou that project.
We have of design held our peace on that issue, holding that the matter will only be properly discussable when the commission now in the territory shall submit its report and this view seems to have the general support of the Zionists in the United States. The leadership and East Africa coming together complicate each other. The vote for the presidency is dependent on the East African vote, and vice-versa. The permanent movement is, however, of greater importance than the African incident and, therefore, we believe that the ensuing Congress should be rigidly divided into sections, that dealing with the general business of the movement, the other entirely devoted to the East African proposition. Precedence should, however, be given to the East African question. The Congress will in this way declare its policy, and the field will then be clear for the reorganization project, and the election of permanent officers. Zionism is a frank and open movement; no difficulty should be shirked, and no issue
avoided; and upon the policy of the movement the whole character of the organization must depend.
CLEARING THE AIR.
At a recent gathering of the Southern Rabbinical Conference it was made clear in the course of the discussions that Reform opinion is divided on the Zionistic question. The division is more considerable than we had reason to anticipate, but of more interest than the measure of that division is the character of the opposition. One Rabbi, whose opinion will not meet with general acceptance in Reform circles, i. e., M. P. Jacobson, of Shreveport, Ala., deserves credit for having reduced his anti-Zionism, which is of a violent kind, to its logical consequence.
Discussing the attitude of the synagogue or temple towards the immigrant he said, "Our present constitution as to charity would imply that in addition to being a religion we are likewise either a nation or a race." This is true. The real Jewish policy has always been secular, that is, national. But Rabbi Jacobson wants nothing of this. He cannot realize that our charity attitude is an historical result of our real condition. To him this is an abnormal phase of Jewish existence, one that misleads, and he would put a violent and complete end to it.
So "in this country of clear thought, free activity and free affiliation I maintain that our lines in Judaism should be drawn distinctly and strictly on our religious, or, if you will, our sectarian issues even, in the matter of charity, so that our communal charity be done exclusively through the synagogue and that the modern synagogue or reform synagogue do its charity directly only to its membership or only to that class of Jews as are known to accept and be in union with its principles and practise and frequent its worship; and similarly the ancient or orthodox synagogue be left to do directly all the necessary charity to its own easily recognized and openly avowed constituency, and that there be no trespassing of the lines."
This is fairly clear, but Rabbi Jacobson would have no mistakes made in his views,
