which we preach and for which we work. Whatever the position may be which the Jew holds in the countries of Europe, he must, according to our teaching, with heart and soul think of the old home, of the old country; he must consider his sojourn among the nations as a fulfilment of God's threats and as a punishment for the sins of the past, but he must also listen all the while to that message, full of joy, which tells that, in the same manner as the punishment, also the heavenly promises shall be fulfilled and that we shall again be gathered into our old home, not under the form of charity, but through our own efforts to be reborn in Judaism and through Judaism. We do not yearn to return to the land of our forefathers for the purpose of establishing and building up a puny political State, or to establish a Jewish bureaucracy, but only and solely to be able to live there a full life as free human beings, and, above all, as God's own chosen people. There, where our tears of pain and woe have fallen, on the very same spot do we wish to weep for joy, and to see realized with our own eyes the promise of thousands of years.
That is Zionism. This is the center round which the Jews gathered, and that was the reason why they flocked together as in ancient times to hold friendly converse with their brothers, not for the purpose of ascertaining how funds might be raised for helping some poor and dejected scion of our race, but for the purpose of considering how we may be able to help ourselves, to realize our own future; how we may gather strength to break the fetters with which the nations have bound us, and how to reach that goal, when we may look proudly in the face of the nations in the name of Jews and Judaism. Jewish misery, the "Judennot" knows only Jewish beggars and looks to rich benefactors. Zionism knows only Jews, rich or poor makes no difference, it knows Jews who strive after the spiritual emancipation of our nation and hope to realize through it also its physical emancipation. We look for inspiration from above to illumine our hearts again with the ancient truths of our Law and our prophets; we expect new seers to arise in Israel. Our sages have told us in ancient times that the holy spirit rests only upon the inhabitants of the Holy Land, and it draws us thither with thousandfold cords.
A colonization of Jews undertaken by Zionists under the name of Zionism and carried out in a country outside Palestine is rank contradiction in itself; no fine phrases, no rhetorical ingenuity, no sophistical argument could eliminate or modify it. It is a complete breach with the ideal of Zionism, and it is an abuse of the name. The administrators of the fund of the I. C. A. would be justified, and perhaps more so than our New-Zionists, if they considered the work of colonization in Argentina as Zionistic work. They might claim to be the pioneers of the movement, and their work to be the preparatory steps toward its realization. To a certain extent, and from their point of view, they would be right, for at any rate they are carrying on practical work on the lines of colonization and they are rescuing thousands of people ground down by the persecution in Roumania and Russia, while East Africa is still a problem for the future. From my point of view all this is only temporary help, temporary rescue, just as distinct from the aims of Zionism as any other colonization work outside the Holy Land. It is temporary work without any guarantee for the future; for those who are saved from the fire of persecution and hatred carry often with them in their clothes gleaming sparks that can very soon be fanned into a flame by however slight a wind blowing in the new home in which they have been established.
Nor can anyone pretend that the establishment of a large colony outside Palestine is a strengthening of Judaism. History teaches us a wholesome lesson. The rich and powerful colony of Jews in Egypt in ancient times, far from strengthening Judaism, although living close to the borders of Palestine and under the influence of Palestine, produced only Hellenism. Geographically and spiritually they were within the sphere of the Holy Land, and yet were they a source of weakness and not a source of strength. The draining of the Jewish blood into one remote center like East Africa could only have as a consequence a failure of the heart. Our old poet, Jehudah Halevi, has already told us long ago that the Jewish heart lies in Palestine. We cannot hope for Jewish ideals in East Africa, and as for the preparation for independent autonomous life, surely our stay among the nations is the best school, for we are living
