that Zionist Society, or bond or union, will not only be one of the most efficient and give great help to the movement, but will one day be composed of the best sort of Jews of the strongest, physically, mentally and morally, of any bearing allegiance to this free and blessed country.
Another objection raised to East Africa is this: Have you power to carry on both the Palestine and East Africa projects? Those who ask that argue against themselves; because they minimize the abounding love inherent in us for Palestine and ignore the fact that there will be always in our movement those who will give up their very lives for Palestine. But the question is not one for Palestinians only. We Zionists are apt to forget that recognized Zionists even to-day are only a small portion of Jewry. There may be a million Zionists, but there are twelve million Jews. This scheme for East Africa will, I am sure, attract a number of Jews who have till now held aloof from Zionism or any Jewish movement, except perhaps a charity here and there to which they have subscribed. If we can enlist those for our scheme for East Africa, if we can get them to help us with the plan, we shall have thrown out for them a bridge by which they will come over to us. Believe me it will not be long before they are thorough nationalists and thorough Palestinians. Then it is said that our movement is a Zionist Movement and not an East African Movement. I fully admit that, but surely you will not have a man put on the clothes which were fit for him when a child.
In the development of the Zionist movement circumstances around us and which we have not controlled have compelled us to extend the field of our operations. It has been shown to us, on the one hand, that Palestine is not immediately accessible to us, and, on the other, we see that the conditions under which we find ourselves demand that something shall be done to relieve the pressure under which Jewry finds itself, a pressure which I believe can best be relieved by establishing what will be a Jewish settlement under the freest and best Government that history has ever known. What in the main is our Movement, unless it is in the main a movement of Jewish nationalization? I have always held that our Movement, instead of
being called the Zionist Movement, should have been called the Jewish National Movement, for that it is in fact. We are Zionists because we are Nationalists; I hope none of us are Nationalists only because we are Zionists. And when I have said that this offer of the British Government is a large step toward Palestine, I have said so because it is a recognition of the national principle for which we have always contended. If the British Government had Palestine, we would now be negotiating with them for that country. The British Government has very practically recognized our claim to be a nation, when they say to us, "We will give you a tract of country which shall be Jewish, and a settlement governed by a local Jewish Government."
Now a number of Zionists and others have spoken and written about East Africa, and some of them have sought to excuse Dr. Herzl for having considered the British offer. They say the offer was made and Dr. Herzl could not have refused it without consideration, the least he could do being to submit it to the Congress. I utterly dissent from that view. I am convinced that if Dr. Herzl had thought that the offer was not in the interests of the Jewish people, or was of opinion that it was a retrograde step, then Dr. Herzl could, should and would have asked the British Government to excuse him from even considering their proposal. For my own part, I can say this, that if I had not seen that this project would be a progressive one, consistent with our best ideals, if I had felt it did not take us nearer to the goal of our hopes, I should not have urged Dr. Herzl to consider it or to submit it to Congress. I have never claimed to be a party man, cribbed, cabined and confined to the single idea of Palestine, rejecting all else outside the Zionist purview. I have always been anxious to do all I could and employ to the utmost our Movement for what is best for our people as a whole. And so when I saw there was a chance here of relieving some of the tension under which our people are suffering I urged Dr. Herzl to consider very seriously the British offer.
I share with him the view that the East Africa scheme is a good scheme. Let me point to some of the reasons why it may be of value to us. In the first place, it can be of great political advantage because it will be, as I
