The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 6 · December 1903
355printed page
scan 24 of 63
Facsimile · scan 24 of 63
Scan of p. 355
Text · transcribed from the scan

in the midst of the highest forms of civilization, and if we cannot learn the ways of administration from the pattern which is set us by these countries, especially England and America, we shall never be able to learn it among the negroes in the wilds of tropical Africa. From whichever point of view we look upon it, a colony in East Africa is alien to the aims and to the spirit of Zionism, and it should never have been promulgated from the height of the tribune of the Zionist Congress.

Psychologically one can easily understand the turn which events have taken. The two currents which I have tried to describe, the tendency to rescue from physical bondage and the tendency of spiritual emancipation, have had their representatives among the Zionists. They who dreamed of a Jewish State in the abstract and they who worked for the Jewish home in the concrete crossed and recrossed one another in the course of the development of Zionism, and for a time the latter were the driving force. Palestine and Zion could alone inspire the masses, an appeal to the hopes and yearnings of centuries could alone produce an imposing manifestation of Jewish enthusiasm and Jewish energy. At the moment, however, when it was seen, or alleged, that difficulties arose which everyone conversant with the facts must have anticipated, and which seemed to jeopardize the successful accomplishment of the plan for obtaining Palestine, at that very moment some of the lukewarm Zionists returned to their old love, and they who dreamed of a State pure and simple caught at the sharp edge of the sword like drowning men, without considering that they were cutting their hands thereby. To them Africa or Zion were one and the same; it had made no difference to them before where a Jewish State or what could be called a Jewish State would be, as long as such a "State" was only established. Excuses were made from all sides, some trivial, some cynical, some pathetic and some apologetic, but they cannot remove the impression which is deepening from day to day that anti-Zionism had taken the place of Zionism.

It is scarcely worth while to attempt the refutation of all the arguments which have been advanced in the midst of the fight and since, for the purpose of saving at least some

appearance of Zionism, if only for the eyes of the deluded masses. Still, with a few of these arguments I must deal. The one that a colony in East Africa was a stepping-stone, although it could not be denied that it was a long and roundabout way of reaching Palestine, I have already discussed. One might just as well say that if one travels around the world one is sure one day to reach Palestine. A Jewish colony in China as has been proposed by some, or in Manchuria, as it is said now to be the intention of Russia of establishing, would be equally satisfactory for the purpose.

The author of the famous expression Luftmenschen urges as an argument in favor of East Africa that it would be a "night lodging," or shelter. He can hardly have used the word seriously, for, unless our people are really "living in the air" they must touch ground somewhere, and what has our lodging among the nations been other than such a "night refuge," a temporary shelter, not knowing when lying down at night what the next morning would bring forth? Houseless, homeless, we have been constantly wandering from place to place in search of temporary lodgings. Not without reason does our literature speak of the "dark night of galuth" (finsterer goluss), of our sufferings and our humiliations! Out of that darkness into the sunlit country of our ancient home—into that sunlit country in which the eternal light of liberty shines! is the motto of Zionism. We have no right to undertake the experiment of new "night lodgings" for our people in East Africa. Shall we again sow our enthusiasm, our devotion, our energy in a field where the germ would be killed at once, into a place where, even before the attempt of settlement has been made, inimical voices have been heard disputing us in the right of settlement, and before a Jew has set his foot in the country he has already been declared to be "undesirable," to whom admittance should be refused?

Another argument used is, that it is high time to put a stop to the “scattering” of our nation, to end the dispersion. What ignorance on the part of our people! Does the “scattering” begin just now for the first time? Are we not living scattered through the world, and have we not been so for at least 2,000 years? And in spite of it we are