They are satisfied to know that somewhere or other a place is found whither the Jew may go, and they do not inquire too closely into the conditions, so long as these refugees do not come to be, as they allege, a burden and a danger to them. This is as far removed from Zionism as heaven from earth, and may have more untoward consequences than these self-preserved philanthropists imagine. Assuming that the Jews accept a hypothetical shelter in East Africa, every European Power might feel inclined to take advantage of England’s offer and force the Jews by the usual means to emigrate to that place. Every country might no longer hesitate to close the doors to Jewish emigrants, for they could and would point to the new country in East Africa as the only place where Jews, and specially poor Jews, could legitimately emigrate. So far, if the report should be a favorable one. But if the report of the Commission should be an unfavorable one, and I have not yet seen anyone competent to speak about that country, who has given me anything but an unfavorable report, then the damage worked will be ever so much greater. The high-flown expectations will give way to bitter disappointment. The poor, suffering people thrown from one extreme to the other will lose its balance completely; the double disappointment created by the leaders of the Zionist Movement, the impossibility of obtaining Palestine and the impracticability of settling in East Africa will produce profound despair; the people will lose hope in themselves and the belief in the future; the misery, great as it is now, will appear in their eyes tenfold greater then, for their ideals will be shattered, their supports undermined, their hopes lost. And as for the consequences which our enemies will draw from it, I need not dilate upon them. The position of the poor will be more difficult, and that of the others who have indulged in vain hopes will not be an envious one. There are shades and gradations even to misery.
These are some of the dangers resulting from the vote snatched from the delegates who were taken by surprise at the last Congress. It is, therefore, our bounden duty, that is, of all those who like me stand irrevocably on the basis of the Zionist programme and expect the salvation of our people only and exclusively on the soil of Pales-
tine, to protest against this resolution. It stands in direct contradiction to our principles. It is a negation of Zionism; it is a breach with our past and a danger to our future. A decision to seek Zion in East Africa cannot be binding upon us. We remain now, as before, stanch adherents to our hopes and ideals. We strive now, as before, to re-establish our home in Palestine in order to begin there a new life in Judaism, to break the spiritual and physical thraldom in which our people are still kept in the “Dispersion.” We wish to plant again the flag of Judah upon the walls of Zion. We wish to create a true gathering point for the scattered of our nation. We wish to lay the fiend of persecution and misery, and to send from the holy mountain the joyous message to mankind that a new era is dawning of freedom, of equality and of justice.
Mr. L. J. Greenberg, London Let us see what some of the objections to the East African plan are. In the first place, there is a fear that this colonization scheme will detract from our ideal in respect to Palestine. I really have never heard anything quite so absurd as that. For 2,000 years our people have been more or less—and more rather than less— under the iron heel of brutal persecution. They have suffered as no other people have suffered. They have been sent from pillar to post in most parts of the habitable globe. Where they have been allowed to settle they have for the most part been placed under grinding disabilities, or at most been allowed to bask but a short time in a clouded sunshine of prosperity.
But we find that to-day, in this twentieth century, with all its materialism, our people have never been more strongly imbued with a feeling of love for Palestine, a feeling of veneration for the ancient home of the Jewish race. Is it reasonable to suppose that because a settlement in East Africa is offered to a comparatively small number of our people, we are going to forget Jerusalem? I do not believe that anything of the sort will occur, and if I did I would not advocate the settlement. I believe that one of the first and most flourishing institutions that will arise in this new Judæa will be a strong Zionist Society, and I have not the slightest doubt that
