The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 5 · November 1903
297printed page
scan 20 of 56
Facsimile · scan 20 of 56
Scan of p. 297
Text · transcribed from the scan

the name of those of whom it may truly be said that “Hunger is their ruling passion . and starving the order of their day.” Allow me to test your patience just long enough to simply answer this question by another question. What would you have said; aye, what would the Jewish world at large have said; what would those very Jewish papers have said who have turned their books of English synonyms inside out in their attempts at an ill-informed outcry and acrimonious agitation against Zionists—what would all these have said if we had sullenly refused even to consider the proposition made so generously and so large-heartedly? What do you say to-night to a Jewish paper, the American Israelite in Cincinnati, which has this beautiful and kindly sentence in a recent editorial. “The scheme is simply a crazy one, and only the densest ignorance of everything that one called upon to act in such a matter ought to know can account for giving it an instant’s serious consideration.” All respect for the transcendant wisdom of the Israelite, of whom it may indeed be said as was said of a professor at a certain German university: “Der lieber Herr Gott weiss alles; aber der Herr Professor weiss alles besser.”

What will you say to the advice which has been so readily given, and which only recently has been voiced by a noble citizen of this town, with whom it is at all times painful to disagree, "That the Russian question (that is synonymous with the Jewish) must be fought out in Russia." Take up your morning newspapers, and as you comfortably sit at your breakfast tables, read how that question is now being fought out in Russia. What else could Dr. Herzl have done, what else could the great majority of the Congress have done, than act as they have? We know as yet very little about the land itself; we know next to nothing about its possibilities. How can we form an opinion one way or the other? What right have we before the world, what right have we before our suffering brethren, what right have we before our own consciences to refuse something about which we know nothing? We have agreed simply to send out a commission, which, as the spies of old, "Shall see the land as it is, whether it to be good or bad, whether it to be fat or lean, whether there

be wood therein or not.” We have committed ourselves absolutely neither one way nor another. When the commission shall have brought back its report, when we shall know whereof we speak, then will be the time to come to a decision. As we have acted in the past so shall we act in the future—not for one section of the Jews, but for our whole people. If, after careful examination and after mature deliberation, we shall find that the offer of the English government is one which in no way harmonizes with the Zionistic aspirations, we shall have done our part in examining into it, and it may be for others to carry the scheme to fruition. Whatever issue the work of the commission may have, we stand firm upon our ground, and we repeat again and again, the refrain

We shall remain Palestinians whatever course of action may be found necessary for the moment. All our religious and all our national aspirations center in the Holy Land; and we feel the noble pathos of the situation, and we appreciate the grandeur of spirit in the delegates from Kishineff who, at the Congress, voted yes upon the question of sending the commission, though coming from the scenes of blood and pillage. Shall we be more Zionistic than they?

I would fain have spoken to you a word regarding the letter of Minister von Plehve, which was published during the Congress; if only because it's significance also has been so wofully misrepresented. In a Jewish paper published in Chicago, and which for some time has run with the hare and hunted with the hounds, the promulgation of the letter is made the subject of a would-be powerful onslaught upon us by one of its regular contributors. It is made to appear that we are vaunting ourselves with the encouragement given to our cause in that letter, and we are once more charged with being the devil's advocates. It is hard to imagine how such a construction can be put upon its production at the Congress, or what word was said there which could give color to such a statement. Russia wishes to get rid of what she calls her surplus Jewish population; whether she is right or wrong is a question which it is useless to discuss even academically. She has the power to think as she does, and no protest and no arguing will