The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 2 · February 1905
70printed page
scan 36 of 60
Facsimile · scan 36 of 60
Scan of p. 70
Text · transcribed from the scan

measure of franchise. The Russian Radicals stand in need of no such act to justify themselves; they are rising not to free the world, their idealism is usefully limited to their national purposes, and a thousand semi-cogent reasons might be found in Russia against anything like a general enfranchisement. In other words, it seems fair to asume that when the time comes the Russian constitutionalists will not go beyond a class franchise, in which the Jews could not be easily included without serious danger to the new state. History and the broad facts of the situation, should at least teach us as much, and experience should at least guide us beyond that to a definite conclusion as to the future of our people.

No doubt a lightening of the burdens would stay the present serious rate of emigration from Russia, and, moreover, some of the short-sighted would see in any measure of relief a promise of more emancipation, but those gifted with statecraft recognize that political freedom has been bitter fruit to the Jews in Europe, and that a century of freedom has produced a reaction. The equality of 1792 ended in the Dreyfus incident of 1894, and it is no pessimism, but a simple understanding of facts which teaches that like will produce like in other forms. To put it as plainly as we know how, if Russia gave the Jews the fullest imaginable measure of freedom today, there would at once ensue a species of competition between the higher Jewish intelligence and industry, and the lesser Russian intelligence and oriental Slavic sloth which would end in another struggle compared with which the present condition would be mere child's play.

As Jews seeking freedom we cannot but wish the Russians success in their efforts; every measure of liberty has its universal use though it be not universal in its application; but as Jews we feel that our future safety lies not in the gifts of those who struggle to be free, but in the emancipation we shall achieve for ourselves, and the existence of a free national Jewish home in which our people shall be their own masters.

THE INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATION.

Our continental colleagues are much exercised by the questions which will be submitted to the next Congress. The date of that important gathering has not yet been set, but some time at the end of July, or the beginning of August the delegates will assemble, without the presence and guidance of our beloved leader, Theodor Herzl. That will be the great overshadowing condition of that Congress, and all the discussion that is taking place follows upon that lamentable fact. With Herzl absent the whole question of leadership, organization and policy crops up in a natural form.

The leadership must solve itself. Leaders are born, not made. Men create their offices, offices do not create men, and constitutions must in practise always lag behind the individual. All, therefore, that the next Congress can undertake as an organized effort is to elect a president, who may or may not be the actual leader of the movement. On the other hand some one man may prove himself the man of the hour and the opportunity, and be leader by personal right as well as by office. We have capable men in our midst, but whilst Herzl lived he so overshadowed all our colleagues that on their past record it would be impossible to say who amongst the best men is the most fit for the supreme office, or has the individual force of leadership. We would, therefore, set all gossip on one side, leave the delegates free to elect whomsoever they find is equal to the emergency on the spot.

Pendant to the question of leadership is that of the international organization. In fact, it is one way of avoiding the leadership issue, but the point that has apparently roused the most interest is that of the future center of the organization. A good deal of propoganda has been made for the removal of the centre from Vienna to London. To us in America this seems a matter of second-rate importance, but judging from the articles in Die Welt it is an all-absorbing question with some of our German friends. Vienna was only made the center of the movement by reason of the fact that Dr. Herzl resided there, and he himself frequently looked to London as a centre more congenial than the Austrian capital for the