most favorable calculation would not be capable of supporting more than 500,000 souls, has been offered to us for a Jewish settlement. I must leave for another article the answer to the question in general whether colonization in East Africa is possible, whether and in how far it will tend to alleviate the Jewish misery, whether all the arguments which are now advanced by people who have scarcely been to the trouble of studying the available material, will not turn out to be so many snares and delusions. Here I am dealing primarily with the question how far will it affect Zionism. If those who have urged upon the delegates of the Congress the acceptance of the proposal are earnest in their endeavors and true in their statements, then their activity in connection with the programme of the Zionist movement must come to an end. One cannot serve conscientiously two masters at the same time. They will have to devote themselves with all the energy and all the zeal at their disposal to make this venture a success. It will be impossible for them to spare time and energy for any work in Palestine; it is impossible for any human being, however eminent he may be, to carry two such undertakings on with the hope of success. If those, however, who urge the sending of a Commission to East Africa to consider this proposition, do not take the settlement seriously and, as is hinted by some, it is to be used for some ulterior diplomatic object, if they, therefore, anticipate and expect in consequence a negative report from the Commission, then they are playing a dangerous game with the noble-minded Government and they are committing a great wrong to the Jewish people, for whom they are preparing trouble and disappointment which they will not be able to overcome easily.
But this is not all. There are other circles which take a deep interest in the good or the evil report of this Commission, for let us ask whether this very magnanimous offer of England is absolutely free from political motives ? Why should the English Government, apparently of its own initiative, make such an offer to the Jews, and to foreign Jews, to boot? The modern practical politician knows very little of sentimentality. Without in the remotest degree doubting the magnanimity of the English Government or trying to min-
The Government could now submit to Parliament such restrictions as recommended by the Alien Commission, and yet show at the same time sympathy with the persecuted. By preserving its own interests in the country the Government still maintains a high standard of lofty humanitarianism, and helps the poor, persecuted people in a most magnanimous way. These undoubtedly would be satisfied to go anywhere, so long as protection was offered them together with liberty and safety. The emigrants from Russia, Roumania, etc., need therefore no longer come to England. A safe and free country had been offered to them under the mighty ægis of free and tolerant England. By such means the stream of emigrants would be deflected from England, and, indirectly, also from America. That explains how it came to pass that a representative of American Jewry who, as far as I can see, had not hitherto shown his Zionistic proclivities before this Congress, defended the acceptance of the English proposal with all his energy, for he understood its purport clearly. Representative American Jews, it is well known, are anxiously desirous of preventing the stream of Jewish emigrants from touching the soil of America and are at least as anxious as Jews elsewhere to turn it away as far as possible. They are afraid for their own political position; they do not mean to further Zionism by their action; it is simply a policy of self-preservation, though a short-sighted policy.
