The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 6 · December 1903
353printed page
scan 22 of 63
Facsimile · scan 22 of 63
Scan of p. 353
Text · transcribed from the scan

rights and privileges. The Jews are persecuted, cramped and prevented by hostile legal and illegal measures from full physical and economical development. Assuming now, for argument's sake, that these measures were removed and the hostile legislation abolished, the barrier which separates Jew from non-Jew broken down, so that there should be no longer any difference between one and the other, then the Jewish Question as such would be solved; Jewish misery would come to an end and the whole problem would be settled.

But how about Zionism? Would Zionism, as understood by me and by all those who think like me, cease also? According to our belief, certainly not. To us Zionism means (Drang nach dem Osten) the desire of moving toward the East, the yearning for the old home in the East, the Holy Land, in order to reknit again the old bonds, to quicken the Jewish religious and national life, to realize the old hopes and yearnings; to begin a new life free from the yoke of the nations, unfettered, unshackled. In that way Jewish misery, nay, the whole Jewish problem would be brought to an end, but by different means. The first solution of the Jewish Question has, as a consequence, the dissolution of the Jews by a slow process of assimilation, however much people may refuse to subscribe to those consequences. The facts are too strong to allow even of the slightest doubt. In drawing these conclusions I am summing up the results of the development of Jewry during the last century. We witnessed then, it is quite true, a certain amount of revival among the Jews, but it was at the cost of Judaism; outside its tenets and teaching, it created would-be Jews, and even this spurt of revival has soon come to a stop. The other nations objected to an element which was neither Jewish nor non-Jewish. New measures were evolved for the repression of this element, and as a result we have to deplore to-day that Jewish misery, which has not only grown in the course of the last few years, but which is felt more keenly than before.

However great that misery may be, and no one who is acquainted with the facts can deny it, it has not yet reached those depths to which Jews were subjected at the end of the eighteenth century; we only resent the op-

pression and we feel the persecution with greater intensity because we have had the opportunity of learning the difference personally, the difference which is made between the Jew and the non-Jew. The contact was close for a time and the break is now felt as a personal loss, hence the desire of changing this state of things; and among other heroic measures some have come to the fantastic idea of a Jewish State. The leading idea in the establishment of such a State was to gather into one political unity Jews, i. e., such persons who were born as Jews, and who, living under persecution, were anxious to escape and to obtain the possibility of a free political and economical development. It is thus merely an attempt to solve the economical problem; it is neither bound up with the old tradition nor is limited to place or country, for it makes no difference to the promoters of that scheme where that place would be so long as a political entity would be brought into being. Jewish culture, Jewish spiritual life, are not considered at all. There is no room for our national hopes and wishes; their claims are ignored and pushed aside, and with a light heart the promoters of a "Jewish State" pass over the historical conditions of Judaism; and no wonder, for they had long ago lost their connection with the traditions of Judaism; the old tie had been broken long ago.

Such a solution as this would proceed from people, who, consciously or unconsciously, had already been assimilated, and could be proposed only to such people who, on the verge of starvation, would accept any means of rescue. The leading motive would, however, be charity, to act charitably. It is an offer of alms made by the Jew of the West who finds himself in a better position, to his less well-favored brother of the East. The form, or the name, in which that charity is offered is absolutely indifferent. It may be done in the name of a society or in the name of one charitable individual. It all comes to the same thing. "We desire to help you, but we personally do not want help." To see in this offer anything national or ideal, an object which would rouse the enthusiasm of the people and induce them to bring the greatest sacrifices, means to play with words, to abuse the confidence of the people.

But how different is Zionism, the Zionism