so he adds when the immigrant Jew comes here "finding charity done here among the Jews of our country only through the synagogue, he will have to determine to declare his religion, even his synagogal affiliation."
It is idle for some one to tell us that Rabbi Jacobson is rather an excitable man of extreme views, and only great in a small council, for the relative position of the man is of no great importance. He has given vent to a very clear idea; it is so honest that it will make many rabbis and congregations shudder, but it is thoroughly logical from the point of view of "Americans of the Jewish persuasion." The rabbi who wishes to be a Jew after his own heart, and change his doctrine with every one of its flutters, need not worry about the common heart of Israel. Its history and its
traditions are impediments to his mercurial progress, but at the same time he is wholly sincere when he asks the strange Jew what his views of doctrine are before he will commit himself to the task of supporting him.
That the majority of anti-Zionists will object to these views does not prove Rabbi Jacobson wrong. Their objections go to show that the anti-nationalistic attitude is, after all, a sham, a convenient but unrealized idea, and that in the urgent business of life the average Jew is just a Jew. We hope Rabbi Jacobson will give further publicity to his views. He is right as to the logic of anti-Zionism; he will aid us considerably in our work by driving thousands of people into the Zionist camp.
The Movement Abroad
NORDAU ON UGANDA.
In a letter addressed to an American contemporary, dated Paris, December 29, 1904, Dr. Max Nordau wrote as follows with reference to the Uganda proposition:
"Respecting the method to be employed in dealing with the Uganda problem, I agree with you in most points, as set forth in your able article of December 16. Provided the exploring commission sent out to the spot returns a favorable report, there would be no excuse for not taking advantage of the British government's generous offer. The Jewish people, in their present direful situation, cannot afford to refuse the gift of a considerable tract of good land.
"But the taking possession of Uganda is an affair of the whole Israel, not of the Zionists. In fact, all these can do is to treat with the British government to receive the charter and to hand it over at once to a company to be formed without delay, according to your suggestion, on the board of which Zionism may be represented by some members, without, however, this being a 'conditio sine qua non.'
"As to the funds, do not count for one moment on the slightest contribution from Zionists. Our capitals are tightly vinculated for other strictly-defined purposes, and individual Zionists are financially far too weak to keep going the political movement and at the same time to float a big organizing enterprise.
"If non-Zionistic Jews do not come forward with substantial aid in this emergency they alone will have to bear the responsibility for missing a splendid opportunity of helping on radically our poorest and most abandoned brothers."
BRITISH EMPIRE.
LIVERPOOL.—The annual conference of Zionist Societies was held in the Zionist Hall West Derby street, Mr. M. Blumfield, president of the Central Committee, presiding. Mr. H. Enbinder, honorary secretary, presented the annual report, in which reference was made to the present general condition of the movement, the differences over East Africa, and other matters, the conclusion being that despite everything
